Propositions 1–94 of Euclid’s Data¶
The ninety-four propositions of Euclid’s Data establish the constructive closure of Greek geometric analysis, progressing systematically across magnitudes, ratios, position loci, triangle species, area application with defect and excess, proportional figures, and circular chords.
Section 1
- order:
10
- type:
chapter
- canonical_id:
D.unit.1
- folio:
Menge pp. 4–42
- book:
Propositions 1–24: Magnitudes & Ratios
- description:
Deductive closure of given magnitudes and ratios over Elements Book V: addition, subtraction, inversion, composition, division, ex aequali chains, affine-linear offset relations (δοθέντι μεῖζον ἢ ἐν λόγῳ), non-singular linear combinations (D.22–D.23), and geometric mean proportions (D.24).
Magnitudes & Ratios (Propositions 1–24)¶
Pure Algebraic Closure of Given Magnitudes, Ratios, and Affine-Ratio Equations — D.1–D.24 (Simson I–XXVII) · Menge (1896) pp. 4–42
Note
Edition Track (English): Deductive closure of given magnitudes and ratios over Elements Book V: addition, subtraction, inversion, composition, division, ex aequali chains, affine-linear offset relations (δοθέντι μεῖζον ἢ ἐν λόγῳ), non-singular linear combinations (D.22–D.23), and geometric mean proportions (D.24). Switch tabs above for Greek (Menge 1896), Summary, or Notes.
- order:
12
- type:
summary
- canonical_id:
D.unit.1
- folio:
Menge pp. 4–42
- book:
Propositions 1–24: Magnitudes & Ratios
Magnitudes & Ratios (Propositions 1–24) — Analytical Summary¶
Unit Overview & Role in Greek Geometric Analysis¶
Deductive closure of given magnitudes and ratios over Elements Book V: addition, subtraction, inversion, composition, division, ex aequali chains, affine-linear offset relations (δοθέντι μεῖζον ἢ ἐν λόγῳ), non-singular linear combinations (D.22–D.23), and geometric mean proportions (D.24).
Scope: 24 propositions (D.1–D.24 (Simson I–XXVII), Menge pp. 4–42).
Analytical Function: Each proposition below compiles into a forward-chaining inference rule
Given(...) -> Determined(...)within Pappus's Treasury of Analysis (Synagoge Book VII) andgeometor.modelsymbolic DAGs.
Functional Overview (D.1–D.24 (Simson I–XXVII))¶
ID |
Simson |
Functional Signature |
Key Dependencies |
Tracks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Prop. I |
|
|||
Prop. II |
|
|||
Prop. III |
|
|||
Prop. IV |
|
|||
Prop. VI |
|
|||
Prop. VII |
|
|||
Prop. VIII |
|
|||
Prop. IX |
|
|||
Prop. X |
|
|||
Prop. XVI |
|
[Data Def. 9], [Data Def. 11], [Data 3], [Data 4], [Data 5], [Data 6], [V.18], [V.19] |
||
Prop. XVII |
|
[Data Def. 11], [Data 2], [Data 4], [Data 6], [V.12], [V.16], [V.18], [V.19] |
||
Prop. V |
|
|||
Prop. XXIV |
|
|||
Prop. XVIII |
|
[Data Def. 11], [Data 1], [Data 2], [Data 4], [Data 8], [V.12], [V.18] |
||
Prop. XIX |
|
[Data Def. 11], [Data 1], [Data 2], [Data 4], [Data 8], [V.19] |
||
Prop. XX |
|
|||
Prop. XXV |
|
|||
Prop. XXVI |
|
|||
Prop. XXVII |
|
|||
Prop. XXIII |
|
[Data Def. 11], [Data 1], [Data 2], [Data 4], [Data 8], [V.19] |
||
Omitted (cf. Prop. XVIII) |
|
|||
Prop. XI |
|
|||
Prop. XII |
|
|||
Prop. XIII |
|
[Data Def. 1], [Data Def. 2], [Data 1], [Data 2], [VI.13], [VI.17], [VI.22] |
Computational Primitives (geometor.model & SymPy)¶
D.1 (Prop. I): Exact symbolic ratio evaluation sp.simplify(A / B) from known magnitudes.
D.2 (Prop. II): Fourth-proportional solver B = A * (D / C) when homogeneous constructibility holds.
D.3 (Prop. III): Additive closure X + Y of constructible symbolic quantities.
D.4 (Prop. IV): Subtractive closure X - Y (with X > Y) of constructible symbolic quantities.
D.5 (Prop. VI): Conversio rationis closure: r = A/C -> A/(A-C) = r/(r-1).
D.6 (Prop. VII): Compositio rationis closure: r = A/B -> (A+B)/B = r+1 and (A+B)/A = (r+1)/r.
D.7 (Prop. VIII): Barycentric / internal ratio partition AC = r/(r+1)*AB, CB = 1/(r+1)*AB.
D.8 (Prop. IX): Transitive elimination of shared reference magnitude B via ex aequali (A/C = (A/B)/(C/B)).
D.9 (Prop. X): Diagonal scaling of a projective tuple (D, E, F) = (A/k1, B/k2, C/k3).
D.10 (Prop. XVI): Affine-ratio composition and converse bifurcation depending on whether given offset D < AB or D > AB.
D.11 (Prop. XVII): Bidirectional affine-linear substitution solving BC = (AB - D)/k into AB + BC and back.
D.12 (Prop. V): Elimination of common summand B: A - C = (A + B) - (B + C).
D.13 (Prop. XXIV): Scalar multiplication of an affine-ratio relation A = r*B = r*F + (r*k)*C.
D.14 (Prop. XVIII): Affine shift of proportional variables: (A+d1) - r*(C+d2) = d1 - r*d2.
D.15 (Prop. XIX): Subtractive affine shift: (A-d1) - r*(C-d2) = r*d2 - d1.
D.16 (Prop. XX): Mixed affine shift: A + d2 = r*(C - d1) + (r*d1 + d2), offset strictly positive.
D.17 (Prop. XXV): Elimination of parameter B between two affine-linear equations A = d1 + k1*B, C = d2 + k2*B.
D.18 (Prop. XXVI): Elimination of shared dominant variable C = d1 + k1*A = d2 + k2*E.
D.19 (Prop. XXVII): Composition of 1D affine maps f(g(C)) = d1 + k1*(d2 + k2*C) = (d1 + k1*d2) + (k1*k2)*C.
D.20 (Prop. XXIII): Parametric line segment difference: (A - x) + r*y = A, eliminating x = r*y.
D.21 (Omitted (cf. Prop. XVIII)): Dual of D.20 and symmetric restatement of D.14 (omitted as redundant by Simson).
D.22 (Prop. XI): Linearity of ratios over common denominator: (A + B)/C = A/C + B/C.
D.23 (Prop. XII): Non-singular 2x2 homogeneous linear solver (det = r1 - r2 != 0; Zamberti/Simson condition).
D.24 (Prop. XIII): Quadratic/mean-proportional root extraction over Q(sqrt(r)): A/B = sqrt(A/C).
- order:
13
- type:
notes
- canonical_id:
D.unit.1
- folio:
Menge pp. 4–42
- book:
Propositions 1–24: Magnitudes & Ratios
Magnitudes & Ratios (Propositions 1–24) — Philological & Critical Notes¶
1. Inhomogeneous Magnitudes & Simson’s Diorismos on D.2, D.7, and D.8¶
Unit 1 (D.1–D.24) operates at the universal level of Elements Book V magnitudes (μεγέθη): lines, plane areas, solids, and angles. In his critical notes on D.2 (pp. 456–457), Robert Simson pointed out a subtle foundational boundary that Euclid leaves tacit: in the Elements, constructing a fourth proportional $C : D = A : B$ is proved constructively only for straight lines ([VI.12]), not directly for arbitrary solids or inhomogeneous magnitudes.
Simson observed that whenever a given ratio between two homogeneous magnitudes can be exhibited as the ratio of two given straight lines $L_1 : L_2$ (as is always the case for constructible plane and solid problems in geometry), [VI.12] supplies the required fourth proportional rigorously. Similarly, in D.8 (magnitudes having given ratios to the same magnitude have a given ratio to one another), $A$ and $C$ must be homogeneous with one another (both lines, or both areas, etc.) in order to stand in a Eudoxian ratio ([V.def.3]).
2. The Affine-Linear Calculus (Defs. 11–12 & D.10–D.21) and Simson’s Additions¶
Propositions D.10–D.21 constitute an extraordinary piece of Greek symbolic compression. By packaging the two-parameter affine relation $y = k x + c$ ($c > 0$ given in magnitude, $k > 0$ given in ratio) into the single predicate δοθέντι μεῖζον ἢ ἐν λόγῳ ([Data Def. 11]) and $y = k x - c$ into [Data Def. 12], Euclid proves that affine functions of an unknown magnitude form a closed algebraic groupoid:
Additive & Subtractive Shifts (D.10–D.11): Notice that in Heinrich Menge's non-Theonine text (1896, pp. 16–22), both D.10 and D.11 contain two parts—a direct theorem and its converse! In the converse of D.10, subtracting the given offset $c$ from $x + y = c + k y$ splits into two cases according as $c < x$ (leaving $x = c + (k-1)y$) or $c > x$ (producing $x + (c - x) = c$ where $y : (c - x)$ is given, i.e., $x = c - k' y$). Because Euclid in Vat. gr. 190 avoided phrasing the second branch via Def. 12 directly, Simson (Props. XIV–XXIV) split and expanded the entire suite symmetrically across all sign combinations (Props. XIV–XV and Props. XXI–XXII).
Composition & Elimination (D.13, D.17–D.19): D.19 proves closure under composition ($A = k_1 B + c_1$ and $B = k_2 C + c_2 \implies A = (k_1 k_2) C + (c_1 + k_1 c_2)$), while D.17 and D.18 eliminate a shared variable between two affine equations.
The Doublet D.21: As Simson noted (p. 458), D.21 (adding magnitudes in a given ratio to two given magnitudes) is mathematically identical to the first part of D.14 (adding two given magnitudes to magnitudes in a given ratio) with the roles of the summands swapped; Simson therefore omitted D.21, whereas Menge retained it on the manuscript authority of Vat. gr. 190.
3. Non-Singularity in D.23 (det != 0) & Simson’s Critique of Newton on D.24¶
Two philological gems crown the close of * Determinant Non-Singularity in D.23: In D.23, if whole $AB = AE + EB$ has a given ratio $r$ to whole $CD = CF + FD$, while $AE : CF = r_1$ and $EB : FD = r_2$ are given, the crucial Greek proviso μὴ τοὺς αὐτοὺς δέ ("yet not the same ratios", $r_1 \neq r_2$) is the exact classical statement of matrix non-singularity! Algebraically, $(r_1 - r) CF + (r_2 - r) FD = 0$; if $r_1 = r_2 = r$, the two equations collapse into one ($0 = 0$) and $CF : FD$ is indeterminate (ἄτακτον), whereas $r_1 \neq r_2$ forces $CF : FD = (r - r_2) : (r_1 - r)$ uniquely. Bartolomeo Zamberti's 1505 Latin translation omitted the negation non, rendering the theorem false until Claude Hardy (1625) and David Gregory (1703) restored the Greek condition.
Continued Proportion & Quadratic Root Extraction in D.24: D.24 proves that if $A : B = B : C$ and $A : C$ is given, then $A : B$ is given ($A/B = \sqrt{A/C}$). Notably, Unit 1 here steps from general magnitudes to straight lines (εὐθεῖαι) so that [VI.13] can construct the geometric mean $E = \sqrt{D \cdot F}$. Late Byzantine manuscripts appended an alternative proof (Ἄλλως, relegated by Menge to the Appendix) that tried to dispense with squares, and Isaac Newton cited a similar shortcut in Principia Book I, Lemma XVII; Simson (pp. 459–460) demonstrated that the scholiast’s Ἄλλως tacitly begged the question, vindicating Euclid’s authentic proof.
Cross-Corpus Concordance (Pappus · Petersen · Altshiller-Court · G-Index)¶
D.1 (Prop. I) — Elements G-Index:
G.183, G.195· Pappus: Synagoge VII.3D.2 (Prop. II) — Elements G-Index:
G.189, G.187, G.222· Pappus: Synagoge VII.3 · Petersen (1879): Similarity / Scaling · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 18 (Fourth Proportional)D.3 (Prop. III) — Elements G-Index:
G.36· Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 6 (Sum of Segments)D.4 (Prop. IV) — Elements G-Index:
G.19· Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 6 (Difference of Segments)D.5 (Prop. VI) — Elements G-Index:
G.201· Pappus: Synagoge VII.4D.6 (Prop. VII) — Elements G-Index:
G.199, G.201· Pappus: Synagoge VII.4D.7 (Prop. VIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.220· Pappus: Synagoge VII.4 · Petersen (1879): Similarity / Ratio Division · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 19 (Internal Division)D.8 (Prop. IX) — Elements G-Index:
G.183, G.189, G.205· Pappus: Synagoge VII.4D.9 (Prop. X) — Elements G-Index:
G.189, G.205· Pappus: Synagoge VII.4D.10 (Prop. XVI) — Elements G-Index:
G.199, G.201· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.11 (Prop. XVII) — Elements G-Index:
G.190, G.195, G.199, G.201· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.12 (Prop. V) — Elements G-Index:
G.19· Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.13 (Prop. XXIV) — Elements G-Index:
G.189, G.201· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.14 (Prop. XVIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.190, G.199· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.15 (Prop. XIX) — Elements G-Index:
G.201· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.16 (Prop. XX) — Elements G-Index:
G.201· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.17 (Prop. XXV) — Elements G-Index:
G.189· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.18 (Prop. XXVI) — Elements G-Index:
G.189· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.19 (Prop. XXVII) — Elements G-Index:
G.189· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.20 (Prop. XXIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.201· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.21 (Omitted (cf. Prop. XVIII)) — Elements G-Index:
G.199· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.22 (Prop. XI) — Elements G-Index:
G.207· Pappus: Synagoge VII.4D.23 (Prop. XII) — Elements G-Index:
G.189, G.195, G.201· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic MethodD.24 (Prop. XIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.223, G.228, G.234· Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Mean Proportional · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 21 (Mean Proportional)
Section 2
- order:
20
- type:
chapter
- canonical_id:
D.unit.2
- folio:
Menge pp. 42–66
- book:
Propositions 25–38: Position & Parallels
- description:
Transition from abstract magnitudes to planar geometry: uniqueness of line-line intersections (D.25), endpoints and directions of segments (D.26–D.30), neusis/circle distance meets (D.31), inclined transversals across parallels (D.32–D.33), and parallel ratio-division loci through a fixed pole (D.34–D.38).
Position, Angles & Parallel Loci (Propositions 25–38)¶
Straight Lines Given in Position, Angular Rays, and Parallel Locus Determination — D.25–D.38 (Simson XXVIII–XL) · Menge (1896) pp. 42–66
Note
Edition Track (English): Transition from abstract magnitudes to planar geometry: uniqueness of line-line intersections (D.25), endpoints and directions of segments (D.26–D.30), neusis/circle distance meets (D.31), inclined transversals across parallels (D.32–D.33), and parallel ratio-division loci through a fixed pole (D.34–D.38). Switch tabs above for Greek (Menge 1896), Summary, or Notes.
Interactive locus diagram (Menge pp. 46–66): From given external pole P, secants PF (cutting AB at E and CD at F) and PH (cutting at G and H) are divided in a constant given ratio (D.34), while internal division points M, N, and S trace the parallel locus MN (D.35–D.38). Ray KQ from given point K at given angle ∠BKQ (D.29) meets CD at unique point Q (D.25).
- order:
22
- type:
summary
- canonical_id:
D.unit.2
- folio:
Menge pp. 42–66
- book:
Propositions 25–38: Position & Parallels
Position, Angles & Parallel Loci (Propositions 25–38) — Analytical Summary¶
Unit Overview & Role in Greek Geometric Analysis¶
Transition from abstract magnitudes to planar geometry: uniqueness of line-line intersections (D.25), endpoints and directions of segments (D.26–D.30), neusis/circle distance meets (D.31), inclined transversals across parallels (D.32–D.33), and parallel ratio-division loci through a fixed pole (D.34–D.38).
Scope: 14 propositions (D.25–D.38 (Simson XXVIII–XL), Menge pp. 42–66).
Analytical Function: Each proposition below compiles into a forward-chaining inference rule
Given(...) -> Determined(...)within Pappus's Treasury of Analysis (Synagoge Book VII) andgeometor.modelsymbolic DAGs.
Functional Overview (D.25–D.38 (Simson XXVIII–XL))¶
ID |
Simson |
Functional Signature |
Key Dependencies |
Tracks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Prop. XXVIII |
|
|||
Prop. XXIX |
|
|||
Prop. XXX |
|
[Data Def. 1], [Data Def. 4], [Data Def. 6], [Post. 3], [I Def. 15] |
||
Prop. XXXI |
|
|||
Prop. XXXII |
|
|||
Prop. XXXIII |
|
|||
Prop. XXXIV |
|
[Data Def. 4], [Data Def. 6], [Data 25], [Data 26], [I.12], [Post. 3] |
||
Prop. XXXV |
|
|||
Prop. XXXVI |
|
[Data Def. 1], [Data Def. 4], [Data 28], [Data 31], [I.29], [I.34] |
||
Prop. XXXVIII |
|
[Data 1], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 30], [I.12], [VI.2], [VI.4] |
||
Prop. XXXIX (pt. 1) |
|
[Data 7], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 28], [Data 30], [VI.2] |
||
Prop. XXXIX (pt. 2) |
|
[Data 2], [Data 6], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 28], [Data 30], [VI.2] |
||
Prop. XL (pt. 1) |
|
[Data 7], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 28], [Data 30], [I.30], [I.34], [VI.2] |
||
Prop. XL (pt. 2) |
|
[Data 2], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 28], [Data 30], [I.30], [I.34], [VI.2] |
Computational Primitives (geometor.model & SymPy)¶
D.25 (Prop. XXVIII): Fundamental model.intersect(L1, L2) primitive in geometor.model.
D.26 (Prop. XXIX): Fundamental model.set_line(A, B) and Euclidean metric norm \(|B - A|\).
D.27 (Prop. XXX): Line-circle intersection model.intersect(line, Circle(A, r)) fixing endpoint B on a given ray.
D.28 (Prop. XXXI): Euclidean parallel constructor through P along direction vector of BC (Elements I.31).
D.29 (Prop. XXXII): Angular ray constructor Elements I.23 rotating line direction at vertex C by given angle.
D.30 (Prop. XXXIII): Auxiliary angle construction at A on parallel through A (D.28 + D.29), yielding dropped oblique/altitude.
D.31 (Prop. XXXIV): Circle-line intersection Circle(A, r) cap Line(BC) (1 tangent or 2 symmetric chords; Simson diorismos).
D.32 (Prop. XXXV): Translational invariance of oblique transversal length across a fixed parallel strip (I.34).
D.33 (Prop. XXXVI): Converse of D.32 reducing free transversal of given length to pinned circle-line meet (D.31).
D.34 (Prop. XXXVIII): Thales projection invariant: collinear segments from fixed pole E cut parallel lines in constant ratio.
D.35 (Prop. XXXIX (pt. 1)): Internal homothetic dilation H(A, k) with 0 < k < 1 mapping given line BC to parallel locus FEG.
D.36 (Prop. XXXIX (pt. 2)): External homothetic dilation H(A, 1 + r) or H(A, -r) mapping line BC to parallel locus FEG.
D.37 (Prop. XL (pt. 1)): Affine convex combination (1 - t)*L1 + t*L2 of two parallel lines given in position.
D.38 (Prop. XL (pt. 2)): Extrapolated affine combination (1 + r)*L2 - r*L1 outside the parallel strip.
- order:
23
- type:
notes
- canonical_id:
D.unit.2
- folio:
Menge pp. 42–66
- book:
Propositions 25–38: Position & Parallels
Position, Angles & Parallel Loci (Propositions 25–38) — Philological & Critical Notes¶
1. Shifting Proofs (Μεταπεσεῖται) vs. Constructive Proofs in D.25–D.30¶
The opening propositions of Unit 2 (D.25–D.30) exhibit a striking stylistic feature in the Greek manuscripts: instead of constructing an auxiliary copy, they argue by reductio ad absurdum using the kinematic verb μεταπεσεῖται ("it will shift / fall elsewhere"), appealing directly to [Data Def. 4] ("always occupying the same place").
Robert Simson (pp. 460–462), consistent with his repair of Definition 4 (requiring procurability alongside uniqueness), replaced several shifting arguments with explicit straightedge-and-compass constructions ([Post. 1], [Post. 3], [I.23], [I.31]) and inserted a companion converse (Simson Prop. XXVII: if one extremity of a straight line given in magnitude be given, and the line also pass through another given point, or be given in position…). Modern foundational scholarship (Taisbak (2003)) recognizes that Euclid’s μεταπεσεῖται idiom intentionally isolates topological/incidence invariance once elementary constructibility is already guaranteed by Books I and III.
2. Multi-Valued Intersections & Diorismos in D.31 and D.33¶
In D.31 (drawing a segment of given length $r$ from a given point $A$ to a position-given line $CD$), the circle $(A, r)$ ([Data Def. 6]) meets $CD$ in:
Zero points if $r < d(A, CD)$ (requiring the diorismos $r \ge d(A, CD)$);
One point (tangent foot of the perpendicular) if $r = d(A, CD)$; or
Two symmetric points $B_1, B_2$ on $CD$ if $r > d(A, CD)$.
As Marinus already explained in Protheoria § 4, Greek analysis treats a finitely bifurcated intersection—unique on each side of the perpendicular axis of symmetry—as genuinely ordered and given (μοναχῶς ἐφʼ ἑκάτερα), in sharp contrast to an indeterminate (ἄτακτον) continuum of solutions. Exactly the same two-branch symmetry governs D.33.
3. Petersen’s Two-Locus & Parallel-Translation Paradigm (D.25–D.38)¶
Nearly twenty-two centuries after Euclid, Julius Petersen opened his celebrated Danish problem-solving classic Methods and Theories for the Solution of Problems of Geometrical Constructions (1879) by distilling Unit 2 of Euclid’s Data into two master heuristics:
Method of Loci (Chapter I): Drop one constraint on an unknown point $X$; its locus is a position-given line (D.28–D.30, D.35–D.38) or circle ([Data Def. 6]). Restore the second constraint to obtain a second position-given locus; D.25 then determines $X$ as their intersection.
Parallel Translation & Homothety (Chapters II–III): Propositions D.32–D.33 translate a floating segment $EF$ between parallel lines $AB \parallel CD$ to a chosen anchor point $G \in AB$, while D.35–D.38 apply central dilation (homothety) from a fixed centre $A$ (or transversal dilation between parallels) to transform a position-given line into a parallel position-given locus. Note also that Simson (Props. XXXIX–XL) consolidated Euclid’s external/internal pairs D.35 + D.36 into Prop. XXXIX and D.37 + D.38 into Prop. XL.
Cross-Corpus Concordance (Pappus · Petersen · Altshiller-Court · G-Index)¶
D.25 (Prop. XXVIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.14, G.4· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Method of Loci (Two-Locus Intersection) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 1 (Intersection of Loci)D.26 (Prop. XXIX) — Elements G-Index:
G.14, G.15· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Method of Loci · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 2D.27 (Prop. XXX) — Elements G-Index:
G.15, G.10· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Method of Loci (Line + Circle) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 3D.28 (Prop. XXXI) — Elements G-Index:
G.53, G.56, G.57, G.58· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Parallel Translation · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 8 (Parallel Locus)D.29 (Prop. XXXII) — Elements G-Index:
G.48· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Rotation / Angular Locus · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 5 (Given Angle Ray)D.30 (Prop. XXXIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.48, G.56, G.58· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Parallel Translation · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 8D.31 (Prop. XXXIV) — Elements G-Index:
G.35, G.15· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Method of Loci (Circle + Line) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 11 (Circle-Line Intersection)D.32 (Prop. XXXV) — Elements G-Index:
G.56, G.58, G.62· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Parallel Translation · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 31 (Translation between Parallels)D.33 (Prop. XXXVI) — Elements G-Index:
G.56, G.62· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Parallel Translation · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 31D.34 (Prop. XXXVIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.35, G.211, G.213· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Homothecy / Multiplication of Curves · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 39 (Homothetic Ratio across Parallels)D.35 (Prop. XXXIX (pt. 1)) — Elements G-Index:
G.211· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Homothecy / Multiplication of Curves · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 40 (Homothetic Line Locus)D.36 (Prop. XXXIX (pt. 2)) — Elements G-Index:
G.211· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Homothecy / Multiplication of Curves · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 40 (Homothetic Line Locus)D.37 (Prop. XL (pt. 1)) — Elements G-Index:
G.57, G.62, G.211· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Method of Loci · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 9 (Parallel Intermediate Locus)D.38 (Prop. XL (pt. 2)) — Elements G-Index:
G.57, G.62, G.211· Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Method of Loci · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 9
Section 3
- order:
30
- type:
chapter
- canonical_id:
D.unit.3
- folio:
Menge pp. 66–98
- book:
Propositions 39–55: Triangles & Species
- description:
Constructive determination of triangles up to similarity (εἴδει) from SSS-ratios (D.39), AAA (D.40), SAS-ratio (D.41), side-ratios (D.42), right-SSA (D.43), general SSA bifurcation with obtuse/acute diorismos (D.44), sum/difference of sides (D.45–D.46), decomposing rectilinear polygons into triangles (D.47), and quadratic area-scaling of figures given in species (D.48–D.55).
Triangles & Polygons Given in Species (Propositions 39–55)¶
Similarity Invariants, Triangle Rigidity Criteria, and Area-to-Side Scaling — D.39–D.55 (Simson XLII–LX) · Menge (1896) pp. 66–98
Note
Edition Track (English): Constructive determination of triangles up to similarity (εἴδει) from SSS-ratios (D.39), AAA (D.40), SAS-ratio (D.41), side-ratios (D.42), right-SSA (D.43), general SSA bifurcation with obtuse/acute diorismos (D.44), sum/difference of sides (D.45–D.46), decomposing rectilinear polygons into triangles (D.47), and quadratic area-scaling of figures given in species (D.48–D.55). Switch tabs above for Greek (Menge 1896), Summary, or Notes.
Interactive species diagram (Menge pp. 66–82): Left panel illustrates unique species determination (D.39–D.42), pairing similar triangles DEF and GHK with equal vertex angles ∠EDF and ∠HGK and proportional sides DE to GH. Right panel illustrates the SSA two-root bifurcation (D.44): given angle ∠CAB at A and side ratio AB to radius BC₁, circle (B, BC₁) cuts ray AC₂ in equal radii at obtuse solution C₁ and acute solution C₂ symmetric across altitude BP (foot P).
- order:
32
- type:
summary
- canonical_id:
D.unit.3
- folio:
Menge pp. 66–98
- book:
Propositions 39–55: Triangles & Species
Triangles & Polygons Given in Species (Propositions 39–55) — Analytical Summary¶
Unit Overview & Role in Greek Geometric Analysis¶
Constructive determination of triangles up to similarity (εἴδει) from SSS-ratios (D.39), AAA (D.40), SAS-ratio (D.41), side-ratios (D.42), right-SSA (D.43), general SSA bifurcation with obtuse/acute diorismos (D.44), sum/difference of sides (D.45–D.46), decomposing rectilinear polygons into triangles (D.47), and quadratic area-scaling of figures given in species (D.48–D.55).
Scope: 17 propositions (D.39–D.55 (Simson XLII–LX), Menge pp. 66–98).
Analytical Function: Each proposition below compiles into a forward-chaining inference rule
Given(...) -> Determined(...)within Pappus's Treasury of Analysis (Synagoge Book VII) andgeometor.modelsymbolic DAGs.
Functional Overview (D.39–D.55 (Simson XLII–LX))¶
ID |
Simson |
Functional Signature |
Key Dependencies |
Tracks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Prop. XLII |
|
|||
Prop. XLIII |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 29], [I.32], [VI.4] |
||
Prop. XLIV |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 2], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 29], [VI.6] |
||
Prop. XLV |
|
|||
Prop. XLVI |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 2], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 29], [Data 31], [I.47], [VI.7] |
||
Prop. XLVII |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 2], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 29], [Data 31], [I.13], [VI.7] |
||
Prop. XLVIII |
|
|||
Prop. XLIX |
|
|||
Prop. LI |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 4], [Data 8], [Data 41], [I.32], [VI.20] |
||
Prop. LII |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 8], [Data 28], [Data 30], [I.37], [VI.1], [VI.4] |
||
Prop. LIII |
|
|||
Prop. LIV |
|
|||
Prop. LV |
|
|||
Prop. LVI |
|
|||
Prop. LVII |
|
|||
Prop. LIX |
|
|||
Prop. LX |
|
Computational Primitives (geometor.model & SymPy)¶
D.39 (Prop. XLII): Constructive SSS rigidity (Elements I.22 + I.8) determining all angles and side-ratios.
D.40 (Prop. XLIII): Prototype unit-base construction (D.27 + D.29) + equiangular similarity (Elements VI.4).
D.41 (Prop. XLIV): SAS similarity (Elements VI.6) on an auxiliary model triangle with fixed side D and E = (b/c)*D.
D.42 (Prop. XLV): Scale-free SSS similarity (Elements VI.5 + D.39) instantiating segments F, G, H in given ratios.
D.43 (Prop. XLVI): Unambiguous right-triangle HL similarity (semicircle intersection fixes unique acute complement).
D.44 (Prop. XLVII): Elements VI.7 SSA similarity split into acute and obtuse roots C1, C2 of Circle(B, r) cap Ray(AC).
D.45 (Prop. XLVIII): Produce BA to D with AD = AC: angle BDC = A/2 is given, reducing (b+c):a to SSA (D.44) on △DBC!
D.46 (Prop. XLIX): Produce BA to D with AD = AC: △DBC has given Angle B and given ratio BD : BC (D.41), then CD bisector fixes A!
D.47 (Prop. LI): Inductive diagonal ear-clipping (D.41 peels △ABC, subtracts ∠ACB from ∠BCD via D.4, scales ratio via D.8).
D.48 (Prop. LII): Common-base area ratio equals ratio of altitudes h1 : h2, determined by species angles and side ratios.
D.49 (Prop. LIII): Triangulate both polygons (D.47), relate sub-triangles via D.48 and VI.20, sum via D.22.
D.50 (Prop. LIV): Duplicate-ratio scaling (Elements VI.20 cor.): Area(E) : Area(F) = AB : third_proportional(AB, CD) = r^2.
D.51 (Prop. LV): Copy figure G ~ E onto AB or CD (VI.18), bridge Area(E):Area(G) by D.50 and Area(G):Area(F) by D.49, compose via D.8.
D.52 (Prop. LVI): Construct square ABFG on given AB (I.46, given in magnitude and species); Area(P) : AB^2 is given by D.49, hence Area(P) by D.2.
D.53 (Prop. LVII): Chain internal side ratios from Def. 3 across the cross-figure bridge ratio via D.8.
D.54 (Prop. LIX): Reduce Area(A):Area(B) to similar figures via D.49, then extract square-root side ratio from duplicate ratio via D.24!
D.55 (Prop. LX): Instantiate unit-side prototype B ~ A (D.52 gives Area(B)); D.1 gives Area(A):Area(B); D.54 + D.2 yield exact sides (Elements VI.25!
- order:
33
- type:
notes
- canonical_id:
D.unit.3
- folio:
Menge pp. 66–98
- book:
Propositions 39–55: Triangles & Species
Triangles & Polygons Given in Species (Propositions 39–55) — Philological & Critical Notes¶
1. Triangle Rigidity modulo Similarity & Petersen’s Method of Similarity (D.39–D.42)¶
Unit 3 shifts from position in the plane to intrinsic shape—figures given in species ([Data Def. 3]), i.e., determined up to similarity (angles given and pairwise side-ratios given). Propositions D.39–D.42 lift the congruence and similarity theorems of Books I and VI into constructive shape-determination operators:
Notice Euclid’s constructive technique throughout: he sets out an arbitrary reference segment $DE$ given in position and magnitude, builds a concrete prototype $\triangle DEF$ whose vertices are determined in position by Unit 2, reads off its given angles and ratios, and transfers species to $\triangle ABC$ by Book VI similarity. This is the exact archetype of Petersen's Method of Similarity (1879, Chapter II).
2. Unambiguous Right-Triangle HL (D.43) vs. General SSA Bifurcation (D.44)¶
The contrast between D.43 and D.44 (illustrated interactively in data_03_triangle_species.svg) showcases Euclid’s command of diorismos:
In D.43, $\angle BAC = 90^\circ$ is opposite the hypotenuse $BC$, while the ratio $BC : BA$ ($> 1$ by [I.19]) is given. Since the remaining angle $\angle ACB$ is necessarily acute ([I.17]), inscribing $DG$ in the Thales semicircle $DGE$ ([III.31]) yields a single, unambiguous species ([VI.7]).
In D.44, $\angle ABC$ is given while the ratio $AB : AC$ of the sides about another angle $\angle BAC$ is given (SSA). When $AC < AB$ ($AC \ge AB \sin B$), the circle $(A, AC)$ cuts ray $BC$ in two distinct points $C_1, C_2$ symmetric across the altitude foot $P$, with $\angle AC_1 B + \angle AC_2 B = 180^\circ$! Euclid’s proof drops the altitude $AD \perp BC$, reduces $\triangle ADC$ to D.43, and handles the acute and obtuse branches separately (χωρὶς δὲ τοῦ συμπτώματος), matching [VI.7].
3. Angle-Bisector Harmonic Reduction (D.45–D.46) vs. Simson’s Construction¶
Propositions D.45 and D.46 determine the species of $\triangle ABC$ from one angle and the ratio $(BA + AC) : BC$ of the sum of two sides to the third side:
Euclid’s Proof via Elements VI.3: Bisecting $\angle BAC$ by $AD$ gives $BA : AC = BD : DC$ ([VI.3]), whence alternando and componendo $(BA + AC) : BC = BA : BD$! In D.46 (where $\angle ABC$ is given), $\angle ABD$ lies between $BA$ and $BD$, so D.41 applies immediately without ambiguity. In D.45 (where $\angle BAC$ is given), $\angle BAD = \frac{1}{2}\angle BAC$ is opposite $BD$; since $BD < BC$ and $\angle ADB = \angle DAC + \angle C > \angle BAD$, $\angle ABD$ can actually take two supplementary-like configurations only up to swapping $AB$ and $AC$!
Simson’s Isosceles-Extension Proof & Added Prop. L: Simson (Props. XLVIII–L, pp. 394–397, 463) noted that extending $CA$ to $E$ with $AE = AB$ makes $EC = BA + AC$ directly and $\angle AEB = \frac{1}{2}\angle BAC$, reducing D.45 (Simson XLVIII) cleanly to D.44 on $\triangle EBC$ and inspiring Simson’s companion Prop. L for the difference of the sides $(BA - AC) : BC$ (via cutting off $AE' = AB$ internally).
4. Polygon Triangulation & Quadratic Area-to-Side Extraction (D.47–D.55)¶
The second half of Unit 3 (D.47–D.55) links 1D linear segments to 2D rectilinear areas:
D.47 proves that every species-given $n$-gon triangulates into $(n-2)$ species-given triangles by ear-clipping diagonals (D.41).
D.48–D.51 establish that any two species-given figures on the same or ratio-given segments have a given area ratio, culminating in D.52 (species-given figure on a magnitude-given segment is given in area, calibrated against the unit square $AB^2$).
D.54 and D.55 invert the quadratic scaling map $S \propto x^2$! Using D.24 (which extracted the square root of a ratio via the geometric mean [VI.13]), D.54 deduces linear side-ratios from area-ratios, and D.55 proves the grand converse of D.52: any figure given both in species and in magnitude has all its sides given in magnitude—the exact analytical counterpart of [Elements VI.25] (constructing a figure similar to one given figure and equal in area to another).
Cross-Corpus Concordance (Pappus · Petersen · Altshiller-Court · G-Index)¶
D.39 (Prop. XLII) — Elements G-Index:
G.29, G.47· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Construction of Triangles (SSS) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 13 (SSS Construction)D.40 (Prop. XLIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.59, G.213· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Method of Similarity (AAA) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 44 (Method of Similitude)D.41 (Prop. XLIV) — Elements G-Index:
G.215· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Method of Similarity (SAS) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 44 (Method of Similitude)D.42 (Prop. XLV) — Elements G-Index:
G.45, G.47, G.214· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Method of Similarity (SSS-Ratio) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 45D.43 (Prop. XLVI) — Elements G-Index:
G.79, G.216· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Method of Similarity (Right-HL) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 14 (Right Triangle HL)D.44 (Prop. XLVII) — Elements G-Index:
G.37, G.216· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Method of Similarity (SSA Bifurcation) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 15 (Ambiguous Case SSA)D.45 (Prop. XLVIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.25, G.59· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Auxiliary Isosceles Extension · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 53 (Sum of Two Sides)D.46 (Prop. XLIX) — Elements G-Index:
G.25, G.31, G.59· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Auxiliary Isosceles Extension · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 53 (Sum of Two Sides)D.47 (Prop. LI) — Elements G-Index:
G.59, G.232· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Polygon TriangulationD.48 (Prop. LII) — Elements G-Index:
G.66, G.210, G.213· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Ratio of AltitudesD.49 (Prop. LIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.232· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Polygon TriangulationD.50 (Prop. LIV) — Elements G-Index:
G.221, G.231, G.232· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Duplicate Ratio ScalingD.51 (Prop. LV) — Elements G-Index:
G.229, G.232· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Similarity BridgeD.52 (Prop. LVI) — Elements G-Index:
G.75· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Square Reference UnitD.53 (Prop. LVII) — Elements G-Index:
G.205· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7D.54 (Prop. LIX) — Elements G-Index:
G.229, G.232· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Mean Proportional ExtractionD.55 (Prop. LX) — Elements G-Index:
G.75, G.229· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Similarity + Quadratic Scaling · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 49 (Constructing a Figure of Given Species & Area)
Section 4
- order:
40
- type:
chapter
- canonical_id:
D.unit.4
- folio:
Menge pp. 98–126
- book:
Propositions 56–67: Areas, Quadratics & Cosines
- description:
Equiangular parallelograms and parabolic division of areas (D.56–D.57), quadratic root extraction via elliptic and hyperbolic application of areas (D.58–D.59) and gnomons (D.60), altitude-to-base ratios (D.61–D.63), generalized Law of Cosines projections in obtuse and acute triangles (D.64–D.65), area-product law BD·BC : △ABC (D.66), and the algebraic identity (a+b)² − c² (D.67).
Application of Areas, Quadratics & Cosine Projections (Propositions 56–67)¶
Geometric Algebra of Parabolic, Elliptic & Hyperbolic Areas and Oblique Triangle Projections — D.56–D.67 (Simson LXI–LXXXIV) · Menge (1896) pp. 98–126
Note
Edition Track (English): Equiangular parallelograms and parabolic division of areas (D.56–D.57), quadratic root extraction via elliptic and hyperbolic application of areas (D.58–D.59) and gnomons (D.60), altitude-to-base ratios (D.61–D.63), generalized Law of Cosines projections in obtuse and acute triangles (D.64–D.65), area-product law BD·BC : △ABC (D.66), and the algebraic identity (a+b)² − c² (D.67). Switch tabs above for Greek (Menge 1896), Summary, or Notes.
- order:
42
- type:
summary
- canonical_id:
D.unit.4
- folio:
Menge pp. 98–126
- book:
Propositions 56–67: Areas, Quadratics & Cosines
Application of Areas, Quadratics & Cosine Projections (Propositions 56–67) — Analytical Summary¶
Unit Overview & Role in Greek Geometric Analysis¶
Equiangular parallelograms and parabolic division of areas (D.56–D.57), quadratic root extraction via elliptic and hyperbolic application of areas (D.58–D.59) and gnomons (D.60), altitude-to-base ratios (D.61–D.63), generalized Law of Cosines projections in obtuse and acute triangles (D.64–D.65), area-product law BD·BC : △ABC (D.66), and the algebraic identity (a+b)² − c² (D.67).
Scope: 12 propositions (D.56–D.67 (Simson LXI–LXXXIV), Menge pp. 98–126).
Analytical Function: Each proposition below compiles into a forward-chaining inference rule
Given(...) -> Determined(...)within Pappus's Treasury of Analysis (Synagoge Book VII) andgeometor.modelsymbolic DAGs.
Functional Overview (D.56–D.67 (Simson LXI–LXXXIV))¶
ID |
Simson |
Functional Signature |
Key Dependencies |
Tracks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Prop. LXIII |
|
|||
Prop. LXI |
|
[Data 1], [Data 2], [Data 8], [Data 52], [I.31], [I.46], [VI.1] |
||
Prop. LXXXIII |
|
[Data 3], [Data 4], [Data 52], [Data 55], [II.5], [VI.24], [VI.27], [VI.28] |
||
Prop. LXXXIV |
|
[Data 3], [Data 4], [Data 52], [Data 55], [II.6], [VI.24], [VI.29] |
||
Prop. LXXXII |
|
|||
Prop. LXIX |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 8], [Data 40], [Data 49], [I.13], [I.29], [I.31], [I.35], [VI.1] |
||
Prop. LXX |
|
|||
Omitted (case of Prop. LIII) |
|
|||
Prop. LXXIV |
|
|||
Prop. LXXV |
|
|||
Prop. LXII Cor. |
|
|||
Prop. LXXVI |
|
[Data 8], [Data 40], [Data 50], [Data 66], [I.5], [I.13], [I.31], [I.32], [II.6], [VI.2], [VI.16] |
Computational Primitives (geometor.model & SymPy)¶
D.56 (Prop. LXIII): Reduction of non-equal equiangular parallelogram areas to reciprocal sides (Elements VI.14) by scaling side BC -> BG.
D.57 (Prop. LXI): Linear division of area (parabolē, Elements I.44): x = S / (a * sin(theta)).
D.58 (Prop. LXXXIII): Quadratic solver for elliptic application (Elements VI.28 + II.5 gnomon completion) over Q(sqrt((a/2)^2 - S/c)).
D.59 (Prop. LXXXIV): Unconditional quadratic solver (Elements VI.29 + II.6) yielding exact radical / Q(phi) positive root.
D.60 (Prop. LXXXII): Since P +/- G preserves species (Elements VI.24) and has given area (D.3/D.4), D.55 gives new sides, D.4 gives gnomon widths.
D.61 (Prop. LXIX): Compare AFCB with auxiliary parallelogram FB (D.49), shear CD to equal-base KB (I.35, VI.1), then solve △LCK (D.40) for LC : CB.
D.62 (Prop. LXX): Describe parallelogram AG ~ DF on AB (VI.18); D.50 + D.8 give Area(AEB) : Area(AG), reducing directly to D.61!
D.63 (Omitted (case of Prop. LIII)): Direct specialization of D.49 pairing △ABC with the squares on its sides (omitted as corollarial by Simson).
D.64 (Prop. LXXIV): Elements II.12 gives AC^2 - (AB^2 + BC^2) = 2*BC*BD; right △ABD is given in species (D.40), fixing 2*BC*BD : (1/2*BC*AD) = 4*BD : AD!
D.65 (Prop. LXXV): Elements II.13 gives (AB^2 + BC^2) - AC^2 = 2*BC*BD; right △ABD has given ratio BD : AD (D.40), fixing 4*BD : AD!
D.66 (Prop. LXII Cor.): Drop altitude BD perp AC: right △ABD has given AB : BD (D.40), and Rect(AB, AC) : △ABC = 2*AB : BD.
D.67 (Prop. LXXVI): Extend BA to AD = AC and BE || AC: (BA+AC)^2 - BC^2 = Rect(DC, CE) (II.6), whose ratio to Rect(BA, AC) (D.50) and △ABC (D.66) is given!
- order:
43
- type:
notes
- canonical_id:
D.unit.4
- folio:
Menge pp. 98–126
- book:
Propositions 56–67: Areas, Quadratics & Cosines
Application of Areas, Quadratics & Cosine Projections (Propositions 56–67) — Philological & Critical Notes¶
1. Geometric Algebra of Application of Areas: Parabolē, Elleipsis, and Hyperbolē (D.57–D.60)¶
Unit 4 (D.56–D.67) translates the constructive application of areas (παραβολὴ τῶν χωρίων, Elements II.5–6 & VI.27–29) into analytical root-determination theorems:
Parabolē (παραβολή, D.57): Exact application $a \cdot x = S$ in a given angle $\\theta$ solves the linear equation $x = S / (a \sin\\theta)$.
Elleipsis (ἔλλειψις, D.58): Elliptic application $(a - x)\cdot (\lambda x) = S$ solves the quadratic equation $\lambda x^2 - \lambda a x + S = 0$ by completing the gnomon on the half-segment $a/2$ ([II.5], [VI.28]), subject to the discriminant diorismos $S \le \lambda (a/2)^2$ ([VI.27]).
Hyperbolē (ὑπερβολή, D.59): Hyperbolic application $(a + x)\cdot (\lambda x) = S$ solves $\lambda x^2 + \lambda a x = S$ unconditionally via [II.6] and [VI.29]. When $S = a^2$ and the excess is a square ($\lambda = 1$), $x(a + x) = a^2$ determines the golden section $x = a/\phi \in \mathbb{Q}(\phi)$ ([II.11], [VI.30])!
As Proclus (In Eucl. 419.15) and Pappus record, Apollonius of Perga borrowed the very names parabola, ellipse, and hyperbola directly from this Pythagorean-Euclidean triad.
2. Area-to-Species Bridges (D.61–D.63) & Textual Notes¶
Propositions D.61 and D.62 bridge area-ratios back to species: if a parallelogram $CD$ in a given angle is applied either to a side of a species-given figure (D.61) or to a segment having a given ratio to a side of a species-given figure (D.62), and the area ratio is given, then $CD$ itself is given in species. Simson (Props. LXIX–LXX, p. 464) retained both (D.61–62) while omitting D.63 (species-given figures on the three sides of a species-given triangle have given ratios to one another) as an immediate corollary of D.51; Menge preserved D.63 from Vat. gr. 190.
3. The Euclidean Law of Cosines, Sine Area Formula & Half-Angle Excess (D.64–D.67)¶
Propositions D.64–D.67 form the trigonometric heart of Greek plane geometry (visualized in data_05_cosine_projection.svg):
Obtuse & Acute Cosine Laws (D.64–D.65): By combining [Elements II.12] and [II.13] with species-given right-triangle projections (D.40), Euclid proves that $|a^2 + c^2 - b^2| : (a c) = 2\, BD : AB = 2|\cos B|$ is given whenever $\angle B$ is given—without ever needing symbolic trigonometric tables!
Sine Area Law (D.66): Proves $(AB \cdot BC) : \\triangle ABC = 2/\sin B$ is given whenever $\angle B$ is given.
Compound-Side Quadratic Excess (D.67, Simson Prop. LXXVI): Proves $((b + c)^2 - a^2) : \\triangle ABC$ is given whenever $\angle A$ is given. Algebraically, $(b+c)^2 - a^2 = 2bc(1 + \cos A)$ while $\\triangle ABC = \frac{1}{2}bc\sin A$, so their constant ratio is $4(1+\cos A)/\sin A = 4\cot(A/2)$! In Vat. gr. 190 (Menge pp. 122–126), Euclid establishes this synthetically without trigonometry by extending $BA$ to $D$ with $AD = AC$ and applying [II.6].
Cross-Corpus Concordance (Pappus · Petersen · Altshiller-Court · G-Index)¶
D.56 (Prop. LXIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.210, G.225· Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Application of AreasD.57 (Prop. LXI) — Elements G-Index:
G.58, G.75, G.210· Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Parabolic Application of Areas · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 47 (Transformation of Areas)D.58 (Prop. LXXXIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.87, G.236, G.239, G.240· Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Elliptic Application of Areas (Quadratic) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 50 (Elliptic Application)D.59 (Prop. LXXXIV) — Elements G-Index:
G.88, G.236, G.241· Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Hyperbolic Application of Areas (Quadratic) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 51 (Hyperbolic Application / Golden Section)D.60 (Prop. LXXXII) — Elements G-Index:
G.236· Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Gnomonic ScalingD.61 (Prop. LXIX) — Elements G-Index:
G.37, G.56, G.58, G.64, G.210· Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Area-to-Aspect ConversionD.62 (Prop. LXX) — Elements G-Index:
G.229, G.232· Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Area-to-Aspect ConversionD.63 (Omitted (case of Prop. LIII)) — Elements G-Index:
G.75· Pappus: Synagoge VII.8D.64 (Prop. LXXIV) — Elements G-Index:
G.35, G.59, G.94, G.210· Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Cosine Projection LawD.65 (Prop. LXXV) — Elements G-Index:
G.35, G.59, G.95, G.210· Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Cosine Projection LawD.66 (Prop. LXII Cor.) — Elements G-Index:
G.35, G.70, G.210· Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Trigonometric Area FormulaD.67 (Prop. LXXVI) — Elements G-Index:
G.25, G.37, G.58, G.59, G.88, G.211, G.227· Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Isosceles Auxiliary Extension + Secant-Product
Section 5
- order:
50
- type:
chapter
- canonical_id:
D.unit.5
- folio:
Menge pp. 126–164
- book:
Propositions 68–83: Proportional Figures
- description:
Compound ratio calculus for equiangular and supplementary-angle parallelograms and triangles (D.68–D.75), dropped-altitude ratios in species-given triangles (D.76), duplicated/corollarial area-species bridges (D.77–D.78), inscribed circle-triangle similarity lemmas and area-product determination (D.79–D.80), and four-line proportional transformations (D.81–D.83).
Proportional Parallelograms, Triangles & Four-Line Relations (Propositions 68–83)¶
Compound Side-Ratios, Reciprocal Proportions, Simson’s Lemma, and Four-Line Cross-Multiplications — D.68–D.83 (Simson L–LXXVIII) · Menge (1896) pp. 126–164
Note
Edition Track (English): Compound ratio calculus for equiangular and supplementary-angle parallelograms and triangles (D.68–D.75), dropped-altitude ratios in species-given triangles (D.76), duplicated/corollarial area-species bridges (D.77–D.78), inscribed circle-triangle similarity lemmas and area-product determination (D.79–D.80), and four-line proportional transformations (D.81–D.83). Switch tabs above for Greek (Menge 1896), Summary, or Notes.
- order:
52
- type:
summary
- canonical_id:
D.unit.5
- folio:
Menge pp. 126–164
- book:
Propositions 68–83: Proportional Figures
Proportional Parallelograms, Triangles & Four-Line Relations (Propositions 68–83) — Analytical Summary¶
Unit Overview & Role in Greek Geometric Analysis¶
Compound ratio calculus for equiangular and supplementary-angle parallelograms and triangles (D.68–D.75), dropped-altitude ratios in species-given triangles (D.76), duplicated/corollarial area-species bridges (D.77–D.78), inscribed circle-triangle similarity lemmas and area-product determination (D.79–D.80), and four-line proportional transformations (D.81–D.83).
Scope: 16 propositions (D.68–D.83 (Simson L–LXXVIII), Menge pp. 126–164).
Analytical Function: Each proposition below compiles into a forward-chaining inference rule
Given(...) -> Determined(...)within Pappus's Treasury of Analysis (Synagoge Book VII) andgeometor.modelsymbolic DAGs.
Functional Overview (D.68–D.83 (Simson L–LXXVIII))¶
ID |
Simson |
Functional Signature |
Key Dependencies |
Tracks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Prop. LXV |
|
|||
Prop. LXVI |
|
[Data 8], [Data 40], [Data 68], [I.12], [I.23], [I.31], [I.35] |
||
Props. LXVII–LXVIII |
|
[Data 8], [Data 40], [Data 68], [I.23], [I.35], [VI.1], [VI.14], [VI.23] |
||
Prop. LXVIII Cor. 1 |
|
|||
Prop. LXVIII Cor. 2 |
|
|||
Prop. LXIV (pt. 2) |
|
[Data 8], [Data 40], [Data 56], [Data 70], [I.23], [I.35], [VI.1], [VI.14] |
||
Prop. LXIV (pt. 1; cf. LXIII) |
|
[Data 8], [Data 40], [Data 56], [I.23], [I.35], [VI.1], [VI.14] |
||
Prop. LXIV Cor. |
|
|||
Prop. L |
|
|||
Omitted (dup. of Prop. LIX / D.54) |
|
|||
Omitted (case of Prop. LXX / D.62) |
|
|||
Prop. LXXVII Cor. 1 |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data Def. 7], [Data 40], [I.12], [III.21], [VI.4] |
||
Prop. LXXVIII |
|
[Data 8], [Data 66], [Data 68], [Data 79], [I.12], [I.41], [VI.4], [VI.16] |
||
Prop. LXXI |
|
[Data 8], [Data 24], [Data 50], [Data 54], [Data 70], [VI.17], [VI.20] |
||
Prop. LXXII |
|
|||
Prop. LXXIII |
|
Computational Primitives (geometor.model & SymPy)¶
D.68 (Prop. LXV): Apply auxiliary parallelogram EG on EB equal to CD (VI.1), then cancel shared angle via reciprocal sides (Elements VI.14).
D.69 (Prop. LXVI): Shear P1 at constant base & height (Elements I.35) to match Angle(P2); D.40 gives oblique-side ratio, reducing to D.68.
D.70 (Props. LXVII–LXVIII): Equiangular compound-ratio case (Elements VI.14/VI.23), generalized to arbitrary given angles by shearing (I.35 + D.40).
D.71 (Prop. LXVIII Cor. 1): Complete each triangle into its double parallelogram (I.34, V.15) and invoke D.70.
D.72 (Prop. LXVIII Cor. 2): Construct parallelograms along the oblique direction AG/DH equal to twice each triangle (I.34/I.41) and apply D.70.
D.73 (Prop. LXIV (pt. 2)): Converse of D.74 linking reciprocal-side fourth proportionals (VI.14) to parallelogram area ratios (text repaired by Simson Prop. LXIV).
D.74 (Prop. LXIV (pt. 1; cf. LXIII)): Generalization of D.56 from equiangular parallelograms to arbitrary given angles via equal-area shear (I.35 + D.40).
D.75 (Prop. LXIV Cor.): Half-parallelogram specialization of D.74 (Elements I.34, V.15).
D.76 (Prop. L): Right △ABD has given Angle B (Def. 3), hence Species(△ABD) by D.40, giving AD : AB; compose with AB : BC via D.8.
D.77 (Omitted (dup. of Prop. LIX / D.54)): Textual doublet of D.54 preserved in the Greek archetype (Vat. gr. 190) and omitted by Simson.
D.78 (Omitted (case of Prop. LXX / D.62)): Immediate corollary of D.62 (once both side ratios and angle of parallelogram B are given, B is given in species).
D.79 (Prop. LXXVII Cor. 1): Pure similarity lemma for D.80: inscribe △EDF in equal-angle segment on EF (III.21), cut at equal altitude, establish congruence/similarity.
D.80 (Prop. LXXVIII): Since AB*AC : △ABC is given (D.66) and △ABC = 1/2*BC*h_A, BC^2 : BC*h_A = BC : h_A is given; prototype triangle matches by Lemma D.79!
D.81 (Prop. LXXI): Rectangles A*C = B^2 and D*F = E^2 (VI.17): D.70 gives B^2 : E^2, D.54 extracts B : E (and D.50 + D.68 gives converse).
D.82 (Prop. LXXII): Projective rescaling of second and fourth proportionals: A/(B/k) = C/(D/k) (Elements V.22).
D.83 (Prop. LXXIII): Perturbed four-line proportion (Elements V.23 / VI.16): A*D = B*(C/k) <-> D*k*A… -> D : C = B : (k*A).
- order:
53
- type:
notes
- canonical_id:
D.unit.5
- folio:
Menge pp. 126–164
- book:
Propositions 68–83: Proportional Figures
Proportional Parallelograms, Triangles & Four-Line Relations (Propositions 68–83) — Philological & Critical Notes¶
1. Compound Ratios & Oblique Shear Invariance (D.68–D.75)¶
Unit 5 (D.68–D.83) lifts the theory of equiangular parallelograms ([Elements VI.14], [VI.23]) to arbitrary given angles. Euclid’s key geometric operator in D.69, D.70, D.73, and D.74 is an area-preserving Cavalieri shear ([I.35]) on a fixed base $BC$: shearing a parallelogram from given angle $\\theta_1$ to given angle $\\theta_2$ introduces a corner triangle $\\triangle ABP$ whose angles are given, so its slant-side ratio $BA : BP = \sin\\theta_2 / \sin\\theta_1$ is given by D.40!
In his philological commentary (pp. 464–466), Robert Simson showed that late Greek scribes had slightly garbled the reciprocally-proportional clauses of D.73 and D.74, and consolidated them cleanly in Simson Props. LXIII–LXVII.
2. Manuscript Doublets (D.77–D.78) & the Inscribed-Angle Locus Theorem (D.79–D.80)¶
Doublets in Codex P: D.77 repeats the enunciation of D.54 with an alternative square-calibration proof, and D.78 specializes D.62 to rectangles; Simson omitted both as scholiastic doublets, whereas Menge (pp. 148–152) printed them in their traditional numbering so all ancient citations from Pappus remain intact.
The Inscribed-Angle & Parallel-Chord Masterpiece (D.79–D.80): D.80 (Simson Prop. LXXVIII) proves that $\\triangle ABC$ is given in species if $\angle A$ and the ratio $(AB \cdot AC) : BC^2$ are given. Euclid prepares this via the pure locus lemma D.79: two triangles with equal vertex angles $\angle A = \angle D$ and equal base-to-altitude ratios $BC : AG = EF : DH$ can be superposed onto the same circular segment ([III.21], [III.33]), where equal altitudes cut the arc in a parallel line symmetric across the perpendicular bisector! Simson admired this cluster so deeply that he added four companion theorems (Props. LXXVII, LXXIX–LXXXI).
3. Four-Line Proportional Permutations & Apollonian Analysis (D.81–D.83)¶
Propositions D.81–D.83 provide the algebraic rewrite rules for proportions $A : B = C : D$ when one or more terms are replaced by lines having given ratios to them. As Pappus (Synagoge Book VII) demonstrates across his lemmas to Apollonius's Cutting off of a Ratio (Λόγου ἀποτομή), Cutting off of an Area (Χωρίου ἀποτομή), and Determinate Section (Διωρισμένη τομή), D.82 and D.83 allow an analyst to absorb arbitrary given multiplicative constants into auxiliary segments without breaking a four-term proportion.
Cross-Corpus Concordance (Pappus · Petersen · Altshiller-Court · G-Index)¶
D.68 (Prop. LXV) — Elements G-Index:
G.58, G.210, G.225· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9D.69 (Prop. LXVI) — Elements G-Index:
G.35, G.48, G.58, G.64· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9 · Petersen (1879): Shear TransformationD.70 (Props. LXVII–LXVIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.48, G.64, G.210, G.225, G.235· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9 · Petersen (1879): Compound Ratio of SidesD.71 (Prop. LXVIII Cor. 1) — Elements G-Index:
G.58, G.62, G.193· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9D.72 (Prop. LXVIII Cor. 2) — Elements G-Index:
G.56, G.58, G.62, G.70· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9D.73 (Prop. LXIV (pt. 2)) — Elements G-Index:
G.48, G.64, G.210, G.225· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9D.74 (Prop. LXIV (pt. 1; cf. LXIII)) — Elements G-Index:
G.48, G.64, G.210, G.225· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9D.75 (Prop. LXIV Cor.) — Elements G-Index:
G.62, G.193· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9D.76 (Prop. L) — Elements G-Index:
G.35, G.59· Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Altitude-to-Base InvariantD.77 (Omitted (dup. of Prop. LIX / D.54)) — Elements G-Index:
G.232D.78 (Omitted (case of Prop. LXX / D.62)) — Elements G-Index:
G.225D.79 (Prop. LXXVII Cor. 1) — Elements G-Index:
G.35, G.124, G.213· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9 · Petersen (1879): Circumscribed Segment Locus + Parallel Chord · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 10 (Capable Arc Locus)D.80 (Prop. LXXVIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.35, G.70, G.213, G.227· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9 · Petersen (1879): Capable Arc + Parallel Strip Locus · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 55 (Given Angle, Base & Product/Altitude)D.81 (Prop. LXXI) — Elements G-Index:
G.228, G.232· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9D.82 (Prop. LXXII) — Elements G-Index:
G.189, G.195, G.205· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9D.83 (Prop. LXXIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.195, G.206, G.227· Pappus: Synagoge VII.9
Section 6
- order:
60
- type:
chapter
- canonical_id:
D.unit.6
- folio:
Menge pp. 164–186
- book:
Propositions 84–94: Circles, Chords & Angle Bisectors
- description:
Canonical two-line systems xy = A² with x − y = d (D.84), x + y = s (D.85), and x² − y² = C² (D.86); circles given in magnitude and position, inscribed angle loci, and chord/arc determination (D.87–D.89); secant/chord power of a point (D.90–D.92); the celebrated Prop. 93 interior angle-bisector theorem; and its orthogonal chord-reflection corollary (D.94).
Hyperbolic/Elliptic Systems, Circles, Chords & Angle Bisectors (Propositions 84–94)¶
Canonical Two-Segment Quadratic Systems, Circular Loci, Chord Power, and the Prop. 93 Bisector Theorem — D.84–D.94 (Simson LXXXV–C) · Menge (1896) pp. 164–186
Note
Edition Track (English): Canonical two-line systems xy = A² with x − y = d (D.84), x + y = s (D.85), and x² − y² = C² (D.86); circles given in magnitude and position, inscribed angle loci, and chord/arc determination (D.87–D.89); secant/chord power of a point (D.90–D.92); the celebrated Prop. 93 interior angle-bisector theorem; and its orthogonal chord-reflection corollary (D.94). Switch tabs above for Greek (Menge 1896), Summary, or Notes.
- order:
62
- type:
summary
- canonical_id:
D.unit.6
- folio:
Menge pp. 164–186
- book:
Propositions 84–94: Circles, Chords & Angle Bisectors
Hyperbolic/Elliptic Systems, Circles, Chords & Angle Bisectors (Propositions 84–94) — Analytical Summary¶
Unit Overview & Role in Greek Geometric Analysis¶
Canonical two-line systems xy = A² with x − y = d (D.84), x + y = s (D.85), and x² − y² = C² (D.86); circles given in magnitude and position, inscribed angle loci, and chord/arc determination (D.87–D.89); secant/chord power of a point (D.90–D.92); the celebrated Prop. 93 interior angle-bisector theorem; and its orthogonal chord-reflection corollary (D.94).
Scope: 11 propositions (D.84–D.94 (Simson LXXXV–C), Menge pp. 164–186).
Analytical Function: Each proposition below compiles into a forward-chaining inference rule
Given(...) -> Determined(...)within Pappus's Treasury of Analysis (Synagoge Book VII) andgeometor.modelsymbolic DAGs.
Functional Overview (D.84–D.94 (Simson LXXXV–C))¶
ID |
Simson |
Functional Signature |
Key Dependencies |
Tracks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Prop. LXXXV |
|
|||
Prop. LXXXVI |
|
|||
Prop. LXXXIX (cf. LXXXVII–LXXXVIII) |
|
[Data 1], [Data 2], [Data 8], [Data 55], [Data 57], [Data 58], [Data 59], [Data 68], [II.4], [II.6], [VI.1], [VI.17], [VI.20] |
||
Prop. XCI |
|
[Data Def. 5], [Data 3], [Data 40], [Data 53], [III.21], [III.31] |
||
Prop. XCII |
|
[Data Def. 5], [Data 1], [Data 3], [Data 43], [III.21], [III.22], [III.31] |
||
Prop. XCIII |
|
[Data Def. 6], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 29], [III.1], [III.20] |
||
Prop. XCIV |
|
[Data Def. 6], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 43], [Data 53], [III.17], [III.18], [III.31] |
||
Prop. XCV |
|
|||
Prop. XCVI |
|
[Data Def. 6], [Data 3], [Data 4], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 52], [III.1], [III.35] |
||
Prop. XCVII (cf. Prop. XCVIII [Stanhope]) |
|
[Data 1], [Data 52], [Data 87], [III.21], [III.26], [V.12], [V.16], [VI.3], [VI.4], [VI.16] |
||
Prop. XCIX (cf. Prop. C [Stewart]) |
|
[Data Def. 6], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 91], [Data 92], [I.4], [I.26], [I.29], [III.31], [III.35] |
Computational Primitives (geometor.model & SymPy)¶
D.84 (Prop. LXXXV): Canonical difference-and-product solver: x*(x + d)*sin B = S reduces directly to hyperbolic application D.59!
D.85 (Prop. LXXXVI): Canonical sum-and-product (Vieta) solver: x*(s - x)*sin B = S reduces directly to elliptic application D.58!
D.86 (Prop. LXXXIX (cf. LXXXVII–LXXXVIII)): Biquadratic system x*y = S’, y^2 - k*x^2 = D -> k*x^4 + D*x^2 - S’^2 = 0 solved in radicals via quadratic substitution (D.59/D.58 + D.55)!
D.87 (Prop. XCI): Draw diameter BD (Mag(BD) = 2R by Def. 5); join DC (∠BCD = 90° by III.31, ∠BDC = ∠BAC by III.21); right △BCD given by D.40 + D.53!
D.88 (Prop. XCII): Converse of D.87: diameter BD = 2R (Def. 5), ratio BC : BD given (D.1), right △BCD given in species by D.43, fixing ∠BDC and supplementary arc angle (III.22)!
D.89 (Prop. XCIII): Join centre D to B (D.26); central ∠BDC = 2·∠BAC (Elements III.20) is given, so ray DC (D.29) meets Circle(D, R) (D.25) at given point C!
D.90 (Prop. XCIV): Join centre E to D (D.26); semicircle on ED cuts Circle(E, R) at A (∠EAD = 90° by III.31/III.18), fixing Pos(A) and Mag(DA)!
D.91 (Prop. XCV): Draw tangent DA (Mag(DA) given by D.90, DA^2 given by D.52); by Elements III.36, Rect(DB, DC) = DA^2 is invariant across all secants!
D.92 (Prop. XCVI): Draw diameter FEG through centre E and D: FD = R + ED (D.3) and DG = R - ED (D.4) are given; by Elements III.35, BD*DC = FD*DG!
D.93 (Prop. XCVII (cf. Prop. XCVIII [Stanhope])): Masterpiece of Data: chords BC and BD = DC are given (D.87); VI.3 + V.12 + △ACE ~ △ADB ~ △BDE yield (AB+AC):AD = BC:BD and (AB+AC)*ED = BC*BD!
D.94 (Prop. XCIX (cf. Prop. C [Stewart])): Produce EF to G on circle: since ∠GAE = ∠DAE = 90° (I.29), GE… wait: ∠AEG = 90° -> AG is a diameter through centre H (III.31), so △AHD ~= △GHF (I.26), fixing HF = HD (Pos(F)) and AD*EF = GF*EF (D.92/D.91)!
- order:
63
- type:
notes
- canonical_id:
D.unit.6
- folio:
Menge pp. 164–186
- book:
Propositions 84–94: Circles, Chords & Angle Bisectors
Hyperbolic/Elliptic Systems, Circles, Chords & Angle Bisectors (Propositions 84–94) — Philological & Critical Notes¶
1. Canonical Vieta Systems (D.84–D.85) & the Biquadratic Theorem (D.86)¶
Unit 6 opens (D.84–D.86) with the three most famous algebraic propositions in the Data—solving simultaneous two-variable quadratic systems:
Product & Difference (D.84): $x y \sin\\theta = S$ and $y - x = d \implies$ apply $S$ to $d$ with species-given rhombus excess (D.59). When $\\theta = 90^\circ$ and $S = d^2$, $x(x + d) = d^2$ yields the golden ratio $y/x = \phi$!
Product & Sum (D.85): $x y \sin\\theta = S$ and $x + y = s \implies$ apply $S$ to $s$ with species-given rhombus defect (D.58), subject to $S \le \frac{1}{4}s^2 \sin\\theta$.
Product & Affine Ratio of Squares (D.86): $x y \sin\\theta = S$ and $y^2 - C = k x^2$. In 1703 David Gregory (Praefatio) suspected the Greek text of D.86 might be corrupt; Robert Simson (pp. 467–468) brilliantly vindicated the integrity of Euclid’s biquadratic proof (which completes the square via $y^2 - C = y(y - d)$ and $(2y - d)^2 = 4y(y - d) + d^2$, [II.8]) and added Simson Prop. LXXXVIII covering the sum-of-squares system $x y = S,\; x^2 + y^2 = C$.
2. Chord Trigonometry (D.87–D.89) & Power of a Point (D.90–D.92)¶
Propositions D.87–D.89 establish the constructive equivalence between inscribed angles and chord lengths in circles given in magnitude or position (see data_06_circle_angle_locus.svg). In Book I of the Syntaxis (Almagest), Claudius Ptolemy builds his entire table of chords (Πραγματεία τῶν ἐν κύκλῳ εὐθειῶν) on this foundation alongside D.93.
Propositions D.90–D.92 reformulate [Elements III.17], [III.35], and [III.36] as the invariance of the power of a given point $|OP^2 - R^2|$ with respect to a position-given circle: every secant from an external given point (D.91) or chord through an internal given point (D.92) cuts off segments whose rectangle $PA \cdot PB$ is given in magnitude—the invariant engine behind Apollonius's Tangencies and Plane Loci as well as modern radical-axis geometry (Altshiller-Court 1952).
3. The Crown Jewels (D.93–D.94) & Earl Stanhope’s and Matthew Stewart’s Theorems¶
The treatise culminates in two virtuoso cyclic-similarity theorems (D.93–D.94, with D.93 rendered interactively in data_07_prop93_bisector.svg):
Euclid’s D.93 & Earl Stanhope’s Exterior-Bisector Theorem (`Simson Prop. XCVIII [F]`): When a given chord $BC$ cuts off a segment admitting given $\angle BAC$ in a magnitude-given circle, and the interior bisector $AD$ of $\angle BAC$ meets $BC$ at $E$ and the opposite arc at $D$, Euclid proves both that $(BA + AC) : AD = BC : BD$ is given in ratio and that $(BA + AC) \cdot ED = BD^2$ is given in magnitude! In his 1762/1806 edition (Prop. XCVIII & p. 469), Simson paired D.93 with its dual communicated to him by Philip Stanhope, 2nd Earl Stanhope (Earl Stanhope): if instead the exterior angle at $A$ is bisected by chord $AD'$ meeting $BC$ produced at $E'$ and the circle at $D'$, then the difference $|BA - AC|$ has a given ratio to $AD'$, and $|BA - AC| \cdot E'D' = BD'^2$ is given in magnitude!
Euclid’s D.94 & Matthew Stewart’s Generalization (`Simson Prop. C`): Immediately following D.94, Simson (Prop. C & pp. 469–470) published a remarkable generalization discovered by his pupil and colleague Matthew Stewart (author of Some General Theorems of Considerable Use in the Higher Parts of Mathematics, 1746), showing how fixed lines and chords inflected in a given circle preserve given combinations of products and squares—a direct bridge from Alexandrian Data to eighteenth-century Scottish synthetic geometry.
Cross-Corpus Concordance (Pappus · Petersen · Altshiller-Court · G-Index)¶
D.84 (Prop. LXXXV) — Elements G-Index:
G.58· Pappus: Synagoge VII.10 · Petersen (1879): Hyperbolic Application of Areas · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 51D.85 (Prop. LXXXVI) — Elements G-Index:
G.37, G.58· Pappus: Synagoge VII.10 · Petersen (1879): Elliptic Application of Areas · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 50 (Sum & Product of Segments)D.86 (Prop. LXXXIX (cf. LXXXVII–LXXXVIII)) — Elements G-Index:
G.85, G.88, G.210, G.228, G.232· Pappus: Synagoge VII.10 · Petersen (1879): Biquadratic Reduction (Hyperbola cap Hyperbola)D.87 (Prop. XCI) — Elements G-Index:
G.124, G.139· Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Chord Table / Law of Sines · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 10D.88 (Prop. XCII) — Elements G-Index:
G.124, G.125, G.139· Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Inverse Chord LookupD.89 (Prop. XCIII) — Elements G-Index:
G.98, G.123· Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Central-Inscribed Angle Rotation · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 10 (Inscribed Angle Arc)D.90 (Prop. XCIV) — Elements G-Index:
G.119, G.120, G.139· Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Thales Semicircle Tangent · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 12 (Tangent from External Point)D.91 (Prop. XCV) — Elements G-Index:
G.119, G.144· Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Exterior Power of a Point · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 310 (Power of a Point)D.92 (Prop. XCVI) — Elements G-Index:
G.98, G.143· Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Interior Power of a Point · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 310 (Intersecting Chords / Power of a Point)D.93 (Prop. XCVII (cf. Prop. XCVIII [Stanhope])) — Elements G-Index:
G.124, G.133, G.190, G.195, G.212, G.213, G.227· Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Angle-Bisector Circumcircle Similarity · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 134 (Inscribed Angle Bisector)D.94 (Prop. XCIX (cf. Prop. C [Stewart])) — Elements G-Index:
G.24, G.51, G.56, G.139, G.143· Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Central Point Reflection + Chord Power · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 310