Book VII · The Treasury of Analysis & Projective Lemmas

Μαθηματικὴ Συναγωγή Ζ΄ — Pappus of Alexandria, ed. Friedrich Hultsch (Vol. II, pp. 634–688, 868–894)

Note

Edition Track (English): Complete critical English edition of Book VII’s central historical and projective texts: the Preface to Hermodorus defining analysis and synthesis and cataloguing the 33 books of the Treasury of Analysis, the multi-line locus and Guldin centroid rule, the cross-ratio invariance lemma (VII.129), the complete-quadrilateral harmonic division lemma (VII.131), and the two hexagon collinearity theorems (VII.138–139). Switch tracks above for Greek (Hultsch 1877), Summary, or Notes.

ΠΑΠΠΟΥ ΑΛΕΞΑΝΔΡΕΩΣ ΣΥΝΑΓΩΓΗΣ Ζ΄
PAPPI ALEXANDRINI COLLECTIONIS LIBER SEPTIMUS

Author: Pappus of Alexandria (fl. c. 320–340 CE)
Addressee: Hermodorus
Critical Greek Edition: Friedrich Hultsch (Vol. II, Berlin: Weidmann, 1877, pp. 634–1020)
Latin Editio Princeps: Federico Commandino (Pesaro, 1588)

“That body of doctrine which is called the Treasury of Analysis, my son Hermodorus, is a specialized mathematical resource prepared for those who wish to acquire the power of discovering solutions to problems.”

—Pappus of Alexandria, Synagoge Book VII, Chapter 1


Table of Contents

Proposition 129: Cross-Ratio Invariance Across Central Projection /home/runner/work/pappus/pappus/docsrc/synagoge/book_07/prop_129_cross_ratio/index.rst:4: (INFO/1) Enumerated list start value not ordinal-1: “3” (ordinal 3)

Proposition 129 (Lemma III to Euclid’s Porisms): If from a single point $O$ four straight rays are drawn, and two transversals fall across them cutting them in points $A, B, C, D$ and $A', B', C', D'$, then the compound ratio of the whole segment and the middle segment to the extremes on the first line equals the compound ratio on the second line:

\[\frac{AC \cdot BD}{AD \cdot BC} = \frac{A'C' \cdot B'D'}{A'D' \cdot B'C'} \quad \Longleftrightarrow \quad \operatorname{CR}(A, B; C, D) = \operatorname{CR}(A', B'; C', D').\]
Emergent Harmonic Ranges in the Pappus–Steiner Configuration [ A0 B0 ]: -x - y + 1 = 0 [ A0 B1 ]: x - 1 = 0 [ A0 B2 ]: -3*x + 3*y + 3 = 0 [ A1 B0 ]: -x - 2*y + 2 = 0 [ A1 B1 ]: -3*x/2 - y + 3 = 0 [ A1 B2 ]: -3*x + 2*y + 6 = 0 [ A2 B0 ]: -x - 3*y + 3 = 0 [ A2 B1 ]: -3*x/2 - 2*y + 9/2 = 0 [ A2 B2 ]: -3*x + y + 9 = 0 [ A0 A2 ]: y = 0 [ B0 B2 ]: -2*x + 4*y - 4 = 0 [ M0110 M1221 ]: y - 1/2 = 0 [ M0210 M1122 ]: 4*x/3 + 4*y/3 - 20/9 = 0 [ M0011 M1220 ]: -36*x/11 - 20*y/11 + 84/11 = 0 [ M0211 M1022 ]: 36*x/35 + 44*y/35 - 12/5 = 0 [ M0012 M1120 ]: -36*x/35 + 4*y/35 + 12/7 = 0 [ M0112 M1021 ]: y + 3/2 = 0 [ S1 S2 ]: 2*x + 13*y/9 - 25/6 = 0 X1 = (5/3, 0) X2 = (7/3, 0) X3 = (25/12, 0) X4 = (-1, 1/2) X5 = (4/9, 11/9) X6 = (32/23, 39/23) X7 = (20/29, 39/29) X8 = (32/17, 33/17) X10 = (1/2, 1/2) X12 = (1, 12/5) X13 = (1, 12/11) X14 = (7/4, 3/4) X15 = (-1/2, -3/2) X16 = (101/62, 39/62) X17 = (32/13, -3/13) X18 = (32/19, 3/19) X19 = (49/23, -3/46) X20 = (5/3, 1/2) X21 = (3, -3/2) X22 = (28/15, -1/5) X23 = (36/17, 3/17) X24 = (51/25, 3/50) X25 = (15/8, 3/8) X27 = (147/82, 33/82) X28 = (-7/3, 4) X29 = (23/13, 12/13) X30 = (19/6, 1/2) X31 = (11/4, -3/4) X32 = (103/38, -33/38) X33 = (7/6, 1/2) X34 = (37/18, 1/2) X35 = (-4/3, 3) X36 = (16/9, 1) X37 = (25/6, -3/2) X38 = (3/2, -3/2) A0 = (1, 0) A1 = (2, 0) A2 = (3, 0) B0 = (0, 1) B1 = (1, 3/2) B2 = (4, 3) O = (-2, 0) M0110 = (1, 1/2) M1221 = (7/3, 1/2) M0220 = (3/2, 1/2) M0210 = (4/3, 1/3) M1122 = (8/3, -1) M0120 = (1, 2/3) M1220 = (24/11, 3/11) M0221 = (13/7, 6/7) M0211 = (8/5, 3/5) M1022 = (20/7, -3/7) M0012 = (8/5, -3/5) M1120 = (12/7, 3/7) M0112 = (1, -3/2) M1021 = (5, -3/2) M0022 = (5/2, -3/2) S1 = (31/18, 1/2) S2 = (19/6, -3/2) A0 A1 A2 B0 B1 B2 O S+ S−

Proposition 131: Complete-Quadrilateral Harmonic Conjugates /home/runner/work/pappus/pappus/docsrc/synagoge/book_07/prop_131_harmonic/index.rst:4: (INFO/1) Enumerated list start value not ordinal-1: “4” (ordinal 4)

Proposition 131 (Harmonic Division on a Complete Quadrilateral): Given three collinear points $A, B, C$, to find the fourth point $D$ on their line such that $(A, B; C, D)$ is divided harmonically—that is:

\[\frac{AC}{CB} = \frac{AD}{DB} \quad \Longleftrightarrow \quad \operatorname{CR}(A, B; C, D) = -1.\]
2023 GEOMETOR Parallel Configuration — Even Star Point S+ = (90/73, 38/73) [ A0 B0 ]: x = 0 [ A0 B1 ]: -x + 3*y/2 = 0 [ A0 B2 ]: -x + 5*y/2 = 0 [ A1 B0 ]: -x - y + 1 = 0 [ A1 B1 ]: -x + y/2 + 1 = 0 [ A1 B2 ]: -x + 3*y/2 + 1 = 0 [ A2 B0 ]: -x - 3*y + 3 = 0 [ A2 B1 ]: -x - 3*y/2 + 3 = 0 [ A2 B2 ]: -x - y/2 + 3 = 0 [ A0 A2 ]: y = 0 [ B0 B2 ]: y - 1 = 0 [ M0110 M1221 ]: -4*x/15 + 7*y/5 - 2/5 = 0 [ M0210 M1122 ]: -12*x/7 + 9*y/7 + 6/7 = 0 [ M0011 M1220 ]: -22*x/9 + 5*y/3 + 10/3 = 0 [ M0211 M1022 ]: 9*x/2 + 15*y/4 - 15/2 = 0 [ M0012 M1120 ]: -26*x/21 + 9*y/7 + 6/7 = 0 [ S1 S2 ]: -2660*x/219 + 640*y/73 + 760/73 = 0 A0 = (0, 0) A1 = (1, 0) A2 = (3, 0) B0 = (0, 1) B1 = (3/2, 1) B2 = (5/2, 1) M0110 = (3/5, 2/5) M1221 = (2, 2/3) M0220 = (15/11, 6/11) M0210 = (5/7, 2/7) M1122 = (2, 2) M0120 = (1, 2/3) M1220 = (5/3, 4/9) M0221 = (15/8, 3/4) M0211 = (5/4, 1/2) M0021 = (0, 2) M0012 = (0, -2/3) M1120 = (9/7, 4/7) M0122 = (9/4, 3/2) S1 = (90/73, 38/73) A0 A1 A2 B0 B1 B2 S+

Proposition 138: Pappus Hexagon on Parallel Carriers /home/runner/work/pappus/pappus/docsrc/synagoge/book_07/prop_138_parallel_hexagon/index.rst:4: (INFO/1) Enumerated list start value not ordinal-1: “5” (ordinal 5)

Proposition 138 (Pappus Hexagon on Parallel Lines): If two straight lines A0A2 and B0B2 are parallel, and upon them points A0, A1, A2 and B0, B1, B2 be taken, and their cross-joins A0B1 & A1B0, A0B2 & A2B0, A1B2 & A2B1 meet in points M01, M20, and M12, then these three points lie on a single straight line parallel to the original carrier lines.
Pappus's Hexagon Theorem (Synagoge VII.139) [ A0 B1 ]: -3*x + 2*y = 0 [ A1 B0 ]: -2*x - 2*y + 4 = 0 [ A1 B2 ]: -5*x + 4*y + 10 = 0 [ A2 B1 ]: -3*x - 3*y + 15 = 0 [ A2 B0 ]: -2*x - 5*y + 10 = 0 [ A0 B2 ]: -5*x + 6*y = 0 [ A0 A2 ]: y = 0 [ B0 B2 ]: -3*x + 6*y - 12 = 0 [ M01 M12 ]: -7*x/15 + 38*y/15 - 8/3 = 0 A0 = (0, 0) A1 = (2, 0) A2 = (5, 0) B0 = (0, 2) B1 = (2, 3) B2 = (6, 5) O = (-4, 0) M01 = (4/5, 6/5) M12 = (10/3, 5/3) M20 = (60/37, 50/37) A0 A1 A2 B0 B1 B2 O M01 M12 M20

Proposition 139: Pappus’s General Hexagon Collinearity Theorem /home/runner/work/pappus/pappus/docsrc/synagoge/book_07/prop_139_intersecting_hexagon/index.rst:4: (INFO/1) Enumerated list start value not ordinal-1: “6” (ordinal 6)

Proposition 139 (Hultsch II, pp. 886–889): Let two straight lines a and b meet at O, carrying three points A0, A1, A2 on a and three points B0, B1, B2 on b. If opposite cross-joins A0B1 & A1B0 meet at M01, A2B0 & A0B2 meet at M20, and A1B2 & A2B1 meet at M12, then the three points M01, M20, and M12 lie on a single straight line p.

Book VII · Analytical Summary & Invariant Audit

Analysis (ἀνάπαλιν λύσις): Assumes the sought proposition or construction as already accomplished, tracing implications backward until arriving at an admitted first principle, axiom, or known theorem. * Theoretical: Establishes truth. * Problematic: Constructs a sought geometric figure subject to a diorismos.

Book VII · Philological & Mathematical Notes

Of all the lost works of antiquity, Euclid’s three books of Porisms (Πορίσματα) have stimulated the greatest mathematical detective work (from Fermat and Halley to Simson and Chasles). Book VII of the Synagoge is our primary surviving source for the nature of a porism, preserving 38 preparatory lemmas.