Summary — On the Definition of Immobile Place from Local Translation and Themistius’s Solution¶
Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of Phys. IV, lect. 7
Argument Summary¶
Having established Aristotle‘s definition of immobile place as the innermost immobile surface of the containing body, Aquinas confronts the classic cosmological and topological aporia of the outermost celestial sphere: since nothing exists outside the universe to contain it, how can the outermost sphere be in place, given that it manifestly rotates locally? Aquinas first rejects the hypothesis of self-subsistent three-dimensional void space interpenetrating corporeal dimensions as ontologically impossible. He then subjects four historical Peripatetic and Arabic solutions to rigorous critique: Alexander of Aphrodisias’s denial that the outermost sphere moves in place at all; Avicenna‘s claim that it moves in the category of position (situs) rather than where (refuted because every species of position consists in an indivisible configuration admitting no per se continuous succession, and moreover presupposes place); Avempace’s proposal that a circularly moving body is located by the convex surface of the inner sphere around which it revolves (violating the axioms that place contains and equals the located); and Averroes‘s contention that the outermost sphere is in place per accidens through the fixity of its central body (rejected as incongruous because the center is wholly extrinsic to the substance of the outer shell).
Aquinas decisively endorses the solution of Themistius, grounding it in the epistemological origin of the concept of place itself: place would never be sought save on account of local motion (translation), which reveals place through the succession of distinct bodies within one identical spatial bound. Whereas rectilinear translation requires one whole body to vacate a place and another whole body to enter it—demanding an external containing place per se for the whole—circular rotation preserves the whole body within the selfsame spatial region in subject while its parts continuously replace one another in subject around the circumference. Although the parts of a homogeneous continuum (illustrated by water rotating within a vessel) are not actually divided like a heap of contiguous stones, they are divisible and consecutive to one another around the circle, mutually containing and contained in potency. Thus the outermost sphere is in place per accidens by reason of its intrinsic parts existing potentially in place—a minimal, uniform mode of local variation uniquely suited to the first cosmic motion.
Key Theses¶
The existence and nature of place become known through local translation—the observed succession of distinct bodies occupying the same containing boundary—while self-subsistent three-dimensional space interpenetrating bodies is impossible.
Avicenna’s theory of per se motion in the category of position (situs) fails because each species of situs consists in an indivisible order of parts that admits no continuous succession of more and less apart from local motion.
Averroes’s claim that the outermost sphere is in place per accidens through the immobility of an extrinsic center violates Aristotle’s definition of per accidens location, which requires inherence or containment within what is located.
Following Themistius, circular motion does not require the whole rotating continuum to change place in subject, but only its parts to succeed one another continuously in the same spatial positions.
Unlike a heap of separated, contiguous stones whose parts are in place in act, a homogeneous circular continuum has parts that are consecutive and mutually containing in potency, placing the whole in place per accidens through its intrinsic parts.