Summary — How One Science Is More Certain and Prior to Another: The Unit Without Position and the Point Having Position

Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of Lib. I, lect. 42

Argument Summary

Following immediately upon his ranking of scientific certitude and priority by ontological simplicity—where arithmetic excels geometry because the unit is substance without position (unitas sine positione) whereas the point adds determinate position (punctus habens positionem, Lect. 41)—Aquinas in Lecture 42 establishes the lower boundary of scientific objects by excluding fortuitous events (a fortuna) and sensory particulars (per sensum). Chance events occur in a minority of cases (ut in paucioribus) and per accidens, whereas demonstration requires either a priori absolute necessity—characteristic of the mathematical disciplines (disciplinae), which are always true—or a posteriori conditional necessity from end and form (ut frequenter) in natural generation.

Turning to sense perception, Aquinas proves that because sensation apprehends sensible qualities inhering in a singular substance restricted to here and now (hic et nunc), it can never grasp the universal, which is always and everywhere—not positively as an eternal entity, but by way of negation or abstraction from determinate time and place. Even if we could visually perceive that a triangle has three angles equal to two right angles, or stood upon the moon observing the earth’s shadow during a lunar eclipse, we would perceive only a singular fact and still require demonstration to know the universal per se cause. Sense is nevertheless ordered to science—as illustrated by the hidden pores of transparent glass—insofar as repeated visual observations yield experience (experimentum), from which the intellect grasps the universal concerning all instances together.

Key Theses

  • Completing the hierarchy of exactitude anchored in the unit without position and the point having position, mathematical disciplines possess a priori necessity, whereas natural sciences possess conditional a posteriori necessity and fortuitous events admit of no science.

  • A universal is always and everywhere not by positive omnipresence, but by way of abstraction from every determinate here and now, placing it beyond the reach of sense.

  • Even direct sensory perception that a triangle’s angles equal two right angles, or standing on the moon to watch the earth’s shadow cause an eclipse, would not yield scientia without universal causal demonstration.

  • Sense serves science not by constituting scientific knowledge, but by supplying singular observations from which experience and intellectual universality arise.