Summary — On Action and Passion and the Division of Being into Ten Categories Proportional to Modes of Predicating

Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of Phys. III, lect. 5

Argument Summary

Commenting on Aristotle‘s dialectical investigation into where motion resides relative to mover and moved, Aquinas demonstrates that action (the act of the active principle) and passion (the act of the passive principle) are numerically one and the same continuous motion residing in the mobile subject, yet formally distinct in intelligible definition (ratio). If action and passion were two distinct motions, either motion would reside in the unmoved mover or a single mobile would undergo two simultaneous motions toward the very same specific terminus—both of which are impossible. Conversely, identifying action and passion in subject does not entail that teaching is identical in definition with learning or that every agent undergoes change: just as the road from Thebes to Athens and the road from Athens to Thebes, or an abstract spatial interval taken between opposite endpoints, is one in reality (secundum rem) yet two in directed notion (secundum rationem), so the single continuous motion is action insofar as it proceeds from the agent (ut ab hoc) and passion insofar as it is received in the patient (ut in hoc).

To answer how a merely conceptual distinction within one motion can ground two distinct categories of real being—and how motion can simultaneously belong to quantity, quality, and where—Aquinas unfolds his celebrated systematic derivation of the ten Aristotelian categories. Being is not divided univocally like a genus into species, but analogically according to diverse modes of being (modi essendi), which are strictly proportional to modes of predicating (modi praedicandi). Predicating what pertains to the essence yields substance; predicating what inheres intrinsically yields quantity (on the part of matter, furnishing intrinsic length, breadth, and depth), quality (on the part of form, including geometric figure founded upon lines and surfaces), or relation (an intrinsic respect toward another). Finally, predicating by extrinsic denomination yields action and passion (from external efficient causality), when (from time as extrinsic measure), where and position (from place and the order of parts in place), and having (from external instruments fashioned by human reason). Materially considered as an imperfect act in nature, motion reduces to the category of its terminus (quantity, quality, or where); formally apprehended as a medium between potency and act implying cause and effect, it grounds the categories of action and passion.

Key Theses

  • Action and passion are numerically one continuous motion residing in the mobile patient, distinguished formally as act proceeding from the agent (ut ab hoc) versus act received in the patient (ut in hoc), analogous to one spatial interval traversed in opposite directions.

  • Being is divided into the ten categories not univocally, like a genus into species, but analogically according to diverse modes of being (modi essendi) that are proportional to modes of predicating (modi praedicandi).

  • Intrinsic inherence generates the categories of quantity (consequent upon matter and providing intrinsic dimensional measure), quality (consequent upon form, with figure founded upon quantitative lines and surfaces), and relation.

  • Extrinsic denomination by cause and measure generates action and passion (from efficient causality), when (from temporal measure), where and position (situs, adding the order of parts in place), and having (habitus).

  • Motion as an inchoate reality in nature reduces to the category of its terminus (quantity, quality, or where), whereas as a transition from potency to act apprehended between two terms it grounds the categories of action and passion.