Proposition 1: Pappus’s Parallelogram Generalization of the Pythagorean Theorem¶
Synagoge Book IV, Ch. 1 / Prop. 1 (Hultsch I, pp. 176–179) · Original English Translation from Hultsch’s Greek
Book IV opens directly (its preface having been lost in the archetype manuscript) with a striking affine generalization of Euclid's Elements I.47 and [VI.31]: neither a right angle in the base triangle nor similarity between the erected figures is required. Arbitrary parallelograms erected outward upon any two sides of any triangle sum in area to a third parallelogram erected on the remaining side, whose lateral edge is given in both magnitude and direction by the segment joining the outer intersection apex to the vertex of the triangle.
If ABC be any triangle, and upon its sides $AB, AC$ there be described any parallelograms whatever, ABDE and ACFG, and the outer sides DE and FG be produced to meet at H, and HA be joined, then the parallelograms ABDE and ACFG together are equal in area to the parallelogram BCML contained by base $BC$ and lateral edges BL, CM equal and parallel to HA. “And this theorem is far more universal than that proved in the Elements concerning squares on right-angled triangles.”
step Set out scalene triangle ABC with A $= (3, 4)$, B $= (0, 0)$, and C $= (7, 0)$, and erect arbitrary outward parallelograms ABDE (area $13$) and ACFG (area $15$).
step Produce the outer sides DE (parallel to $AB$) and FG (parallel to $AC$) until they intersect at apex H, and draw the transversal line HA across the vertex A to meet base $BC$ at J.
step Through B and C draw BL and CM equal and parallel to segment $HA$ ($L - B = M - C = A - H$), and join $LM$ with JN parallel to $HA$. Because $BL$ and $CM$ are both equal and parallel to $HA$, they are equal and parallel to one another ([I.30]), so BCML is a parallelogram ([I.33]) partitioned by JN into sub-parallelograms $BJNL$ and $JCMN$.
step Apply [I.35] (shear-invariance of parallelograms on the same base and between the same parallels) twice on the left: parallelogram ABDE equals the intermediate parallelogram $AB\text{-}HA$ on base $AB$ between parallels $AB$ and DE, which in turn equals $BJNL$ on parallel base $HA = BL$ between parallels BL and HA.
step
By the identical double shear on the right, parallelogram ACFG equals $JCMN$ between parallels HA and CM. Adding the two parts gives
Specialization to Elements I.47 (Right Triangle & Squares)¶
When $\angle BAC = 90^\circ$ in a $3$-$4$-$5$ right triangle and ABDE (area $9$) and ACFG (area $16$) are squares, the corner triangle formed at H is congruent to ABC rotated by $90^\circ$, making HA perpendicular to hypotenuse $BC$ with exact length $|HA| = |BC| = 5$. Thus BCML becomes the $5 \times 5$ hypotenuse square of area $25$ partitioned along altitude JN into Euclid’s windmill rectangles of areas $\frac{9}{5} \cdot 5 = 9$ and $\frac{16}{5} \cdot 5 = 16$: