Summary — That Esse Is the Actuality of All Acts and the Perfection of All Perfections¶
Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of De Pot. q. 7, a. 2
Argument Summary¶
Addressing eleven incisive objections against the identity of essence and esse in God, Aquinas constructs a rigorous causal and metaphysical demonstration. Because all created causes, despite differing in their proper specific effects (fire generating fire, a builder building a house), concur in one universal effect—causing esse—that common effect must derive from the highest universal cause whose own proper nature is esse itself. In the replies, Aquinas deploys the distinction between substantive esse and propositional esse (Metaph. V.9) to explain how we know that God is without knowing what He is (ad 1); distinguishes ens commune (abstraction without precision, open to addition) from esse divinum (subsistent purity excluding all addition, ad 6); distinguishes id quod significatur from our concrete modus significandi (ad 7); explains why ‘God is’ is self-evident in itself—like Every whole is greater than its part—yet demonstrable quoad nos (ad 11); and crowns the article in ad 9 by proclaiming hoc quod dico esse to be the actuality of all acts and the perfection of all perfections, determined by quidditative natures not as potency by act, but as act by potency.
Key Theses¶
Whereas Damascene’s statement that ‘that God is, is manifest to us’ refers to propositional esse conceived by the intellect from effects, God’s substantive actum essendi is identical with His essence and exceeds natural comprehension.
Common being (ens commune) abstracts without excluding further determination, whereas subsistent divine esse is individuated by its sheer unreceived purity, excluding any possible addition.
What Aquinas calls esse (hoc quod dico esse) is the actuality of all acts (actualitas omnium actuum) and the perfection of all perfections: no form is understood to exist in act unless esse is posited, and esse is limited by essence as act is contracted by potency.
Like the axiom Every whole is greater than its part for one ignorant of the term ‘whole,’ the proposition ‘God is’ is per se nota secundum se yet requires quia demonstration quoad nos because God’s quiddity is not directly known to us.