Summa Theologiae and Disputed Questions¶
Summa Theologiae et Quaestiones Disputatae de Potentia et de Veritate (c. 1256–1273)
Executive Thesis¶
Part V brings the entire Codex to its metaphysical and epistemological summit by uniting five foundational lectures from St. Thomas Aquinas’s Sententia super Metaphysicam (Books V, VII, and IX) with the systematic syntheses of the Summa Theologiae (Prima Pars, qq. 7, 12, 84, and 85), Quaestiones Disputatae de Potentia Dei (q. 7, a. 2), and Quaestiones Disputatae de Veritate (q. 10, a. 6). Whereas Parts I through IV charted the division of the speculative sciences, the apodictic structure of Euclidean demonstration, the psychological necessity of the spatial phantasm, and the physical ontology of the continuum, Part V grounds all of these doctrines in first philosophy. In Metaphysics V, lect. 9, Aquinas distinguishes real categorical being—contracted proportionally according to diverse modes of being (modi essendi) and predicating (modi praedicandi), with quantity following upon matter as the first intrinsic accident—from propositional being (esse as the verbal copula signifying the truth of judgment, illustrated by the falsity of the diagonal’s commensurability) and from the division of every category by potency and act (illustrated by the midpoint latent in potency within a continuous line). In Metaphysics VII, lect. 10–11, he resolves the Platonic-Pythagorean temptation to reduce geometric figures to pure numbers by establishing the hylomorphic analogy of mathematics: just as natural species require common sensible matter (flesh and bone) in their definition while abstracting from individual sensible matter, mathematical species such as the circle and the right angle dispense with sensible matter (bronze, stone, wood) yet require common materia intelligibilis (the continuum, lines, and surfaces) in their universal definition, while individual mathematical circles grasped in pure imagination are individuated by designated intelligible matter and posterior parts such as semicircles.
From the static definition of mathematical essences, Metaphysics IX shifts to the dynamic order of actuality and heuristic discovery. In Metaphysics IX, lect. 3, Aquinas defends real potentiality against Megarian necessitarianism and Protagorean relativism, establishes the modal law of conditional consequence alongside the impossibility of commensurability between the square’s diagonal and side, and formulates the genetic principle that the name and notion of actus (energeia) are first imposed upon sensible motion—what is first evident to us—and extended thence to higher actualities. In Metaphysics IX, lect. 10, this metaphysics of act yields the classical locus on constructive geometric discovery (inventio): geometers discover latent truths by dividing lines and surfaces (dividendo inveniunt), reducing potential constructions into act so that, once the side of a triangle is produced (Euclid Elements I.32) or the radius is drawn from the midpoint of the diameter to the circumference (Euclid Elements III.31), the necessary nexus becomes immediately manifest to one inspecting the figure (statim manifestum fit videnti dispositionem figurae). The systematic articles in Summa Theologiae I, q. 84, a. 6–7, q. 85, a. 1, and De Veritate q. 10, a. 6 supply the complete cognitive architecture of this insight: steering an Aristotelian middle course between Democritean materialism and Platonic-Avicennian extrinsicism, Aquinas demonstrates that phantasms serve as the materia causae and instrumental agent under the principal light of the intellectus agens, that actual understanding always requires conversio ad phantasmata to behold the universal nature in the particular exemplar, and that abstraction by simple and absolute consideration isolates mathematical quantity in materia intelligibilis communis without mendacity while implanting the habit of first indemonstrable principles.
Finally, Summa Theologiae I, q. 7, a. 1 and 3, q. 12, a. 4, and De Potentia q. 7, a. 2 crown the Codex with Aquinas’s existential metaphysics of ipsum esse. Contrasting the privative infinity of quantitative division—which approaches matter and underpins the geometer’s operational linea infinita—against the formal perfection of unreceived act, Aquinas declares that esse itself is most formal of all (maxime formale omnium) and, in the celebrated formula of De Potentia q. 7, a. 2, ad 9, the actuality of all acts and on account of this the perfection of all perfections (actualitas omnium actuum, et propter hoc perfectio omnium perfectionum). Because the human intellect can consider in abstraction what it knows in concretion (ST I, q. 12, a. 4, ad 3), resolving concrete composites into both form and esse, it grasps diverse proportional modes of being and affirms objective existential and formal nexuses in judgment. As Peter Hoenen S.J. demonstrated across La théorie du jugement d’après St. Thomas d’Aquin (1946) and De Noetica Geometriae (1954)—paralleled by Bernard Lonergan‘s Verbum (1967)—and as the GEOMETOR ecosystem realizes computationally across geometor.model, geometor.explorer, and geometor.divine, geometric construction in act is the privileged arena where human intelligence experiences pre-judgmental insight into necessary nexus within intelligible matter before sealing that discovery in rational judgment.
Key Scholastic & Mathematical Concepts¶
Latin Term |
English Rendering |
Primary Locus |
Doctrinal & Geometric Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
Modi essendi / modi praedicandi |
Modes of being and modes of predicating |
|
Establishes that ens is not a genus contracted by extrinsic differences, but analogically diversified into ten categories proportional to real modes of inherence, with quantity following intrinsically upon matter. |
Esse ut veritas propositionis |
Being as propositional truth |
|
Distinguishes the existential and categorical act of being in reality from the copulative est formed by the composing and dividing intellect to signify that an affirmation or negation—including mathematical impossibility or privation—is true. |
Materia intelligibilis communis et individualis |
Common and individual intelligible matter |
|
Defines substance insofar as it underlies pure continuous extension apart from sensible qualities: common intelligible matter (the continuum, lines, surfaces) enters universal geometric definitions, whereas individual intelligible matter individuates particular diagrams in imagination. |
Circulus mathematicus vs. circulus aeneus |
Mathematical circle vs. bronze circle |
|
Illustrates why sensible substrates (bronze, wood, stone) are excluded from geometric essences, yet plurality of equal lines and similar circles in pure phantasia proves that mathematical objects retain individual intelligible matter. |
Actus ex motu derivatus |
Actuality derived from sensible motion |
|
Explains why the name and intelligible conception of actus (energeia and entelecheia) originate from local and qualitative motion—the actuality most manifest to sense—and are analogically extended to immutable forms, intellectual operations, and esse. |
Inventio per divisionem in actu |
Geometric discovery by division in act |
|
Reveals the heuristic mechanism of constructive geometry: drawing auxiliary lines and circles actualizes divisions previously latent in the continuum’s potency, making demonstrative middle terms immediately visible in the diagram. |
Linea infinita geometrae |
The geometer’s infinite line |
|
Clarifies that Euclidean geometry never posits an actually infinite magnitude, which would violate the terminating nature of figura, but uses ‘infinite line’ operationally for an arbitrarily extensible finite segment. |
Resolutio concreti in abstractione |
Resolution of the concrete in abstraction |
|
Identifies the distinctive mark elevating intellect above sense: whereas sight perceives nature only as this concrete singular, created intellect resolves composites so as to consider both concrete form and concrete esse in abstraction. |
Materia causae / agens instrumentale |
Matter of the cause / instrumental agent |
|
Synthesizes sensory empiricism and intellectual immateriality: phantasms act as secondary, instrumental causes supplying determinate structural content, while the intellectus agens acts as principal cause conferring actual intelligibility. |
Conversio ad phantasmata |
Turning to the phantasms |
|
Demonstrates that even after abstracting habitual intelligible species, the embodied human intellect must turn to exemplar phantasms to inspect the universal nature existing in the particular—the exact psychological law governing mathematical diagrams. |
Abstractio per simplicem considerationem |
Abstraction by simple and absolute consideration |
|
Vindicates the truth of mathematics against Platonic hypostatization: considering quantity and figure without considering sensible qualities involves no false judgment of separation, because the mode of understanding follows the knower rather than the mode of material existence. |
Ipsum esse, actualitas omnium actuum |
Being itself, the actuality of all acts |
|
Establishes esse not as an empty genus or minimal substrate, but as the ultimate formal perfection actualizing every substantial and accidental form, contracted by quidditative potency in creatures and subsisting unreceived in God. |
Table of Contents¶
Being Itself as Most Formal of All; the Geometer’s Infinite Line; Apprehending Absolute Being
[I q. 7 a. 1 arg. 1] We proceed thus to the first article. It seems that God is not infinite. For everything infinite is imperfect, since it has the character of part and of matter, as is said in Book III of the Physics. But God is most perfect. Therefore He is not infinite.
On the Origin of Science from Sensible Things, Turning to Phantasms, and Threefold Abstraction
[I q. 84 a. 6 arg. 1] We proceed thus to the sixth article. It seems that intellectual knowledge is not received from sensible things. For Augustine says in the Book of Eighty-Three Questions that the pureness of truth is not to be expected from the senses of the body. And he proves this in two ways. In one way, from the fact that everything that bodily sense reaches is changed without any intermission of time, and what does not abide cannot be perceived. In another way, from the fact that all things that we sense through the body, even when they are not present to the senses, nevertheless leave us subject to their images, as in sleep or frenzy; yet by the senses we are unable to discern whether we are sensing the sensible objects themselves or their false images. Now nothing can be perceived that is not discerned from the false. And thus he concludes that truth is not to be expected from the senses. Now intellectual knowledge is apprehensive of truth. Therefore intellectual knowledge is not to be expected from the senses.
That Esse Is the Actuality of All Acts and the Perfection of All Perfections
[q. 7 a. 2 arg. 1] For Damascene says in Book I of On the Orthodox Faith: That God is, indeed, is manifest to us; yet what He is according to substance and nature is altogether incomprehensible and unknown. Now one and the same thing cannot be both known and unknown. Therefore the being of God and His substance or essence are not the same.
Whether the Human Mind Receives Knowledge from Sensible Things and on First Indemonstrable Principles
[q. 10 a. 6 arg. 1] For between things that do not share in matter there can be neither action nor passion, as is clear through Boethius in the book On the Two Natures and through the Philosopher in the book On Generation and Corruption. Now our mind does not share in matter with sensible things. Therefore sensible things cannot act upon our mind so that any knowledge from them should be impressed upon our mind.