Summary — Whether Divine Science Treats of What Exists Without Matter and Motion

Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of q. 5, a. 4

Argument Summary

Eight objections argue that divine science cannot treat realities wholly separated from matter and motion: human reason reaches God only through visible material effects (Romans 1); Scripture, Augustine, and Plato speak of divine wisdom or the First Mover as self-moving; angels move by choice and local mission and seem hylomorphically composed since they are not pure act; metaphysics studies ens and substantia, which encompass material beings, matter, and motion; metaphysics demonstrates through efficient and final causes, which imply motion; and revealed theology treats creation and human moral acts.

Aquinas resolves the question by analyzing the nature of principles. Unlike incomplete intrinsic principles (such as the unit of number or the point of a line, studied solely within the science of their principiates), universal causal principles of all beings are also complete, subsistent natures maximally in act, and therefore wholly free of matter and motion. Such divine realities admit a twofold theology: philosophical theology (metaphysics), whose proper subject is ens in quantum est ens and which reaches God and the separate Intelligences from sensible effects as the extrinsic principles of its subject; and the theology of Sacred Scripture, which receives divine self-revelation through faith and treats God himself directly as its proper subject. Crucially, Aquinas distinguishes two senses of separation from matter and motion secundum esse: positive immateriality, where a nature can never exist in matter (God and angels), and negative or neutral immateriality, where a ratio does not depend on matter in being and can exist either with or without matter (ens, substantia, actus, potentia). In the replies, Aquinas refutes universal hylomorphism by distinguishing act-potency composition (esse and essentia, quo est and quod est) in incorruptible angels from matter-form composition, and explains why metaphysics demonstrates via efficient and final causality whereas mathematics—abstracting only in thought—does not.

Key Theses

  • Incomplete principles (such as unit and point) belong solely to the science of their principiates, whereas complete subsistent principles of all being admit both causal philosophical inquiry and self-revealing theological science.

  • Philosophical theology (metaphysics) has being insofar as it is being as its subject and treats God and separate substances as the universal principles of its subject.

  • Separation from matter secundum esse is twofold: positive exclusion of matter (God and angels) and ontological neutrality toward matter (ens, substantia, potentia, actus).

  • Created spiritual substances are free of hylomorphic matter-form composition, yet remain composed of essence (quod est) and received act of being (quo est, ipsum esse).

  • Unlike mathematical entities, which are separated only in consideration and therefore exclude efficient and final causes, metaphysical principles subsist in reality and exercise efficient and final causality.