Interactive geometric-algebra diagram (Menge pp. 104–110): Left panel shows elliptic application (ἔλλειψις, D.58), applying given area AHKE to given line AB (midpoint M) deficient by species-given figure EKBG of breadth EK. Right panel shows hyperbolic application (ὑπερβολή, D.59), applying given area PRST along extended base PR (from given segment endpoint Q bisected at W, crossbar QW) exceeding by species-given figure on RS enclosed within gnomon square PQUV.
Proposition 58 [νη΄ · Prop. LXXXIII]¶
Functional Signature: Given(Mag(S), Mag(a), Species(Defect)) -> Determined(Roots of a*x - c*x^2 = S) [diorismos] · Dependencies: [Data 3], [Data 4], [Data 52], [Data 55], [II.5], [VI.24], [VI.27], [VI.28]
Let a given area $AC$ be applied to a straight line $AB$ given in magnitude, deficient by a parallelogram $CDFB$ given in species ([VI.28]). I say that both the breadths and bases of the deficiency ($BD, DF$ and $AD$) are given in magnitude.
Bisect $AB$ at $E$ ([I.10]). Since $AB$ is given in magnitude, its half $EB$ ($= AE$) is given in magnitude ([Data 7]). On $EB$ describe the parallelogram $EFGH$ similar and similarly situated to the species-given defect $CDFB$ ([VI.18]), and complete the diagram of [VI.28]. Because $EFGH$ is given in species and described on the given segment $EB$, $EFGH$ is given in magnitude ([Data 52]). By the gnomon identity ([II.5] generalized to equiangular parallelograms in [VI.27]–[VI.28]), $EFGH$ equals the applied area $AC$ together with the inner parallelogram $KHLN$ (which is similar and similarly situated to $EFGH$ on segment $ED = EB - BD$). Since both $EFGH$ and $AC$ are given in magnitude (with $AC \le EFGH$ by the diorismos of [VI.27]), the difference $KHLN = EFGH - AC$ is given in magnitude ([Data 4]). Because $KHLN \sim CDFB$ is also given in species, its side $KH$ ($= ED$) is given in magnitude ([Data 55]). Subtracting $ED$ from given $EB$ gives $BD$ ([Data 4]), adding $ED$ to given $AE$ gives $AD$ ([Data 3]), and from species-given $CDFB$ on $BD$ its breadth $DF$ ($= CB$) is given in magnitude ([Data 2]).