Summary — On the Division of Immediate Principles into Axioms, Hypotheses, and Postulates¶
Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of Lib. I, lect. 5
Argument Summary¶
To clarify what makes a principle immediate—namely, having no prior proposition or middle term through which its predicate is proved of its subject—Aquinas first distinguishes the demonstrative proposition from the dialectical problem and proposition. Whereas the dialectician asks for either side of a contradiction indifferently from probable opinion, the demonstrator determinately assumes the true part of a contradiction (an opposition lacking any intermediate in itself) as known. Aquinas then unfolds Aristotle‘s foundational taxonomy of immediate syllogistic principles into axioms (dignitates or maximal propositions) and positions (positiones).
Every immediate proposition is known through itself (per se nota) in itself because its predicate belongs to the intelligible nature (ratio) of its subject. When its terms—such as being, one, whole, and part—are known to everyone, the proposition is an axiom (dignitas), such as non-contradiction or the whole is greater than its part, received by all sciences from metaphysics. When its terms require technical definition not universally known—such as All right angles are equal, whose immediacy rests on defining a right angle via equal adjacent angles formed by one straight line falling upon another—or when a proposition is assumed in geometry though proved in natural philosophy—such as drawing a straight line from any point to any point—it is received by position. Subdividing position, Aquinas distinguishes hypotheses (suppositiones), which assert to be or not to be, from definitions (such as the arithmetician’s definition of the unit as indivisible according to quantity), which signify what a thing is without asserting existence, serving virtually as principles of demonstration.
Key Theses¶
Unlike the dialectician, who interrogates either side of a contradiction from probabilities, the demonstrator determinately assumes the true part of a contradiction.
Immediate propositions whose terms (being, whole, part) are universally understood are axioms (dignitates), evident both in themselves and to all learners.
Propositions immediate in themselves whose technical definitions are not universally known (such as All right angles are equal), or principles borrowed from another science (such as drawing a straight line between any two points), belong to positions and hypotheses.
Definitions are non-propositional positions that signify what a thing is (e.g., the unit as indivisible according to quantity) without asserting that it is, functioning virtually as syllogistic principles.