Preface to Hermodorus · Analysis, Synthesis & Curriculum Summary

The Alexandrian Analytical Method

1. The Two Movements of Mathematical Reasoning

  • Analysis (ἀνάλυσις): The heuristic direction of discovery. Starts from the assumption that the goal is attained, proceeding step-by-step backward to known truths. * Theoretical analysis: Examines the truth value of a proposed theorem. * Problematic analysis: Ascertains the constructibility of a sought entity and determines its existence criteria (diorismos).

  • Synthesis (σύνθεσις): The formal direction of demonstration. Starts from the principles attained at the end of analysis and executes the Euclidean proof forward.

2. Structure of the 33-Book Analytical Canon

Author

Treatise

Books

Locus Genus

Euclid

Data

1 book

Plane

Apollonius

Cutting Off of a Ratio & Area

4 books

Plane / Determinate

Apollonius

Determinate Section & Tangencies

4 books

Plane

Euclid

Porisms

3 books

Projective / Invariance

Apollonius

Inclinations (Neuseis) & Plane Loci

4 books

Plane / Solid

Apollonius

Conics

8 books

Solid

Aristaeus

Solid Loci

5 books

Solid (Conics)

Euclid

Surface Loci

2 books

Linear (Surfaces)

Eratosthenes

On Means

2 books

Solid / Mesolabe