Proposition 10 [ι΄ · Prop. XVI]

If a magnitude be greater than a magnitude by a given magnitude than in ratio, the compounded magnitude will also be greater than the same by a given magnitude than in ratio; and if the compounded magnitude be greater than the same by a given magnitude than in ratio, either the remainder is also greater than the same by a given magnitude than in ratio, or the remainder together with the following magnitude to which the other has a given ratio is given.

Functional Signature: Given((AB - D) : BC = k) <-> Determined(((AB+BC) - D) : BC = k+1 | (AB + BE = D where BC:BE given)) · Dependencies: [Data Def. 9], [Data Def. 11], [Data 3], [Data 4], [Data 5], [Data 6], [V.18], [V.19]

First, let the magnitude $AB$ be greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to $BC$. I say that the compound $AC$ is also greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to the same $BC$.

From $AB$ let the given magnitude $AD$ be subtracted ([Data Def. 11]); then the ratio of the remainder $DB$ to $BC$ is given. Componendo, the ratio $DC : BC$ is given ([Data 6], [V.18]). And since $AD$ is given, the whole $CA$ is greater than $DC$ by the given magnitude $AD$, and hence $AC$ is greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to $BC$ ([Data Def. 11]).

Conversely, let the compound $AC$ be greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to $BC$. I say that the remaining part $AB$ is either greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to $BC$, or else $AB$ together with a magnitude to which $BC$ has a given ratio is given.

Subtract the given excess from $AC$ ([Data Def. 11]). This given magnitude is either less than $AB$ or greater than $AB$ (if equal to $AB$, then $BC$ itself is in a given ratio to $BC$, a boundary case). First let it be less than $AB$, and let it be $AD$: then $DC : CB$ is given, so separando $DB : BC$ is given ([Data 5], [V.17]); and $AD$ is given, so $AB$ is greater by a given magnitude than in ratio to $BC$ ([Data Def. 11]). Next let the given magnitude be greater than $AB$, and let $AE$ be set equal to it (with $E$ falling between $B$ and $C$): then the remainder $EC$ has a given ratio to $CB$, so invertendo $BC : EC$ is given, and convertendo $BC : BE$ is given ([Data 5]). Yet $AE = AB + BE$ is given; therefore $AB$ together with $BE$—to which $BC$ has a given ratio—is given.