§ 9. On the Group of All Contact-Transformations¶
A Comparative Review of Recent Researches in Geometry — § 9 (Trans. M. W. Haskell, 1893, pp. 234–239)
Particular cases of contact-transformations have been long known; Jacobi has even made use of the most general contact-transformations in analytical investigations, but an effective geometrical interpretation has only been given them by recent researches of Lie's [1]. It will therefore not be superfluous to explain here in detail what a contact-transformation is. In this we restrict ourselves, as hitherto, to point-space with its three dimensions.
By a contact-transformation is to be understood, analytically speaking, any substitution which expresses the values of the variables $x, y, z$ and their partial derivatives $\frac{dz}{dx} = p$, $\frac{dz}{dy} = q$ in terms of new variables $x', y', z', p', q'$. It is evident that such substitutions, in general, convert surfaces that are in contact into surfaces in contact, and this accounts for the name. Contact-transformations are divided into three classes (the point being taken as space-element), viz., those in which points correspond to the $\infty^3$ points (the point-transformations just considered); those converting the points into curves; lastly, those converting them into surfaces. This classification is not to be regarded as essential, inasmuch as for other $\infty^3$ space-elements, say for planes, while a division into three classes again occurs, it does not coincide with the division occurring under the assumption of points as elements.
If a point be subjected to all contact-transformations it is converted into the totality of points, curves, and surfaces. Only in their entirety, then, do points, curves, and surfaces form a body of our group. From this may be deduced the general rule that the formal treatment of a problem from the point of view of all contact-transformations (e.g., the theory of partial differential equations considered below) must be incomplete if we operate only with point- (or plane-) co-ordinates, for the very reason that the chosen space-elements do not form a body.
If, however, we wish to preserve the connection with the ordinary methods, it will not do to introduce as space-elements all the individual configurations contained in the body, as their number is $\infty^\infty$. This makes it necessary to introduce in these considerations as space-element not the point, curve, or surface, but the “surface-element,” i.e., the system of values $x, y, z, p, q$. Each contact-transformation converts every surface-element into another; the $\infty^5$ surface-elements accordingly form a body.
From this point of view, point, curve, and surface must be uniformly regarded as aggregates of surface-elements, and indeed of $\infty^2$ elements. For the surface is covered by $\infty^2$ elements, the curve is tangent to the same number, through the point pass the same number. But these aggregates of $\infty^2$ elements have another characteristic property in common. Let us designate as the united position of two consecutive surface-elements $x, y, z, p, q$ and $x + dx, y + dy, z + dz, p + dp, q + dq$ the relation defined by the equation
Thus point, curve, and surface agree in being manifoldnesses of $\infty^2$ elements, each of which is united in position with the $\infty^1$ adjoining elements. This is the common characteristic of point, curve, and surface; and this must serve as the basis of the analytical investigation, if the group of contact-transformations is to be used.
The united position of consecutive elements is an invariant relation under any contact-transformation whatever. And, conversely, contact-transformations may be defined as those substitutions of the five variables $x, y, z, p, q$, by which the relation
is converted into itself. In these investigations space is therefore to be regarded as a manifoldness of five dimensions; and this manifoldness is to be treated by taking as fundamental group the totality of the transformations of the variables which leave a certain relation between the differentials unaltered.
First of all present themselves as subjects of investigation the manifoldnesses defined by one or more equations between the variables, i.e., by partial differential equations of the first order, and systems of such equations. It will be one of the principal problems to select out of the manifoldnesses of elements satisfying given equations systems of $\infty^1$, or of $\infty^2$, elements which are all united in position with a neighboring element. A question of this kind forms the sum and substance of the problem of the solution of a partial differential equation of the first order. It can be formulated in the following way: to select from among the $\infty^4$ elements satisfying the equation all the twofold manifoldnesses of the given kind. The problem of the complete solution thus assumes the definite form: to classify in some way the $\infty^4$ elements satisfying the equation into $\infty^2$ manifoldnesses of the given kind.
It cannot be my intention to pursue this consideration of partial differential equations further; on this point I refer to Lie's articles already cited. I will only point out one thing further, that from the point of view of the contact-transformations a partial differential equation of the first order has no invariant, that every such equation can be converted into any other, and that therefore linear equations in particular have no distinctive properties. Distinctions appear only when we return to the point of view of the point-transformations.
The groups of contact-transformations, of point-transformations, finally of projective transformations, may be defined in a uniform manner which should here not be passed over [2]. Contact-transformations have already been defined as those transformations under which the united position of consecutive surface-elements is preserved. But, on the other hand, point-transformations have the characteristic property of converting consecutive line-elements which are united in position into line-elements similarly situated; and, finally, linear and dualistic transformations maintain the united position of consecutive connex-elements. By a connex-element is meant the combination of a surface-element with a line-element contained in it; consecutive connex-elements are said to be united in position when not only the point but also the line-element of one is contained in the surface-element of the other. The term connex-element (though only preliminary) has reference to the configurations recently introduced into geometry by Clebsch [3] and represented by an equation containing simultaneously a series of point-coordinates as well as a series of plane- and a series of line-coordinates whose analogues in the plane Clebsch denotes as connexes.
Footnotes (1893 Edition)