Summary — On Parts of the Form vs. Parts of Matter: Bronze Circle and Mathematical Circle in Intelligible Matter¶
Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of Metaph. VII, lect. 10
Argument Summary¶
Expositing Metaphysics Z.10 (1034b20–1036a25), Aquinas resolves whether the parts of a whole are prior to the whole and enter its definition. He distinguishes parts of the form or ratio—which are prior to the composite and belong to the universal definition—from parts into which the concrete whole divides as into matter, which are posterior. Thus the acute angle is defined through the right angle and the semicircle through the circle, not conversely. Crucially, Aquinas distinguishes universal composites (which include common matter) from singular composites individuated by designated matter—not only sensible singulars (bronze or wooden circles) but also mathematical singulars (plural equal lines and similar circles grasped by pure phantasia), which are individuated by materia intelligibilis (the continuum, surface, or body) and cannot be defined as singulars once they recede from actual inspection.
Key Theses¶
Formal parts belong to the quod quid erat esse and are prior to the defined whole, whereas material parts into which a figure is divided—such as the acute angle relative to the right angle or the semicircle relative to the circle—are posterior to the form and defined through it.
Definition belongs solely to the universal species, never to singulars, whether sensible (a bronze circle) or mathematical (this imagined circle), because matter in itself is unknowable save through the universal form.
Plurality within a single mathematical species—such as multiple equal lines or multiple similar figures—proves the existence of mathematical singulars apprehended apart from external sense by phantasia alone.
Intelligible matter (materia intelligibilis) exists in sensible things not insofar as they are sensible, but insofar as they are continuous magnitudes (continuum, surface, or three-dimensional body) underlying mathematical forms.