Book IV · Generalized Area Theorem & The Arbelos Circle Chain

Μαθηματικὴ Συναγωγή Δ΄ — Pappus of Alexandria, ed. Friedrich Hultsch (Vol. I, pp. 176–179, 208–232)

Note

Edition Track (English): Complete critical English edition of Book IV’s primary gems: Proposition 1 (the affine parallelogram generalization of the Pythagorean theorem) and Propositions 14–18 (the ancient shoemaker’s knife theorem on the infinite circle chain with $y_n = n\,d_n$). Switch tracks above for Greek (Hultsch 1876), Summary, or Notes.

ΠΑΠΠΟΥ ΑΛΕΞΑΝΔΡΕΩΣ ΣΥΝΑΓΩΓΗΣ Δ΄
PAPPI ALEXANDRINI COLLECTIONIS LIBER QUARTUS

Author: Pappus of Alexandria (fl. c. 320–340 CE)
Critical Greek Edition: Friedrich Hultsch (Vol. I, Berlin: Weidmann, 1876, pp. 176–303)
Latin Editio Princeps: Federico Commandino (Pesaro, 1588)

“And this theorem is far more universal than that proved in the Elements concerning squares on right-angled triangles.”

—Pappus of Alexandria, Synagoge Book IV, Proposition 1


Table of Contents

Synagoge IV.1 — Pappus's Area Theorem on Arbitrary Parallelograms [ D E ]: -4*x + 3*y - 13 = 0 [ F G ]: -4*x - 4*y + 43 = 0 [ H A ]: 4*x + y/4 - 13 = 0 D = (-2, 5/3) E = (1, 17/3) F = (37/4, 3/2) G = (21/4, 11/2) J = (13/4, 0) N = (7/2, -4) A = (3, 4) B = (0, 0) C = (7, 0) L = (1/4, -4) M = (29/4, -4) H = (11/4, 8) D E F G J N A B C L M H

Proposition 1: Pappus’s Parallelogram Generalization of the Pythagorean Theorem

If ABC be any triangle, and upon its sides $AB, AC$ there be described any parallelograms whatever, ABDE and ACFG, and the outer sides DE and FG be produced to meet at H, and HA be joined, then the parallelograms ABDE and ACFG together are equal in area to the parallelogram BCML contained by base $BC$ and lateral edges BL, CM equal and parallel to HA. “And this theorem is far more universal than that proved in the Elements concerning squares on right-angled triangles.”
Synagoge IV.14–18 — Pappus's Arbelos Tangent Circle Chain (y_n = n d_n) ( O0 A ): y**2 + (x - 3)**2 - 9 = 0 ( O1 A ): y**2 + (x - 2)**2 - 4 = 0 ( O2 D ): y**2 + (x - 5)**2 - 1 = 0 ( K1 X1 ): (x - 30/7)**2 + (y - 12/7)**2 - 36/49 = 0 ( K2 X2 ): (x - 3)**2 + (y - 12/5)**2 - 9/25 = 0 ( K3 X3 ): (x - 2)**2 + (y - 12/5)**2 - 4/25 = 0 ( K4 X4 ): (x - 15/11)**2 + (y - 24/11)**2 - 9/121 = 0 [ A C ]: y = 0 P3 = (2, 0) O2 = (5, 0) X1 = (36/7, 12/7) P1 = (30/7, 0) X2 = (18/5, 12/5) X3 = (12/5, 12/5) X4 = (18/11, 24/11) P4 = (15/11, 0) A = (0, 0) D = (4, 0) C = (6, 0) P2 = (3, 0) K1 = (30/7, 12/7) K2 = (3, 12/5) K3 = (2, 12/5) K4 = (15/11, 24/11) P3 O2 P1 P4 A D C P2 K1 K2 K3 K4

Propositions 14–18: The Ancient Theorem on the Arbelos Circle Chain

Let outer semicircle (O0, A) on diameter AC be divided at D into inner semicircles (O1, A) of radius $r_1$ and (O2, D) of radius $r_2$ ($R = r_1 + r_2$). Inscribe circles C1, C2, C3, C4, $\dots$ mutually tangent in the arbelos, and drop altitudes P1K1, P2K2, P3K3, P4K4 perpendicular to AC. Then for every $n \ge 1$, the altitude $y_n = |P_n K_n|$ equals $n$ times the diameter $d_n$ of circle $C_n$.

Book IV · Philological & Mathematical Notes

In Codex Vaticanus Graecus 218, Book IV begins abruptly with Proposition 1 without an address to Hermodorus or Pandrosion. Philologists (Hultsch 1876, Vol. I, p. 176) conclude that the introductory folio containing the dedication and table of contents was lost prior to the 10th century.