Proposition 139: Pappus’s General Hexagon Collinearity Theorem

Synagoge Book VII, Proposition 139 (Hultsch II, pp. 886–889, Lemma XIII to Euclid’s Porisms) · Critical English Edition

Crowning the lemmas to Euclid’s Porisms is Proposition 139, the general theorem of collinearity for opposite sides of a hexagon whose vertices lie alternately on two intersecting carrier lines. Pappus establishes the result purely through compound ratios (cross-ratio invariance) without drawing a single circle.

Pappus's Hexagon Theorem (Synagoge VII.139) [ A0 B1 ]: -3*x + 2*y = 0 [ A1 B0 ]: -2*x - 2*y + 4 = 0 [ A1 B2 ]: -5*x + 4*y + 10 = 0 [ A2 B1 ]: -3*x - 3*y + 15 = 0 [ A2 B0 ]: -2*x - 5*y + 10 = 0 [ A0 B2 ]: -5*x + 6*y = 0 [ A0 A2 ]: y = 0 [ B0 B2 ]: -3*x + 6*y - 12 = 0 [ M01 M12 ]: -7*x/15 + 38*y/15 - 8/3 = 0 A0 = (0, 0) A1 = (2, 0) A2 = (5, 0) B0 = (0, 2) B1 = (2, 3) B2 = (6, 5) O = (-4, 0) M01 = (4/5, 6/5) M12 = (10/3, 5/3) M20 = (60/37, 50/37) A0 A1 A2 B0 B1 B2 O M01 M12 M20
Proposition 139 (Hultsch II, pp. 886–889): Let two straight lines a and b meet at O, carrying three points A0, A1, A2 on a and three points B0, B1, B2 on b. If opposite cross-joins A0B1 & A1B0 meet at M01, A2B0 & A0B2 meet at M20, and A1B2 & A2B1 meet at M12, then the three points M01, M20, and M12 lie on a single straight line p.
step Set carrier a with A0 $= (0, 0)$, A1 $= (2, 0)$, A2 $= (5, 0)$ and carrier b with B0 $= (0, 2)$, B1 $= (2, 3)$, B2 $= (6, 5)$, concurring at perspective apex O $= (-4, 0)$.
step

Form the three opposite cross-join intersections of hexagon A0B1A2B0A1B2:

\[M_{01} = \left(\frac{4}{5}, \frac{6}{5}\right), \qquad M_{20} = \left(\frac{60}{37}, \frac{50}{37}\right), \qquad M_{12} = \left(\frac{10}{3}, \frac{5}{3}\right).\]
step By Proposition 129, projecting from A0 and A2 onto cross-joins A1B0 and A1B2 equates their four-point cross-ratios; since the two ranges share their apex A1, the joins connecting corresponding points concur, forcing M01, M20, and M12 onto the single Pappus line p ($-7x + 38y = 40$).

Permuting $(B_0, B_1, B_2)$ across all $3! = 6$ elements of $S_3$ (construct_pappus_configuration()) yields six Pappus lines that concur three-by-three by parity at Jakob Steiner's Star points S+ and S- along Steiner line:

The Six Pappus Lines and Two Steiner Star Points (S+, S-) [ A0 B0 ]: -2*x - y + 2 = 0 [ A0 B1 ]: -x + 2*y + 1 = 0 [ A0 B2 ]: -x/3 + 4*y + 1/3 = 0 [ A1 B0 ]: -2*x - 2*y + 4 = 0 [ A1 B1 ]: -x + y + 2 = 0 [ A1 B2 ]: -x/3 + 3*y + 2/3 = 0 [ A2 B0 ]: -2*x - 3*y + 6 = 0 [ A2 B1 ]: x - 3 = 0 [ A2 B2 ]: -x/3 + 2*y + 1 = 0 [ A0 A2 ]: y = 0 [ B0 B2 ]: 5*x/3 + 5*y - 10 = 0 [ M0110 M1221 ]: 2*x/9 + 4*y/3 - 22/27 = 0 [ M0210 M1122 ]: 18*x/65 - 8*y/65 - 34/65 = 0 [ M0011 M1220 ]: -16*x/21 + 32*y/21 + 128/63 = 0 [ M0211 M1022 ]: 18*x/77 + 4*y/77 - 38/77 = 0 [ M0012 M1120 ]: -48*x/95 + 128*y/95 + 64/95 = 0 [ M0112 M1021 ]: 6*x/7 + 16*y/7 - 2/7 = 0 [ S1 S2 ]: 10*x/13 - 5*y/13 - 115/78 = 0 A0 = (1, 0) A1 = (2, 0) A2 = (3, 0) B0 = (0, 2) B1 = (3, 1) B2 = (5, 1/3) O = (6, 0) M0110 = (5/3, 1/3) M1221 = (3, 1/9) M0220 = (25/9, 4/27) M0210 = (25/13, 1/13) M1122 = (9/5, -1/5) M0120 = (15/7, 4/7) M0011 = (4/3, -2/3) M1220 = (20/7, 2/21) M0221 = (3, 1/6) M0211 = (23/11, 1/11) M1022 = (15/7, -1/7) M0021 = (3, -4) M0012 = (20/19, -2/19) M1120 = (12/5, 2/5) M0122 = (0, -1/2) M0112 = (5/7, -1/7) M1021 = (3, -1) M0022 = (15/13, -4/13) S1 = (80/39, 7/26) S2 = (5/3, -1/2) A0 A1 A2 B0 B1 B2 O S+ S−