Content of type 'notes'
Marinus’s Protheoria — Philological & Critical Notes
At the close of the Protheoria (§ 18, Menge p. 256), Marinus invokes Pappus's lost Commentary on the Data (Synagoge VII) to assert that Euclid followed the method of analysis rather than synthesis. In the Preface to his 1762/1806 edition (pp. 357–358), Robert Simson sharply objected:
Definition 1 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 1 [α΄ · Def. I]: Given in Magnitude
Definition 10 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 10 [ι΄ · Def. X]: Affine Defect (δοθέντι ἔλασσον)
Definition 11 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 11 [ια΄ · Omitted (expanded verbally in Props. XIV–XXVII)]: Affine-Ratio Excess (δοθέντι μεῖζον ἢ ἐν λόγῳ)
Definition 12 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 12 [ιβ΄ · Omitted (expanded verbally in Props. XIV–XXVII)]: Affine-Ratio Defect (δοθέντι ἔλασσον ἢ ἐν λόγῳ)
Definition 13 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 13 [ιγ΄ · Omitted (late scholium; bracketed by Menge)]: Dropped Line / Katēgmenē [Scholium]
Definition 14 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 14 [ιδ΄ · Omitted (late scholium; bracketed by Menge)]: Erected Line / Anēgmenē [Scholium]
Definition 15 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 15 [ιε΄ · Omitted (late scholium; bracketed by Menge)]: Parallel to Position / Para Thesei [Scholium]
Definition 2 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 2 [β΄ · Def. II]: Given in Ratio
Definition 3 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 3 [γ΄ · Def. III]: Given in Species
Definition 4 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 4 [δ΄ · Def. IV (cf. Def. A)]: Given in Position
Definition 5 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 5 [ε΄ · Def. V]: Circle Given in Magnitude
Definition 6 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 6 [ϛ΄ · Def. VI]: Circle Given in Position & Magnitude
Definition 7 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 7 [ζ΄ · Def. VII]: Segment Given in Magnitude
Definition 8 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 8 [η΄ · Def. VIII]: Segment Given in Position & Magnitude
Definition 9 — Philological & Critical Notes
Definition 9 [θ΄ · Def. IX]: Affine Excess (δοθέντι μεῖζον)
Proposition 1 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.1 (Prop. I) — Elements G-Index: G.183, G.195 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.3
Proposition 10 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.10 (Prop. XVI) — Elements G-Index: G.199, G.201 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 11 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.11 (Prop. XVII) — Elements G-Index: G.190, G.195, G.199, G.201 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 12 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.12 (Prop. V) — Elements G-Index: G.19 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 13 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.13 (Prop. XXIV) — Elements G-Index: G.189, G.201 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 14 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.14 (Prop. XVIII) — Elements G-Index: G.190, G.199 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 15 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.15 (Prop. XIX) — Elements G-Index: G.201 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 16 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.16 (Prop. XX) — Elements G-Index: G.201 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 17 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.17 (Prop. XXV) — Elements G-Index: G.189 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 18 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.18 (Prop. XXVI) — Elements G-Index: G.189 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 19 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.19 (Prop. XXVII) — Elements G-Index: G.189 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 2 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.2 (Prop. II) — Elements G-Index: G.189, G.187, G.222 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.3 · Petersen (1879): Similarity / Scaling · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 18 (Fourth Proportional)
Proposition 20 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.20 (Prop. XXIII) — Elements G-Index: G.201 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 21 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.21 (Omitted (cf. Prop. XVIII)) — Elements G-Index: G.199 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 22 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.22 (Prop. XI) — Elements G-Index: G.207 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.4
Proposition 23 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.23 (Prop. XII) — Elements G-Index: G.189, G.195, G.201 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method
Proposition 24 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.24 (Prop. XIII) — Elements G-Index: G.223, G.228, G.234 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.5 · Petersen (1879): Mean Proportional · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 21 (Mean Proportional)
Proposition 25 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.25 (Prop. XXVIII) — Elements G-Index: G.14, G.4 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Method of Loci (Two-Locus Intersection) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 1 (Intersection of Loci)
Proposition 26 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.26 (Prop. XXIX) — Elements G-Index: G.14, G.15 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Method of Loci · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 2
Proposition 27 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.27 (Prop. XXX) — Elements G-Index: G.15, G.10 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Method of Loci (Line + Circle) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 3
Proposition 28 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.28 (Prop. XXXI) — Elements G-Index: G.53, G.56, G.57, G.58 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Parallel Translation · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 8 (Parallel Locus)
Proposition 29 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.29 (Prop. XXXII) — Elements G-Index: G.48 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Rotation / Angular Locus · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 5 (Given Angle Ray)
Proposition 3 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.3 (Prop. III) — Elements G-Index: G.36 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 6 (Sum of Segments)
Proposition 30 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.30 (Prop. XXXIII) — Elements G-Index: G.48, G.56, G.58 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Parallel Translation · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 8
Proposition 31 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.31 (Prop. XXXIV) — Elements G-Index: G.35, G.15 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Method of Loci (Circle + Line) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 11 (Circle-Line Intersection)
Proposition 32 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.32 (Prop. XXXV) — Elements G-Index: G.56, G.58, G.62 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Parallel Translation · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 31 (Translation between Parallels)
Proposition 33 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.33 (Prop. XXXVI) — Elements G-Index: G.56, G.62 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Parallel Translation · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 31
Proposition 34 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.34 (Prop. XXXVIII) — Elements G-Index: G.35, G.211, G.213 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Homothecy / Multiplication of Curves · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 39 (Homothetic Ratio across Parallels)
Proposition 35 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.35 (Prop. XXXIX (pt. 1)) — Elements G-Index: G.211 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Homothecy / Multiplication of Curves · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 40 (Homothetic Line Locus)
Proposition 36 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.36 (Prop. XXXIX (pt. 2)) — Elements G-Index: G.211 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Homothecy / Multiplication of Curves · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 40 (Homothetic Line Locus)
Proposition 37 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.37 (Prop. XL (pt. 1)) — Elements G-Index: G.57, G.62, G.211 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Method of Loci · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 9 (Parallel Intermediate Locus)
Proposition 38 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.38 (Prop. XL (pt. 2)) — Elements G-Index: G.57, G.62, G.211 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.6 · Petersen (1879): Method of Loci · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 9
Proposition 4 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.4 (Prop. IV) — Elements G-Index: G.19 · Petersen (1879): Algebraic Method · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 6 (Difference of Segments)
Proposition 41 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.41 (SAS-ratio $\to$ species, via [VI.6]);
Proposition 42 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.42 (SSS-ratios $\to$ species, via [VI.5]).
Proposition 43 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.43 (Prop. XLVI) — Elements G-Index: G.79, G.216 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Method of Similarity (Right-HL) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 14 (Right Triangle HL)
Proposition 44 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.44 (Prop. XLVII) — Elements G-Index: G.37, G.216 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Method of Similarity (SSA Bifurcation) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 15 (Ambiguous Case SSA)
Proposition 45 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.45 (Prop. XLVIII) — Elements G-Index: G.25, G.59 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Auxiliary Isosceles Extension · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 53 (Sum of Two Sides)
Proposition 46 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.46 (Prop. XLIX) — Elements G-Index: G.25, G.31, G.59 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Auxiliary Isosceles Extension · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 53 (Sum of Two Sides)
Proposition 47 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.47 proves that every species-given $n$-gon triangulates into $(n-2)$ species-given triangles by ear-clipping diagonals (D.41).
Proposition 48 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.48–D.51 establish that any two species-given figures on the same or ratio-given segments have a given area ratio, culminating in D.52 (species-given figure on a magnitude-given segment is given in area, calibrated against the unit square $AB^2$).
Proposition 49 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.49 (Prop. LIII) — Elements G-Index: G.232 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Polygon Triangulation
Proposition 5 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.5 (Prop. VI) — Elements G-Index: G.201 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.4
Proposition 50 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.50 (Prop. LIV) — Elements G-Index: G.221, G.231, G.232 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Duplicate Ratio Scaling
Proposition 51 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.51 (Prop. LV) — Elements G-Index: G.229, G.232 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Similarity Bridge
Proposition 52 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.52 (Prop. LVI) — Elements G-Index: G.75 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Square Reference Unit
Proposition 53 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.53 (Prop. LVII) — Elements G-Index: G.205 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.7
Proposition 54 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.54 and D.55 invert the quadratic scaling map $S \propto x^2$! Using D.24 (which extracted the square root of a ratio via the geometric mean [VI.13]), D.54 deduces linear side-ratios from area-ratios, and D.55 proves the grand converse of D.52: any figure given both in species and in magnitude has all its sides given in magnitude—the exact analytical counterpart of [Elements VI.25] (constructing a figure similar to one given figure and equal in area to another).
Proposition 55 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.55 (Prop. LX) — Elements G-Index: G.75, G.229 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Similarity + Quadratic Scaling · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 49 (Constructing a Figure of Given Species & Area)
Proposition 56 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.56 (Prop. LXIII) — Elements G-Index: G.210, G.225 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Application of Areas
Proposition 57 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.57 (Prop. LXI) — Elements G-Index: G.58, G.75, G.210 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Parabolic Application of Areas · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 47 (Transformation of Areas)
Proposition 58 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.58 (Prop. LXXXIII) — Elements G-Index: G.87, G.236, G.239, G.240 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Elliptic Application of Areas (Quadratic) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 50 (Elliptic Application)
Proposition 59 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.59 (Prop. LXXXIV) — Elements G-Index: G.88, G.236, G.241 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Hyperbolic Application of Areas (Quadratic) · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 51 (Hyperbolic Application / Golden Section)
Proposition 6 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.6 (Prop. VII) — Elements G-Index: G.199, G.201 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.4
Proposition 60 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.60 (Prop. LXXXII) — Elements G-Index: G.236 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Gnomonic Scaling
Proposition 61 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.61 (Prop. LXIX) — Elements G-Index: G.37, G.56, G.58, G.64, G.210 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Area-to-Aspect Conversion
Proposition 62 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.62 (Prop. LXX) — Elements G-Index: G.229, G.232 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Area-to-Aspect Conversion
Proposition 63 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.63 (Omitted (case of Prop. LIII)) — Elements G-Index: G.75 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.8
Proposition 64 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.64 (Prop. LXXIV) — Elements G-Index: G.35, G.59, G.94, G.210 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Cosine Projection Law
Proposition 65 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.65 (Prop. LXXV) — Elements G-Index: G.35, G.59, G.95, G.210 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Cosine Projection Law
Proposition 66 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.66 (Prop. LXII Cor.) — Elements G-Index: G.35, G.70, G.210 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Trigonometric Area Formula
Proposition 67 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.67 (Prop. LXXVI) — Elements G-Index: G.25, G.37, G.58, G.59, G.88, G.211, G.227 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.8 · Petersen (1879): Isosceles Auxiliary Extension + Secant-Product
Proposition 68 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.68 (Prop. LXV) — Elements G-Index: G.58, G.210, G.225 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9
Proposition 69 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.69 (Prop. LXVI) — Elements G-Index: G.35, G.48, G.58, G.64 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9 · Petersen (1879): Shear Transformation
Proposition 7 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.7 (Prop. VIII) — Elements G-Index: G.220 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.4 · Petersen (1879): Similarity / Ratio Division · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 19 (Internal Division)
Proposition 70 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.70 (Props. LXVII–LXVIII) — Elements G-Index: G.48, G.64, G.210, G.225, G.235 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9 · Petersen (1879): Compound Ratio of Sides
Proposition 71 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.71 (Prop. LXVIII Cor. 1) — Elements G-Index: G.58, G.62, G.193 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9
Proposition 72 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.72 (Prop. LXVIII Cor. 2) — Elements G-Index: G.56, G.58, G.62, G.70 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9
Proposition 73 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.73 (Prop. LXIV (pt. 2)) — Elements G-Index: G.48, G.64, G.210, G.225 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9
Proposition 74 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.74 (Prop. LXIV (pt. 1; cf. LXIII)) — Elements G-Index: G.48, G.64, G.210, G.225 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9
Proposition 75 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.75 (Prop. LXIV Cor.) — Elements G-Index: G.62, G.193 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9
Proposition 76 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.76 (Prop. L) — Elements G-Index: G.35, G.59 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.7 · Petersen (1879): Altitude-to-Base Invariant
Proposition 77 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.77 (Omitted (dup. of Prop. LIX / D.54)) — Elements G-Index: G.232
Proposition 78 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.78 (Omitted (case of Prop. LXX / D.62)) — Elements G-Index: G.225
Proposition 79 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.79 (Prop. LXXVII Cor. 1) — Elements G-Index: G.35, G.124, G.213 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9 · Petersen (1879): Circumscribed Segment Locus + Parallel Chord · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 10 (Capable Arc Locus)
Proposition 8 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.8 (Prop. IX) — Elements G-Index: G.183, G.189, G.205 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.4
Proposition 80 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.80 (Prop. LXXVIII) — Elements G-Index: G.35, G.70, G.213, G.227 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9 · Petersen (1879): Capable Arc + Parallel Strip Locus · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 55 (Given Angle, Base & Product/Altitude)
Proposition 81 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.81 (Prop. LXXI) — Elements G-Index: G.228, G.232 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9
Proposition 82 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.82 (Prop. LXXII) — Elements G-Index: G.189, G.195, G.205 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9
Proposition 83 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.83 (Prop. LXXIII) — Elements G-Index: G.195, G.206, G.227 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.9
Proposition 84 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.84 (Prop. LXXXV) — Elements G-Index: G.58 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.10 · Petersen (1879): Hyperbolic Application of Areas · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 51
Proposition 85 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.85 (Prop. LXXXVI) — Elements G-Index: G.37, G.58 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.10 · Petersen (1879): Elliptic Application of Areas · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 50 (Sum & Product of Segments)
Proposition 86 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.86 (Prop. LXXXIX (cf. LXXXVII–LXXXVIII)) — Elements G-Index: G.85, G.88, G.210, G.228, G.232 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.10 · Petersen (1879): Biquadratic Reduction (Hyperbola cap Hyperbola)
Proposition 87 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.87 (Prop. XCI) — Elements G-Index: G.124, G.139 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Chord Table / Law of Sines · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 10
Proposition 88 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.88 (Prop. XCII) — Elements G-Index: G.124, G.125, G.139 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Inverse Chord Lookup
Proposition 89 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.89 (Prop. XCIII) — Elements G-Index: G.98, G.123 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Central-Inscribed Angle Rotation · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 10 (Inscribed Angle Arc)
Proposition 9 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.9 (Prop. X) — Elements G-Index: G.189, G.205 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.4
Proposition 90 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.90 (Prop. XCIV) — Elements G-Index: G.119, G.120, G.139 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Thales Semicircle Tangent · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 12 (Tangent from External Point)
Proposition 91 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.91 (Prop. XCV) — Elements G-Index: G.119, G.144 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Exterior Power of a Point · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 310 (Power of a Point)
Proposition 92 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.92 (Prop. XCVI) — Elements G-Index: G.98, G.143 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Interior Power of a Point · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 310 (Intersecting Chords / Power of a Point)
Proposition 93 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.93 (Prop. XCVII (cf. Prop. XCVIII [Stanhope])) — Elements G-Index: G.124, G.133, G.190, G.195, G.212, G.213, G.227 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Angle-Bisector Circumcircle Similarity · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 134 (Inscribed Angle Bisector)
Proposition 94 — Philological & Critical Notes
D.94 (Prop. XCIX (cf. Prop. C [Stewart])) — Elements G-Index: G.24, G.51, G.56, G.139, G.143 · Pappus: Synagoge VII.11 · Petersen (1879): Central Point Reflection + Chord Power · Altshiller-Court (1952): § 310