Summary — On Common Conceptions of the Mind, Hypotheses, Postulates, and Why the Geometer Does Not Demonstrate of Lines Drawn in Dust¶
Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of Lib. I, lect. 19
Argument Summary¶
Lecture 19 delivers Aquinas’s most penetrating analysis of axiomatic foundations and geometric idealization. First, he distinguishes common conceptions of the mind (communes animi conceptiones, dignitates) from hypotheses (suppositiones) and postulates (petitiones). While all principles are true per se, common conceptions must also necessarily be seen to be true per se by the natural light of inward reason (ratio interior): although a skeptic may deny non-contradiction in outward spoken words (voce), no intellect can inwardly conceive its opposite. Hypotheses and postulates, by contrast, are demonstrable truths assumed without middle terms within a given science and differ relatively to the learner: what seems probable to the student is assumed as a hypothesis, what meets neutral suspension of judgment is requested as a postulate, and what meets contrary opinion becomes a question requiring prior disputation.
Second, Aquinas proves twice that definitions (termini) are neither hypotheses nor postulates, since definitions neither assert to be or not to be nor predicate universally or particularly, requiring only intellectual comprehension. Within this proof, he resolves the famous objection that geometers argue from false hypotheses when calling an imperfectly traced mark in the dust (in pulvere) straight or one foot long: because geometry demonstrates exclusively of universals, the geometer demonstrates neither concerning nor from sensible lines, using them merely as sensible examples through which universal natures are understood. Finally, against Platonism, Aquinas concludes that eternal geometric demonstrations require no separated Ideas (unum extra multa), but only a universal nature existing one in many and predicated univocally of many (unum in multis et de multis).
Key Theses¶
Common conceptions of the mind (dignitates) command necessary assent from inward reason, whereas hypotheses and postulates are demonstrable principles assumed without proof within a science according to the learner’s disposition.
Definitions (termini) are neither hypotheses nor postulates because they signify quidditative meaning without asserting existence or universal/particular predication.
The geometer utters no falsehood in calling a line drawn in the dust straight or one foot long, for he demonstrates neither of nor from sensible particulars, using diagrams solely as exemplars of intelligible universals.
Apodictic geometric necessity requires no Platonic separated Forms (unum extra multa), but only univocal universals existing one in many.