Proposition 11 [ια΄ · Prop. XVII]¶
Functional Signature: Given((AB - D) : BC = k) <-> Determined((AB - k/(k+1)*D) : (AB + BC) = k/(k+1)) · Dependencies: [Data Def. 11], [Data 2], [Data 4], [Data 6], [V.12], [V.16], [V.18], [V.19]
First, let the magnitude $AB$ be greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to $BC$. I say that $AB$ is also greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to the compound $AC$.
Subtract the given magnitude $AD$ from $AB$ ([Data Def. 11]); then the ratio $DB : BC$ is given. Invertendo and componendo, the ratio $DC : DB$ is given ([Data 6]), so invertendo $DB : DC$ is given. Let the ratio $AD : DE$ be made the same with $DB : DC$ ([Data Def. 2]); since $DB : DC$ is given and $AD$ is given, $DE$ is given ([Data 2]), whence the whole $AE = AD + DE$ is given ([Data 3]). Moreover, since $AD : DE = DB : DC$, it follows by proportion manipulation ([V.12], [V.19]) that the remainder $EB$ is to the compound $AC$ as $DB$ is to $DC$. Thus the ratio $EB : AC$ is given while $AE$ is given; therefore $AB$ is greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to $AC$ ([Data Def. 11]).
Conversely, let $AB$ be greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to the compound $AC$. I say that $AB$ is also greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to the remainder $BC$.
Subtract from $AB$ the given magnitude $AE$ ([Data Def. 11]), so that the ratio $EB : AC$ is given, whence invertendo $AC : EB$ is given. Make $AE : ED$ have the same ratio as $AC : EB$ ([Data Def. 2]). Because $AE$ is given, $ED$ is given ([Data 2]), and therefore the remainder $AD$ is given ([Data 4]). Since $AC : EB = AE : ED$, convertendo, alternando, and separando ([V.19], [V.17]), the ratio $BC : DB$ (and hence $DB : BC$) is given while $AD$ is given. Therefore $AB$ is greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to $BC$ ([Data Def. 11]).