Summary — On the Twofold Foreknowledge (That It Is and What It Is) of Subject and Attribute: Unit and Triangle

Analytical Synopsis & Core Theses of Lib. I, lect. 2

Argument Summary

Expositing Aristotle‘s doctrine of foreknowledge (praecognitio), Aquinas analyzes both what must be known prior to a scientific conclusion and the order in which it is known. Because every demonstrative conclusion predicates a proper attribute (passio) of a subject through a principle, foreknowledge distributes asymmetrically across the two fundamental questions that it is (quia est) and what it is (quid est). Principles, being complex enunciations (such as the principle of excluded middle), have no quidditative definition and require foreknowledge solely that they are true. Proper attributes cannot have their inherence (quia est) foreknown—for proving their inherence is the very task of demonstration—so one foreknows of them only what is signified by the name (quid est quod dicitur). Primary subjects, such as the unit in arithmetic or lines and surfaces in geometry, require foreknowledge of both what they are and that they exist.

To explain why Aristotle illustrates nominal foreknowledge of a proper attribute using the triangle, Aquinas introduces a pivotal distinction between sciences of substance and sciences of accidents like mathematics. In geometry, primary elements of quantity (unit, line, surface) are presupposed exclusively as subjects; from them, composite figures such as the equilateral triangle and the square are first demonstrated to exist through quasi-operative demonstrations (quoting Euclid I.1), where the triangle stands as a proper attribute, before subsequently serving as a subject for further theorems. Finally, Aquinas distinguishes principles foreknown prior in time (the universal major premise that every triangle has three angles equal to two right angles) from truths known simultaneously in time yet prior in nature—as when recognizing this figure inscribed in a semicircle as a triangle immediately yields scientific knowledge of its angle-sum without any further middle term.

Key Theses

  • Demonstrative foreknowledge divides asymmetrically: principles require that they are true, proper attributes require what the name signifies, and primary subjects require both what they are and that they are.

  • In mathematical sciences of quantity, composite figures like the equilateral triangle and square first function as proper attributes proved to exist via quasi-operative constructions before serving as secondary subjects.

  • Whereas the subject is defined absolutely, a proper attribute is defined with essential dependence upon its subject, which supplies the middle term of demonstration.

  • When a singular or subordinate instance—such as a figure inscribed in a semicircle—is immediately recognized under its universal species, the minor premise and the demonstrative conclusion become known simultaneously in time.