Commentary & Notes — On the Division of Per Se Being into Ten Categories and Being Signified by Propositional Judgment

Aristotelian Sources, Euclidean Counterparts, Hoenen’s Noetics, and GEOMETOR Significance

Aristotelian & Scholastic Foundations

Aquinas’s exposition of Metaphysics Δ.7 (1017a7–b9) transforms Aristotle‘s compact lexical entry into a foundational treatise on analogical predication and the architecture of the categories (paralleled in In III Physicorum, lect. 5, in Part IV of this Codex). Against Parmenidean monism and Platonic univocity, Aquinas invokes Metaphysics B.3 (998b22) to prove that ens cannot be a genus, deriving the ten categories systematically from the triple relation of predicate to subject: essential identity (substance), intrinsic inherence consequent upon matter (quantity), upon form (quality), or toward another (relation), and extrinsic denomination by measure or causal principle/term. Equally decisive is his explicit refutation of Avicenna (Liber de Philosophia Prima III.2–4), who treated concrete accidental predicates like album as signifying substance primarily and quality secondarily; Aquinas insists that album primarily signifies quality in an accidental mode (esse est inesse), preserving the integrity of the nine accidental categories—chief among them mathematical quantity—as genuine modes of ens per se rather than collapsing them into ens per accidens.

Euclidean & Classical Geometric Counterparts

Two canonical Euclidean paradigms anchor Lecture 9’s distinctions of propositional truth and potentiality. In Marietti n. 895, illustrating how non esse signifies the falsity of a proposition, Aquinas explicates Aristotle‘s famous example (1017a34–35): to say that the diagonal of a square is not incommensurable with its side is to assert what is false—alluding to the Pythagorean-Euclidean proof (preserved in Elements X, Appendix 27, and implied by Elements I.47 and X.9) that the ratio of diagonal to side (√2 : 1) admits no common unit measure. Immediately afterward, in Marietti n. 897, illustrating ens in potentia across the categories, Aquinas cites the midpoint of a line (medium lineae) as existing potentially within the undivided line (Elements I.10 bisects a given finite straight line in act), noting explicitly that Aristotle places the line provisionally among substances in view of the Pythagorean-Platonic thesis not yet refuted in Book V.

Hoenen’s De Noetica Geometriae & Judgment Theory

In the Appendix to De Noetica Geometriae (1954) and throughout La théorie du jugement d’après St. Thomas d’Aquin (1946/1953), Peter Hoenen S.J. makes In V Metaphysicorum, lect. 9 (especially Marietti nn. 890, 895–896) the cornerstone of his distinction between the two operations of the intellect and the analogical diversity of esse. Hoenen highlights Aquinas’s guiding principle—quoties ens dicitur, toties esse significatur—showing that diverse modi essendi (substantial subsistence, quantitative extension, qualitative intensity, fluent motion) originate from the quidditative natures and relations affirmed in judgment. Furthermore, by contrasting real categorical esse (cause) with propositional est as the copula of truth (effect, Marietti nn. 895–896), Aquinas provides the exact textual warrant for Hoenen’s and Bernard Lonergan‘s (Verbum, Ch. 2) insistence that judgment is not a mere juxtaposition of concepts, but a reflective intellectual posit affirming (or denying, as in diagonal commensurability) the correspondence between mental synthesis and objective necessity.

GEOMETOR Constructive & Symbolic Significance

Aquinas’s dual analysis of diagonal incommensurability and the potential midpoint of a segment speaks directly to the symbolic foundations of geometor.model. In floating-point dynamic geometry software, commensurability and incommensurability are blurred into indistinguishable decimal approximations, obliterating the exact modal boundary that Aquinas highlights in Marietti n. 895. Because geometor.model represents every point, line, and circle in exact SymPy algebraic fields, the irrationality of √2 in a unit square or the golden ratio φ = (1 + √5)/2 in a golden section is preserved as an exact polynomial identity, allowing propositional queries over collinearity, concurrency, and commensurability to evaluate with strict Boolean truth. Likewise, before a bisecting circle-pair construction is executed in geometor.model, the midpoint of a segment exists only virtually—in potency—until explicit constructive steps reduce that point into actual algebraic coordinates within the model’s directed acyclic graph.