Summary — That No Particular Science Demonstrates Its Own Proper Principles, Which Belong to First Philosophy¶
Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of Lib. I, lect. 17
Argument Summary¶
Aquinas here establishes that genuine propter quid demonstration requires proper and proximate principles belonging per se to the subject-genus, not merely true and immediate common axioms. He illustrates this failure of generic proximity through Bryson’s sophistical squaring of the circle (tetragonismus): Bryson argued that wherever there exist something greater and something less (circumscribed and inscribed squares around a circle), there exists something equal, and hence a square equal to the circle. Because equal, greater, and less transcend the genus of circle and rectilinear polygon—applying equally to numbers, times, or weights—Bryson’s argument yields at best per accidens knowledge rather than per se geometric causation.
Addressing the objection from subalternate sciences—such as harmonics (music) proved through arithmetic, or optics (perspective) and mechanical arts proved through geometry—Aquinas distinguishes knowing that (quia) in the lower science from knowing the reason why (propter quid) in the superior mathematical science to whose subject-genus the middle term essentially belongs. From the dual fact that particular sciences cannot demonstrate from common axioms alone and yet their proper principles presuppose higher common truths, Aquinas deduces a monumental architectural conclusion: no particular science (neither geometry nor arithmetic) can demonstrate its own proper principles; that office belongs to first philosophy (metaphysics), which studies being qua being and the common principles of all sciences as its own proper domain.
Key Theses¶
True and immediate common premises do not suffice for science unless joined to proper principles proximate to the subject-genus.
Bryson’s attempted quadrature of the circle fails as a geometric demonstration because its middle term (greater, less, and equal) transcends the proximate genus of circular and rectilinear magnitudes.
In subalternate sciences (harmonics under arithmetic, optics and mechanics under geometry), the lower science knows the that (quia) while the pure mathematical science knows the reason why (propter quid).
No particular science can demonstrate its own first proper principles; their ultimate validation belongs to first philosophy (metaphysics), which treats being universally.