Notes I–VII: Historical & Foundational Appendices

A Comparative Review of Recent Researches in Geometry — Author’s Appendix Notes I–VII (Trans. M. W. Haskell, 1893, pp. 242–249)

Note I: Synthetic vs. Analytic Method in Modern Geometry (1893 English)

The distinction between modern synthesis and modern analytic geometry must no longer be regarded as essential, inasmuch as both subject-matter and methods of reasoning have gradually taken a similar form in both. We choose therefore in the text as common designation of them both the term projective geometry. Although the synthetic method has more to do with space-perception and thereby imparts a rare charm to its first simple developments, the realm of space-perception is nevertheless not closed to the analytic method, and the formulae of analytic geometry can be looked upon as a precise and perspicuous statement of geometrical relations. On the other hand, the advantage to original research of a well formulated analysis should not be underestimated, — an advantage due to its moving, so to speak, in advance of the thought. But it should always be insisted that a mathematical subject is not to be considered exhausted until it has become intuitively evident, and the progress made by the aid of analysis is only a first, though a very important, step.

Note II: Division of Modern Geometry into Theories (1893 English)

When we consider, for instance, how persistently the mathematical physicist disregards the advantages afforded him in many cases by only a moderate cultivation of the projective view, and how, on the other hand, the student of projective geometry leaves untouched the rich mine of mathematical truths brought to light by the theory of the curvature of surfaces, we must regard the present state of mathematical knowledge as exceedingly incomplete and, it is to be hoped, as transitory.

Note III: On the Value of Space-Perception (1893 English)

When in the text we designated space-perception as something incidental, we meant this with regard to the purely mathematical contents of the ideas to be formulated. Space-perception has then only the value of illustration, which is to be estimated very highly from the pedagogical stand-point, it is true. A geometric model, for instance, is from this point of view very instructive and interesting.

Note IV: On Manifoldnesses of Any Number of Dimensions (1893 English)

That space, regarded as the locus of points, has only three dimensions, does not need to be discussed from the mathematical point of view; but just as little can anybody be prevented from that point of view from claiming that space really has four, or any unlimited number of dimensions, and that we are only able to perceive three. The theory of manifoldnesses, advancing as it does with the course of time more and more into the foreground of modern mathematical research, is by its nature fully independent of any such claim. But a nomenclature has become established in this theory which has indeed been derived from this idea. Instead of the elements of a manifoldness we speak of the points of a higher space, etc. The nomenclature itself has certain advantages, in that it facilitates the interpretation by calling to mind the perceptions of geometry. But it has had the unfortunate result of causing the wide-spread opinion that investigations on manifoldnesses of any number of dimensions are inseparably connected with the above-mentioned idea of the nature of space. Nothing is more unsound than this opinion. The mathematical investigations in question would, it is true, find an immediate application to geometry, if the idea were correct; but their value and purport is absolutely independent of this idea, and depends only on their own mathematical contents.

Cayley–Klein Projective Metric Inside the Absolute Ω = 0: d(A,B) = c log(A, B; I₁, I₂) I₁ A B C I₂ Absolute Ω = 0 (A, B; I₁, I₂) · (B, C; I₁, I₂) = (A, C; I₁, I₂) ⇒ d(A, B) + d(B, C) = d(A, C)

Note V: On the So-Called Non-Euclidean Geometry (1893 English)

The projective metrical geometry alluded to in the text (Cayley 1859, Klein 1871) is essentially coincident, as recent investigations have shown, with the metrical geometry which can be developed under non-acceptance of the axiom of parallels (Lobachevsky, Bolyai), and is to-day under the name of non-Euclidean geometry widely treated and discussed. The reason why this name has not been mentioned at all in the text, is closely related to the expositions given in the preceding note. With the name non-Euclidean geometry have been associated a multitude of non-mathematical ideas, which have been as zealously cherished by some as resolutely rejected by others, but with which our purely mathematical considerations have nothing to do whatever. A wish to contribute towards clearer ideas in this matter has occasioned the following explanations.

Note VI: Line Geometry as a Manifoldness of Constant Curvature (1893 English)

In combining line geometry with the projective measurement in a manifoldness of five dimensions, we must remember that the straight lines represent elements of the manifoldness which, metrically speaking, are at infinity. It then becomes necessary to consider what the value of a system of a projective measurement is for the elements at infinity; and this may here be set forth somewhat at length, in order to remove any difficulties which might else seem to stand in the way of conceiving of line geometry as a metrical geometry. We shall illustrate these expositions by the graphic example of the projective measurement based on a quadric surface.