Summary — Being Itself as Most Formal of All; the Geometer’s Infinite Line; Apprehending Absolute Being

Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of ST I, q. 7, a. 1 & 3; q. 12, a. 4

Argument Summary

These three articles from the Prima Pars establish the metaphysical polarity between quantitative limitation and subsistent esse, together with the abstractive power of created intellect. In Question 7, Article 1, Aquinas distinguishes imperfect material infinity (formless indeterminacy) from perfect formal infinity, proving that because ipsum esse is most formal of all (maxime formale omnium), God as unreceived subsistent being is infinito-perfect, whereas figure is the quantitative boundary terminating extension. In Question 7, Article 3, he proves that neither a natural body nor an actually imagined mathematical body can be infinite in magnitude because every actual mathematical body must have a terminating figure, explaining that the geometer’s ‘infinite line’ means only a finite line extensible or subtractable as needed, and that quantitative infinity belongs solely to division toward matter, never addition toward the formal whole. In Question 12, Article 4, he maps the hierarchy of cognitive powers to modes of being and demonstrates in the third reply that because the human intellect can resolve concrete composites to consider form and esse in abstraction, it possesses a natural openness to being elevated by grace.

Key Theses

  • Matter is perfected and made finite by form, whereas form’s amplitude is contracted by matter; because ipsum esse is most formal of all, unreceived subsistent esse is supremely infinite and perfect.

  • No mathematical body can exist in act without some figure (figura), which is the form of quantity enclosed by boundaries; hence an actually infinite magnitude is impossible both physically and mathematically.

  • When the geometer postulates ‘Let this line be infinite,’ he requires no actually infinite line, but only an actually finite line from which as much may be taken as demonstration requires; quantitative infinity exists solely in potential division toward matter.

  • Unlike bodily sight, which grasps nature solely in concrete singularity, created intellect resolves what is concrete so as to consider both form and esse in abstraction (per modum resolutionis cuiusdam).