Summary — On Positional Directions in Natural Bodies and How They Are Considered by Position in Mathematical Figures

Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of De Caelo II, lect. 2

Argument Summary

Investigating whether positional polarities such as right and left belong intrinsically to the celestial sphere as the Pythagoreans claimed, Aquinas develops a rigorous ontology of directional orientation (differentiae positionum) across animate organisms, inanimate physical bodies, and abstract geometric figures. Drawing on On the Progression of Animals, Aquinas establishes that the three directional oppositions—above and below (governing length), right and left (governing breadth), and before and behind (governing depth)—belong per se and intrinsically only to living self-movers endowed with determinate organic parts from which vital motions originate: plants possess only above and below (with the root functioning organically as above by drawing nourishment), sessile animals add before and behind through sense perception, and locally mobile perfect animals possess all six directions. Furthermore, these three axes stand in a strict hierarchy both dimensionally (length precedes breadth and breadth precedes depth, just as line precedes surface and surface precedes body—since according to geometers a moving line generates a surface) and dynamically (above is the primary origin of growth and sensory command, before is the goal of sensory orientation, and right is the starting limb of locomotion).

By contrast, inanimate bodies and artificial or mathematical objects possess no intrinsic active principle of motion in one determinate part rather than another: heavy and light elements move uniformly from every side toward their natural center or periphery, while artificial and geometric figures lack internal self-motion altogether. Consequently, directional terms (above and below, right and left, before and behind) are predicated of inanimate things and geometric figures solely by comparison to us (per comparationem ad nos) in three relational modes: by direct alignment with our own sides (as in augury), by anthropomorphic likeness (as in a statue), or by mirror-image inversion (contraria positio, as in a specular reflection, where right opposes our left). This relational relativity is proved by rotational invariance: turning an inanimate object or geometric figure reverses its right and left relative to us, whereas an organism retains its intrinsic right and left under every rotation. Aquinas concludes by refuting the Pythagorean table of ten opposites for attributing right and left universally to all things while omitting the prior axes of above and below as well as before and behind.

Key Theses

  • The six directional differences (above and below, before and behind, right and left) belong intrinsically and per se only to animate bodies possessing internal principles of nutrition, sensation, and locomotion in determinate organs.

  • Dimensionally and genetically, above (principle of length) is prior to right (principle of breadth), and right is prior to before (principle of depth), mirroring the geometric priority of line to surface (where a moving line generates a surface) and surface to solid.

  • Inanimate bodies, artifacts, and mathematical figures possess no intrinsic directional polarity, because they lack determinate parts initiating self-motion; when rotated, their apparent right and left invert.

  • Positional directions are attributed to inanimate and geometric objects solely by comparison to us (quoad nos) in three ways: direct observer alignment, anthropomorphic correspondence (as in statues), and mirror-image inversion (in speculo).

  • The Pythagoreans erred both in projecting right and left onto all things via their moral table of ten opposites and in attributing right and left to the cosmos while neglecting the dimensionally and causally prior principle of above and below.