§ 10. On Manifoldnesses of Any Number of Dimensions¶
A Comparative Review of Recent Researches in Geometry — § 10 & Concluding Remarks (Trans. M. W. Haskell, 1893, pp. 239–242)
We have already repeatedly laid stress on the fact that in connecting the expositions thus far with space-perception we have only been influenced by the desire to be able to develop abstract ideas more easily through dependence on graphic examples. But the considerations are in their nature independent of the concrete image, and belong to that general field of mathematical research which is designated as the theory of manifoldnesses of any dimensions, — called by Grassmann briefly “theory of extension” (Ausdehnungslehre). How the transference of the preceding development from space to the simple idea of a manifoldness is to be accomplished is obvious. It may be mentioned once more in this connection that in the abstract investigation we have the advantage over geometry of being able to choose arbitrarily the fundamental group of transformations, while in geometry a minimum group — the principal group — was given at the outset.
We will here touch, and that very briefly, only on the following three methods:
1. The Projective Method or Modern Algebra (Theory of Invariants)¶
Its group consists of the totality of linear and dualistic transformations of the variables employed to represent individual configurations in the manifoldness; it is the generalization of projective geometry. We have already noticed the application of this method in the discussion of infinitesimals in a manifoldness of one more dimension. It includes the two other methods to be mentioned, in so far as its group includes the groups upon which those methods are based.
2. The Manifoldness of Constant Curvature¶
The notion of such a manifoldness arose in Riemann's theory (1854/1867) from the more general idea of a manifoldness in which a differential expression in the variables is given. In his theory the group consists of the totality of those transformations of the variables which leave the given expression unchanged. On the other hand, the idea of a manifoldness of constant curvature presents itself when a projective measurement is based upon a given quadratic equation between the variables (Cayley, 1859; Klein, 1871). From this point of view as compared with Riemann’s the extension arises that the variables are regarded as complex; the variability can be limited to the real domain afterwards. Under this head belong the long series of investigations touched on in §§ 5, 6, 7.
3. The Plane Manifoldness¶
Riemann designates as a plane manifoldness one of constant zero curvature. Its theory is the immediate generalization of elementary geometry. Its group can, like the principal group of geometry, be separated from out the group of the projective method by supposing a configuration to remain fixed which is defined by two equations, a linear and a quadratic equation. We have then to distinguish between real and imaginary if we wish to adhere to the form in which the theory is usually presented. Under this head are to be counted, in the first place, elementary geometry itself, then for instance the recent generalizations of the ordinary theory of curvature, etc.
Concluding Remarks¶
In conclusion we will introduce two further remarks closely related to what has thus far been presented, — one with reference to the analytic form in which the ideas developed in the preceding pages are to be represented, the other marking certain problems whose investigation would appear important and fruitful in the light of the expositions here given.
Analytic geometry has often been reproached with giving preference to arbitrary elements by the introduction of the system of co-ordinates, and this objection applies equally well to every method of treating manifoldnesses in which individual configurations are characterized by the values of variables. But while this objection has been too often justified owing to the defective way in which, particularly in former times, the method of co-ordinates was manipulated, yet it disappears when the method is rationally treated. The analytical expressions arising in the investigation of a manifoldness with reference to its group must, from their meaning, be independent of the choice of the co-ordinate system; and the problem is then to clearly set forth this independence analytically. That this can be done, and how it is to be done, is shown by modern algebra, in which the abstract idea of an invariant that we have here in view has reached its clearest expression. It possesses a general and exhaustive law for constructing invariant expressions, and operates only with such expressions. This object should be kept in view in any formal (analytical) treatment, even when other groups than the projective group form the basis of the treatment [1]. For the analytical formulation should, after all, be congruent with the conceptions whether it be our purpose to use it only as a precise and perspicuous expression of the conceptions, or to penetrate by its aid into still unexplored regions.
The further problems which we wished to mention arise on comparing the views here set forth with the so-called Galois theory of equations.
In the Galois theory, as in ours, the interest centres on groups of transformations. The objects to which the transformations are applied are indeed different; there we have to do with a finite number of discrete elements, here with the infinite number of elements in a continuous manifoldness. But still the comparison may be pursued further owing to the identity of the group-idea [2], and I am the more ready to point it out here, as it will enable us to characterize the position to be awarded to certain investigations begun by Lie and myself [3] in accordance with the views here developed.
In the Galois theory, as it is presented for instance in Serret’s Cours d’Algèbre supérieure (1866) or in C. Jordan’s Traité des substitutions (1870), the real subject of investigation is the group theory or substitution theory itself, from which the theory of equations results as an application. Similarly we require a theory of transformations, a theory of the groups producible by transformations of any given characteristics. The ideas of commutativity, of similarity, etc., will find application just as in the theory of substitutions. As an application of the theory of transformations appears that treatment of a manifoldness which results from taking as a basis the groups of transformations.
In the theory of equations the first subjects to engage the attention are the symmetric functions of the coefficients, and in the next place those expressions which remain unaltered, if not under all, yet under a considerable number of permutations of the roots. In treating a manifoldness on the basis of a group our first inquiry is similarly with regard to the bodies (§ 5), viz., the configurations which remain unaltered under all the transformations of the group. But there are configurations admitting not all but some of the transformations of the group, and they are next of particular interest from the point of view of the treatment based on the group; they have distinctive characteristics. It amounts, then, to distinguishing in the sense of ordinary geometry symmetric and regular bodies, surfaces of revolution and helicoidal surfaces. If the subject be regarded from the point of view of projective geometry, and if it be further required that the transformations converting the configurations into themselves shall be commutative, we arrive at the configurations considered by Lie and myself in the article cited (Math. Ann. 4, 1871), and the general problem proposed in § 6 of that article. The determination (given in §§ 1, 3 of that article) of all groups of an infinite number of commutative linear transformations in the plane forms a part of the general theory of transformations named above [4].
Footnotes (1893 Edition)