Summary — On the Three Elements Required in Every Demonstrative Science: Subject-Genus, Proper Attributes, and Common Axioms

Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of Lib. I, lect. 18

Argument Summary

Synthesizing the relationship between proper and common principles, Aquinas sets forth the canonical triad governing every demonstrative science. First, distinguishing principles from derived theorems (ea quae sunt ex principiis), he notes that while both require nominal or quidditative understanding (quid significent), mathematics supposes the existence (quia sunt) of its primary subjects—the unit and magnitude (points and lines)—whereas it demonstrates the existence of derived constructs and attributes, such as the equilateral triangle, the right angle, and the straightness of a constructed line. Second, reconciling the use of common axioms with the prohibition against generic kind-crossing, Aquinas explains that common conceptions of the mind are employed in each science according to analogy (secundum analogiam), contracted proportionally to its subject-genus: geometry restricts subtracting equals from equals to equal magnitudes, while arithmetic restricts it to equal numbers.

Illustrating proper principles and proper attributes across arithmetic, geometry, and astronomy, Aquinas highlights arithmetical attributes (even, odd, square, cubic) alongside rich Euclidean geometric attributes: rational (commensurable) versus irrational or surd (incommensurable) lines measured against a given reference line, as well as the deflected and the curved. Every demonstrative science therefore revolves around three things: the subject-genus (genus subiectum), the common axioms (communes dignitates), and the proper attributes (passiones)—even when a science omits express mention of one because it is already manifest to reason (like number) or to sense.

Key Theses

  • Mathematics supposes both the meaning and existence of primary subjects (unit, magnitude, points, lines) while demonstrating the existence of constructed figures and proper attributes (equilateral triangle, right angle, rational and surd lines).

  • Common conceptions of the mind enter into particular sciences according to analogy, contracted proportionally to continuous magnitudes in geometry and discrete numbers in arithmetic.

  • Every demonstrative science necessarily rests on three pillars: the subject-genus, the common axioms (communes dignitates), and the proper attributes (passiones).

  • A science may omit explicit formulation of manifest presuppositions (such as the existence of number or familiar common notions), yet all three elements remain naturally presupposed.