Summary — Whether in Divine Things Imagination Must Be Altogether Relinquished (Why Mathematical Judgment Terminates at the Imagination)¶
Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of q. 6, a. 2
Argument Summary¶
Six objections contend that even divine science must be led back to the imagination (ad imaginationes deduci): Sacred Scripture clothes divine truths in sensible metaphors; Aristotle teaches in On the Soul that the soul never understands without a phantasm (phantasma); Dionysius declares that the divine ray shines upon us only through sacred sensible veils; God is known from sensible effects; phantasms regulate our intellect as colors regulate sight; and cerebral injury impedes contemplation even of divine things. Counter-authorities from Dionysius’s Mystical Theology, Augustine‘s On the Trinity, and Boethius‘s Consolation warn that reducing spiritual realities to corporeal images is the fountainhead of metaphysical error.
Aquinas resolves the tension by introducing a foundational epistemological distinction between the beginning (principium) of cognition, which pertains to apprehension, and its term (terminus), which pertains to judgment where truth is completed. In the present life, all human cognition begins in sense and depends continuously upon the phantasm—not as a transient ladder discarded after abstraction, but as a permanent foundation (permanens ut quoddam fundamentum) in which the intellect inspects its objects either positively or negatively. Yet the terminus where judgment is verified differs radically across the three sciences: in natural philosophy, judgment must terminate at sense (terminari ad sensum), conforming to sensory manifestation; in mathematics, because definitions abstract from sensible matter while retaining imaginable dimensive quantity, judgment must terminate at the imagination (terminari ad imaginationem) and not at sense—for a mathematical straight line touches a sphere at a single indivisible point, surpassing any sensible ruler and bronze sphere; and in divine science, judgment terminates neither at sense nor at the imagination, employing phantasms solely as starting points via Dionysian causality, transcendence, and negation. Methodological ruin ensues whenever thinkers attempt to apply a uniform criterion of verification across physics, mathematics, and metaphysics.
Key Theses¶
Every human cognitive act must be analyzed according to both its principium (apprehension, originating in sense and phantasm) and its terminus (judgment, where truth is verified).
In the present state of life, the phantasm remains a permanent foundation (permanens fundamentum) of intellectual operation across all sciences, analogous to first principles in demonstration.
Physical judgment terminates at sense (ad sensum), because sensible qualities and motions belong intrinsically to the definitive nature of natural bodies.
Mathematical judgment terminates at the imagination (ad imaginationem) and surpasses sense, verifying exact geometric relations—such as point-tangency between line and sphere—in pure spatial intuition.
Metaphysical judgment terminates in the pure intellect alone, employing sense and imagination strictly as points of departure via causality, excess, and negation without ever judging divine things to be imaginable.