Summary — On the Division of Per Se Being into Ten Categories and Being Signified by Propositional Judgment¶
Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of Metaph. V, lect. 9
Argument Summary¶
Commenting on Aristotle‘s philosophical lexicon (Metaphysics Δ.7, 1017a7–b9), Aquinas distinguishes ens per accidens (accidental predication across a common subject) from ens per se, which he subdivides into three fundamental orders: first, extramental ens perfectum contracted proportionally into the ten categories according to diverse modes of predicating that track diverse modes of being (correcting Avicenna‘s claim that accidental terms primarily signify substance); second, intramental esse signified by the verbal copula of propositional composition and division, which expresses the truth of a statement as effect to extramental cause (illustrated by privations like blindness and the negation of the diagonal’s commensurability with the side of a square); and third, the division of all categories by potency and act, illustrated by the statue of Mercury in stone and the midpoint latent in potency within a continuous line.
Key Theses¶
Being (ens) cannot be a genus contracted by extrinsic differences, because nothing lies outside being; instead, it contracts into the ten categories proportionally as modi praedicandi follow real modi essendi.
Quantity inheres in substance per se and absolutely as consequent upon matter, whereas quality follows upon form and relation regards another.
Propositional esse formed by the composing and dividing intellect signifies that a statement is true (quia aliquod dictum est verum), extending even to privations and mathematical impossibilities such as the incommensurability of the square’s diagonal.
Every category is divided by act and potency, just as every part of a continuum—such as the midpoint of a line—exists potentially in the whole prior to actual division.