Summary — On the Origin of the Habit of First Principles (Intellectus) from Sense, Memory, and Experience¶
Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of Lib. II, lect. 20
Argument Summary¶
In the crowning final lecture of the Posterior Analytics, Aquinas resolves how the first indemonstrable principles become known and by what intellectual habit they are held. Confronting the dilemma between innate Platonism (which absurdly posits hidden possession of a knowledge more certain than demonstration) and radical empiricism or skepticism (which cannot generate supreme certitude from total ignorance without pre-existing demonstrative knowledge), Aquinas traces a pre-existing cognitive power—innate sense—that is prior in the order of generation without surpassing principles in certitude. Across three grades of animal cognition, transient sensation leaves retained phantasms in memory, and in humans multiple memories compared by particular collative reason generate experience (experimentum). Ascending beyond particular experience, the intellect grasps the universal resting in the soul—one apart from the many in intellectual consideration, yet existing specifically in singulars—which serves as the principle of art (in things subject to generation) and of science (in necessary things such as numbers and geometrical figures), illustrated by Aristotle‘s famous simile of a routed army rallying soldier by soldier until a battle-line stands fast.
Crucially, Aquinas guards against sensualist reductionism: sense and memory never suffice of themselves to cause universal science unless the soul possesses both the possible intellect to receive universal intelligibles and the agent intellect to abstract universals from phantasms—enabled because sense apprehends Callias not merely as Callias, but implicitly as this man. Finally, comparing intellectual habits, Aquinas proves that because demonstration cannot regress infinitely, discursive scientia cannot know its own starting points; rather, understanding (intellectus)—the infallible habit of principles—apprehends first principles immediately and stands to them just as science as a whole stands to the entire body of demonstrated conclusions.
Key Theses¶
First principles are neither innate habits hidden in the soul nor conclusions deduced from higher science, but arise genetic-epistemically from pre-existing sense.
From sensation arises memory, from repeated memories compared by particular reason arises experience (experimentum), and from experience the intellect grasps the universal resting in the soul governing numbers and figures.
Sensory induction (inductio) yields universal principles only through the abstractive illumination of the agent intellect and reception in the possible intellect, grounded in sense’s implicit grasp of the common nature in the singular.
The habit by which first indemonstrable principles are known is understanding (intellectus), the infallible principle of scientia.