Master Concordance & Dependency Matrix¶
Complete cross-reference of Euclid's Data across Heinrich Menge's 1896 Teubner Greek text (Vat. gr. 190), Robert Simson's 1762/1806 critical edition, the Heath Elements, the geometor.elements G-Index, Pappus's Synagoge Book VII, and Julius Petersen's Methods and Theories (1879).
Definitions (D.def.1 – D.def.15)¶
Menge ID |
Page |
Simson ID |
Mode of Givenness |
Functional Predicate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Def. I |
Magnitude (μεγέθει) |
|
|
|
Def. II |
Ratio (λόγῳ) |
|
|
|
Def. III |
Species (εἴδει) |
|
|
|
Def. IV (cf. Def. A) |
Position (θέσει) |
|
|
|
Def. V |
Circle in Magnitude |
|
|
|
Def. VI |
Circle in Position & Magnitude |
|
|
|
Def. VII |
Circular Segment in Magnitude |
|
|
|
Def. VIII |
Circular Segment in Position & Magnitude |
|
|
|
Def. IX |
Affine Excess (δοθέντι μεῖζον) |
|
|
|
Def. X |
Affine Defect (δοθέντι ἔλασσον) |
|
|
|
Omitted (expanded verbally in Props. XIV–XXVII) |
Affine-Ratio Excess (δοθέντι μεῖζον ἢ ἐν λόγῳ) |
|
|
|
Omitted (expanded verbally in Props. XIV–XXVII) |
Affine-Ratio Defect (δοθέντι ἔλασσον ἢ ἐν λόγῳ) |
|
|
|
Omitted (late scholium; bracketed by Menge) |
Directed Ordinate [Bracketed Scholium] |
|
|
|
Omitted (late scholium; bracketed by Menge) |
Erected Line [Bracketed Scholium] |
|
|
|
Omitted (late scholium; bracketed by Menge) |
Parallel to Position [Bracketed Scholium] |
|
Propositions (D.1 – D.94)¶
Menge ID |
Page |
Simson |
Functional Signature |
Data & Elements Deps |
G-Index / Loci |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Prop. I |
|
G.183, G.195, Synagoge VII.3 |
||
|
Prop. II |
|
G.189, G.187, G.222, Synagoge VII.3 |
||
|
Prop. III |
|
G.36 |
||
|
Prop. IV |
|
G.19 |
||
|
Prop. VI |
|
G.201, Synagoge VII.4 |
||
|
Prop. VII |
|
G.199, G.201, Synagoge VII.4 |
||
|
Prop. VIII |
|
G.220, Synagoge VII.4 |
||
|
Prop. IX |
|
G.183, G.189, G.205, Synagoge VII.4 |
||
|
Prop. X |
|
G.189, G.205, Synagoge VII.4 |
||
|
Prop. XVI |
|
[Data Def. 9], [Data Def. 11], [Data 3], [Data 4], [Data 5], [Data 6], [V.18], [V.19] |
G.199, G.201, Synagoge VII.5 |
|
|
Prop. XVII |
|
[Data Def. 11], [Data 2], [Data 4], [Data 6], [V.12], [V.16], [V.18], [V.19] |
G.190, G.195, G.199, Synagoge VII.5 |
|
|
Prop. V |
|
G.19 |
||
|
Prop. XXIV |
|
G.189, G.201, Synagoge VII.5 |
||
|
Prop. XVIII |
|
[Data Def. 11], [Data 1], [Data 2], [Data 4], [Data 8], [V.12], [V.18] |
G.190, G.199, Synagoge VII.5 |
|
|
Prop. XIX |
|
[Data Def. 11], [Data 1], [Data 2], [Data 4], [Data 8], [V.19] |
G.201, Synagoge VII.5 |
|
|
Prop. XX |
|
G.201, Synagoge VII.5 |
||
|
Prop. XXV |
|
G.189, Synagoge VII.5 |
||
|
Prop. XXVI |
|
G.189, Synagoge VII.5 |
||
|
Prop. XXVII |
|
G.189, Synagoge VII.5 |
||
|
Prop. XXIII |
|
[Data Def. 11], [Data 1], [Data 2], [Data 4], [Data 8], [V.19] |
G.201, Synagoge VII.5 |
|
|
Omitted (cf. Prop. XVIII) |
|
G.199, Synagoge VII.5 |
||
|
Prop. XI |
|
G.207, Synagoge VII.4 |
||
|
Prop. XII |
|
G.189, G.195, G.201, Synagoge VII.5 |
||
|
Prop. XIII |
|
[Data Def. 1], [Data Def. 2], [Data 1], [Data 2], [VI.13], [VI.17], [VI.22] |
G.223, G.228, G.234, Synagoge VII.5 |
|
|
Prop. XXVIII |
|
G.14, G.4, Synagoge VII.6 |
||
|
Prop. XXIX |
|
G.14, G.15, Synagoge VII.6 |
||
|
Prop. XXX |
|
[Data Def. 1], [Data Def. 4], [Data Def. 6], [Post. 3], [I Def. 15] |
G.15, G.10, Synagoge VII.6 |
|
|
Prop. XXXI |
|
G.53, G.56, G.57, Synagoge VII.6 |
||
|
Prop. XXXII |
|
G.48, Synagoge VII.6 |
||
|
Prop. XXXIII |
|
G.48, G.56, G.58, Synagoge VII.6 |
||
|
Prop. XXXIV |
|
[Data Def. 4], [Data Def. 6], [Data 25], [Data 26], [I.12], [Post. 3] |
G.35, G.15, Synagoge VII.6 |
|
|
Prop. XXXV |
|
G.56, G.58, G.62, Synagoge VII.6 |
||
|
Prop. XXXVI |
|
[Data Def. 1], [Data Def. 4], [Data 28], [Data 31], [I.29], [I.34] |
G.56, G.62, Synagoge VII.6 |
|
|
Prop. XXXVIII |
|
[Data 1], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 30], [I.12], [VI.2], [VI.4] |
G.35, G.211, G.213, Synagoge VII.6 |
|
|
Prop. XXXIX (pt. 1) |
|
[Data 7], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 28], [Data 30], [VI.2] |
G.211, Synagoge VII.6 |
|
|
Prop. XXXIX (pt. 2) |
|
[Data 2], [Data 6], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 28], [Data 30], [VI.2] |
G.211, Synagoge VII.6 |
|
|
Prop. XL (pt. 1) |
|
[Data 7], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 28], [Data 30], [I.30], [I.34], [VI.2] |
G.57, G.62, G.211, Synagoge VII.6 |
|
|
Prop. XL (pt. 2) |
|
[Data 2], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 28], [Data 30], [I.30], [I.34], [VI.2] |
G.57, G.62, G.211, Synagoge VII.6 |
|
|
Prop. XLII |
|
G.29, G.47, Synagoge VII.7 |
||
|
Prop. XLIII |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 29], [I.32], [VI.4] |
G.59, G.213, Synagoge VII.7 |
|
|
Prop. XLIV |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 2], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 29], [VI.6] |
G.215, Synagoge VII.7 |
|
|
Prop. XLV |
|
G.45, G.47, G.214, Synagoge VII.7 |
||
|
Prop. XLVI |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 2], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 29], [Data 31], [I.47], [VI.7] |
G.79, G.216, Synagoge VII.7 |
|
|
Prop. XLVII |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 2], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 29], [Data 31], [I.13], [VI.7] |
G.37, G.216, Synagoge VII.7 |
|
|
Prop. XLVIII |
|
G.25, G.59, Synagoge VII.7 |
||
|
Prop. XLIX |
|
G.25, G.31, G.59, Synagoge VII.7 |
||
|
Prop. LI |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 4], [Data 8], [Data 41], [I.32], [VI.20] |
G.59, G.232, Synagoge VII.7 |
|
|
Prop. LII |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 8], [Data 28], [Data 30], [I.37], [VI.1], [VI.4] |
G.66, G.210, G.213, Synagoge VII.7 |
|
|
Prop. LIII |
|
G.232, Synagoge VII.7 |
||
|
Prop. LIV |
|
G.221, G.231, G.232, Synagoge VII.7 |
||
|
Prop. LV |
|
G.229, G.232, Synagoge VII.7 |
||
|
Prop. LVI |
|
G.75, Synagoge VII.7 |
||
|
Prop. LVII |
|
G.205, Synagoge VII.7 |
||
|
Prop. LIX |
|
G.229, G.232, Synagoge VII.7 |
||
|
Prop. LX |
|
G.75, G.229, Synagoge VII.7 |
||
|
Prop. LXIII |
|
G.210, G.225, Synagoge VII.8 |
||
|
Prop. LXI |
|
[Data 1], [Data 2], [Data 8], [Data 52], [I.31], [I.46], [VI.1] |
G.58, G.75, G.210, Synagoge VII.8 |
|
|
Prop. LXXXIII |
|
[Data 3], [Data 4], [Data 52], [Data 55], [II.5], [VI.24], [VI.27], [VI.28] |
G.87, G.236, G.239, Synagoge VII.8 |
|
|
Prop. LXXXIV |
|
[Data 3], [Data 4], [Data 52], [Data 55], [II.6], [VI.24], [VI.29] |
G.88, G.236, G.241, Synagoge VII.8 |
|
|
Prop. LXXXII |
|
G.236, Synagoge VII.8 |
||
|
Prop. LXIX |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data 8], [Data 40], [Data 49], [I.13], [I.29], [I.31], [I.35], [VI.1] |
G.37, G.56, G.58, Synagoge VII.8 |
|
|
Prop. LXX |
|
G.229, G.232, Synagoge VII.8 |
||
|
Omitted (case of Prop. LIII) |
|
G.75, Synagoge VII.8 |
||
|
Prop. LXXIV |
|
G.35, G.59, G.94, Synagoge VII.8 |
||
|
Prop. LXXV |
|
G.35, G.59, G.95, Synagoge VII.8 |
||
|
Prop. LXII Cor. |
|
G.35, G.70, G.210, Synagoge VII.8 |
||
|
Prop. LXXVI |
|
[Data 8], [Data 40], [Data 50], [Data 66], [I.5], [I.13], [I.31], [I.32], [II.6], [VI.2], [VI.16] |
G.25, G.37, G.58, Synagoge VII.8 |
|
|
Prop. LXV |
|
G.58, G.210, G.225, Synagoge VII.9 |
||
|
Prop. LXVI |
|
[Data 8], [Data 40], [Data 68], [I.12], [I.23], [I.31], [I.35] |
G.35, G.48, G.58, Synagoge VII.9 |
|
|
Props. LXVII–LXVIII |
|
[Data 8], [Data 40], [Data 68], [I.23], [I.35], [VI.1], [VI.14], [VI.23] |
G.48, G.64, G.210, Synagoge VII.9 |
|
|
Prop. LXVIII Cor. 1 |
|
G.58, G.62, G.193, Synagoge VII.9 |
||
|
Prop. LXVIII Cor. 2 |
|
G.56, G.58, G.62, Synagoge VII.9 |
||
|
Prop. LXIV (pt. 2) |
|
[Data 8], [Data 40], [Data 56], [Data 70], [I.23], [I.35], [VI.1], [VI.14] |
G.48, G.64, G.210, Synagoge VII.9 |
|
|
Prop. LXIV (pt. 1; cf. LXIII) |
|
[Data 8], [Data 40], [Data 56], [I.23], [I.35], [VI.1], [VI.14] |
G.48, G.64, G.210, Synagoge VII.9 |
|
|
Prop. LXIV Cor. |
|
G.62, G.193, Synagoge VII.9 |
||
|
Prop. L |
|
G.35, G.59, Synagoge VII.7 |
||
|
Omitted (dup. of Prop. LIX / D.54) |
|
G.232 |
||
|
Omitted (case of Prop. LXX / D.62) |
|
G.225 |
||
|
Prop. LXXVII Cor. 1 |
|
[Data Def. 3], [Data Def. 7], [Data 40], [I.12], [III.21], [VI.4] |
G.35, G.124, G.213, Synagoge VII.9 |
|
|
Prop. LXXVIII |
|
[Data 8], [Data 66], [Data 68], [Data 79], [I.12], [I.41], [VI.4], [VI.16] |
G.35, G.70, G.213, Synagoge VII.9 |
|
|
Prop. LXXI |
|
[Data 8], [Data 24], [Data 50], [Data 54], [Data 70], [VI.17], [VI.20] |
G.228, G.232, Synagoge VII.9 |
|
|
Prop. LXXII |
|
G.189, G.195, G.205, Synagoge VII.9 |
||
|
Prop. LXXIII |
|
G.195, G.206, G.227, Synagoge VII.9 |
||
|
Prop. LXXXV |
|
G.58, Synagoge VII.10 |
||
|
Prop. LXXXVI |
|
G.37, G.58, Synagoge VII.10 |
||
|
Prop. LXXXIX (cf. LXXXVII–LXXXVIII) |
|
[Data 1], [Data 2], [Data 8], [Data 55], [Data 57], [Data 58], [Data 59], [Data 68], [II.4], [II.6], [VI.1], [VI.17], [VI.20] |
G.85, G.88, G.210, Synagoge VII.10 |
|
|
Prop. XCI |
|
[Data Def. 5], [Data 3], [Data 40], [Data 53], [III.21], [III.31] |
G.124, G.139, Synagoge VII.11 |
|
|
Prop. XCII |
|
[Data Def. 5], [Data 1], [Data 3], [Data 43], [III.21], [III.22], [III.31] |
G.124, G.125, G.139, Synagoge VII.11 |
|
|
Prop. XCIII |
|
[Data Def. 6], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 29], [III.1], [III.20] |
G.98, G.123, Synagoge VII.11 |
|
|
Prop. XCIV |
|
[Data Def. 6], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 43], [Data 53], [III.17], [III.18], [III.31] |
G.119, G.120, G.139, Synagoge VII.11 |
|
|
Prop. XCV |
|
G.119, G.144, Synagoge VII.11 |
||
|
Prop. XCVI |
|
[Data Def. 6], [Data 3], [Data 4], [Data 25], [Data 26], [Data 52], [III.1], [III.35] |
G.98, G.143, Synagoge VII.11 |
|
|
Prop. XCVII (cf. Prop. XCVIII [Stanhope]) |
|
[Data 1], [Data 52], [Data 87], [III.21], [III.26], [V.12], [V.16], [VI.3], [VI.4], [VI.16] |
G.124, G.133, G.190, Synagoge VII.11 |
|
|
Prop. XCIX (cf. Prop. C [Stewart]) |
|
[Data Def. 6], [Data 26], [Data 27], [Data 91], [Data 92], [I.4], [I.26], [I.29], [III.31], [III.35] |
G.24, G.51, G.56, Synagoge VII.11 |