Summary — What Unqualified Scientific Knowledge Is and How Demonstration Proceeds from Primary, True, Immediate Causes

Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of Lib. I, lect. 4

Argument Summary

Beginning the treatise on the demonstrative syllogism proper, Aquinas explains why Aristotle constructs two linked definitions of demonstration: a formal-teleological definition taken from its end (to know scientifically, scire), which serves as the middle term proving its material definition taken from the required character of its premises. Setting aside sophistical knowing per accidens (such as knowing Coriscus approaching), Aquinas expounds Aristotle’s three conditions for knowing unqualifiedly (scire simpliciter): knowing the cause of the thing, knowing its actual application as the cause of that effect, and knowing with certitude that it cannot be otherwise. Demonstration is accordingly defined as a scientific syllogism (syllogismus scientialis)—one whose very possession constitutes scientific knowledge—which must therefore proceed from premises that are true, primary, immediate (lacking any prior middle term), better known than, prior to, and causes of the conclusion.

Manifesting each material condition, Aquinas illustrates the impossibility of knowing falsehoods through Euclid Book X: because to be and to be true are convertible, one cannot scientifically know that the diagonal of a square is commensurable (symmetrum) with its side, since they necessarily lack any common numerical measure. Finally, Aquinas harmonizes the Posterior Analytics thesis that demonstrative premises are prior according to nature rather than in relation to us (where sensible singulars come first) with Physics I: in natural philosophy, material essences are hidden from us so we frequently argue a posteriori from sensible effects, whereas in mathematics, owing to abstraction from sensible matter, demonstrations proceed purely from formal principles in which what is better known in relation to us is simultaneously better known unqualifiedly and according to nature.

Key Theses

  • Unqualified scientific knowledge (scire simpliciter) requires knowing the cause, its actual causal nexus with the effect, and the impossibility of the truth being otherwise.

  • Because being and being true are convertible, falsehoods—such as the commensurability of the square’s diagonal with its side (Elements X)—cannot be scientifically known, nor can science arise from false or unproved premises.

  • Demonstrative premises must be primary, immediate, causal, and naturally prior to and better known than the conclusion.

  • In mathematics, unlike natural philosophy, abstraction from sensible matter ensures that formal principles better known in relation to us are simultaneously better known unqualifiedly and according to nature.