Commentary & Notes — Whether in Divine Things Imagination Must Be Altogether Relinquished (Why Mathematical Judgment Terminates at the Imagination)¶
Aristotelian Sources, Euclidean Counterparts, Hoenen’s Noetics, and GEOMETOR Significance
Aristotelian & Scholastic Foundations¶
Question VI, Article 2 brings Aquinas’s theory of scientific judgment to completion by uniting On the Soul III.7–8 (431a16–b2, 432a8–14: the soul never understands without a phantasm, and phantasms stand to the intellective soul as sensible objects to sense), On the Heavens III.7 (306a5–17, where Aristotle rebukes the Platonists for forcing physical elements into geometric polyhedra in defiance of sensory observation, insisting that physical science must terminate at sensory appearance), On the Soul I.1 (403a12–16, alongside Metaphysics III.2, 997b35–998a4, refuting Protagoras’s cavil that a straight ruler touches a bronze sphere across a sensible expanse rather than at a point), and Pseudo-Dionysius’s On the Divine Names and Mystical Theology (the triplex via of causality, eminence, and negation).
Euclidean & Classical Geometric Counterparts¶
Aquinas’s concrete example in co. 3—that a mathematical straight line touches a sphere at a single indivisible point alone, whereas a physical ruler touches a material sphere along an extended patch—corresponds directly to Euclid‘s Elements III.16 (a straight line drawn at right angles to the diameter of a circle from its extremity falls outside the circle and touches it at one point alone) extended stereometrically to the sphere (as in Theodosius’s Sphaerica I.3). By distinguishing what external sense perceives in rough bronze or chalk from what constructive imagination exhibits under the governance of a definitive notion (ratio diffinitiva), Aquinas explains how Euclidean diagrams function in proof: the geometer never measures chalk thickness with empirical calipers (ad sensum), but judges exact point-incidence and tangency by terminating judgment at idealized spatial imagination (ad imaginationem).
Hoenen’s De Noetica Geometriae & Judgment Theory¶
Chapters III and IV of Hoenen‘s De Noetica Geometriae (1954) constitute an extended philosophical commentary on the exact doctrine of q. 6, a. 2, co. 3 and ad 6. Examining Aristotle‘s and Aquinas’s response to Protagoras on tangent lines and angle sums (In III Metaph. lect. 7, no. 416; In I Anal. Post. lect. 42, no. 7; ST I, q. 84, a. 6–7), Hoenen demonstrates how terminari ad imaginationem avoids both empiricist skepticism (which denies exact points and lines because sensation is coarse) and Platonic or Hilbertian formalism (which severs geometry from spatial intuition altogether). Because the phantasm remains a permanent foundation (permanens fundamentum, ad 6) illuminated by the agent intellect, the geometer inspects within imaginative extension itself the exact indivisibility of limits and necessary incidence relations, verifying universal geometric judgments in constructive intuition.
GEOMETOR Constructive & Symbolic Significance¶
Aquinas’s twin theses in Question VI, Article 2—that the phantasm abides as a permanent foundation (permanens fundamentum) of intellectual insight, and that mathematical judgment terminates at the imagination (terminari ad imaginationem) rather than at coarse empirical sensation—define the exact synergy between geometor.model and geometor.explorer. Whereas floating-point CAD or dynamic geometry software reduces tangency and intersection to numerical pixel tolerances (ad sensum, where a tangent line and circle may blur or miss due to rounding error), geometor.model adjudicates every incidence according to its exact definitive notion in SymPy symbolic algebra—verifying, just as Aquinas writes in co. 3, that a tangent line meets a circle at a single exact algebraic point—while geometor.explorer renders luminous SVG diagrams and animations as precision visual phantasms in which the human intellect directly inspects and contemplates the intelligible structure of the construction.