Note V: Non-Euclidean Metrics & Hilbert’s Axioms — Critical & Symbolic Notes¶
Exact Symbolic Cayley–Klein Additivity (geometor.klein.erlangen) and Sister-Corpus Concordance
Cayley–Klein Projective Metric Additivity (Note V & Note VI)¶
Klein’s Projective Model of Non-Euclidean Metric Geometry (Note V, 1871–1872). Inside a real non-degenerate Absolute conic $\Omega = 0$ (hyperbolic geometry of Lobachevsky and Bolyai), straight chords act as geodesics and every chord cuts $\Omega$ in two ideal boundary points $I_1, I_2$. Projective distance is proportional to the logarithm of the $4$-point cross-ratio $d(A, B) = c \log(A, B; I_1, I_2)$.¶
In geometor.klein.erlangen.verify_cayley_klein_additivity(), we verify exact projective metric additivity in SymPy over $\mathbb{Q}$ on the diameter $(-1, 0)$ to $(1, 0)$ of the real unit-circle Absolute $x^2 + y^2 - 1 = 0$:
Taking collinear interior points $A\!\left(-\frac{1}{2}, 0\right)$, $B\!\left(\frac{1}{5}, 0\right)$, $C\!\left(\frac{2}{3}, 0\right)$ between ideal points $I_1(-1, 0)$ and $I_2(1, 0)$ inside
geometor.model.Model:\[(A, B; I_1, I_2) = \frac{9}{2}, \qquad (B, C; I_1, I_2) = \frac{7}{2}, \qquad (A, C; I_1, I_2) = \frac{63}{4} = \frac{9}{2} \cdot \frac{7}{2}.\]Because the cross-ratio telescopes multiplicatively along every chord ($(A, B; I_1, I_2) \cdot (B, C; I_1, I_2) - (A, C; I_1, I_2) = 0$ identically), Klein’s logarithmic metric satisfies exact additivity:
\[d(A, B) + d(B, C) = c \ln\!\left(\tfrac{9}{2}\right) + c \ln\!\left(\tfrac{7}{2}\right) = c \ln\!\left(\tfrac{63}{4}\right) = d(A, C).\]
Note V’s Direct Prophecy of Hilbert’s Grundlagen (1899)¶
Look closely at paragraph 3 of Note V:
“Similar investigations could and should be performed with regard to every axiom (and not alone in geometry); an insight would thus be obtained into the mutual relation of the axioms.”
Twenty-seven years later, Klein’s Göttingen colleague David Hilbert carried out this exact program in Grundlagen der Geometrie (1899) (geometor/hilbert), constructing algebraic coordinate fields to prove the mutual independence of Incidence, Order, Congruence, Continuity/Archimedes, and Parallels! Meanwhile, Klein’s 1893 Footnote 41 directly sets the stage for Bertrand Russell's 1897 Essay on the Foundations of Geometry (geometor/bertrand-russell) and P. H. J. Hoenen's 1954 De Noetica Geometriae (geometor/hoenen).