Propositions 14–18: The Ancient Theorem on the Arbelos Circle Chain

Synagoge Book IV, Chs. 19–26 / Props. 14–18 (Hultsch I, pp. 208–232) · Original English Translation from Hultsch’s Greek

“There is set forth in the ancient geometrical inquiries a proposition of the following kind, which appears marvelous to many” (φέρεταί τις ἐν τοῖς ἀρχαίοις πρότασις τοιαύτη, Hultsch I p. 208): Suppose three semicircles be described tangent to one another upon a single straight diameter—forming the curvilinear region bounded by the three arcs which the ancients call the arbelos (ἄρβηλος, “shoemaker’s knife”)—and into the space between the three circumferences there be inscribed an endless chain of circles tangent both to the bounding semicircles and successively to one another. Then the perpendicular dropped from the center of the first circle to the base diameter equals its own diameter, that from the center of the second circle is double its diameter, that from the third is triple its diameter, and so on without end according to the natural numbers exceeding one another by unity:

\[y_n = n\,d_n = 2n\,r_n \qquad (n = 1, 2, 3, \dots).\]

After stating that the proposition remains equally valid whether the two inner semicircles lie on the same side (the arbelos proper) or embrace one another externally, Pappus establishes three preliminary tangent-circle lemmas (Props. 15–17, Hultsch I pp. 210–224):

  • Lemma 1 (Prop. 15): If two circles touch at $\Theta$ and a third circle touches both at $E$ and $P$, the chord $EP$ produced meets the line of centers on the radical tangent at $Z$ where $ZE \cdot ZP = Z\Theta^2$.

  • Lemma 2 (Prop. 16): For any single circle inscribed tangent to two nested semicircles on baseline $AC$, the square of its center’s perpendicular height satisfies a fixed rectangle relation on the base segments cut off by rays from the outer semicircle’s endpoints ([III.36]).

  • Lemma 3 (Prop. 17): If two consecutive circles centered at $K_n$ and $K_{n+1}$ touch both nested semicircles and touch each other externally at $\Theta$, then the sum of the $n$-th altitude and its diameter stands to its diameter in the exact same ratio as the $(n+1)$-th altitude stands to the $(n+1)$-th diameter:

    \[\frac{y_n + d_n}{d_n} = \frac{y_{n+1}}{d_{n+1}} \quad \Longleftrightarrow \quad \frac{y_{n+1}}{d_{n+1}} = \frac{y_n}{d_n} + 1.\]
Synagoge IV.14–18 — Pappus's Arbelos Tangent Circle Chain (y_n = n d_n) ( O0 A ): y**2 + (x - 3)**2 - 9 = 0 ( O1 A ): y**2 + (x - 2)**2 - 4 = 0 ( O2 D ): y**2 + (x - 5)**2 - 1 = 0 ( K1 X1 ): (x - 30/7)**2 + (y - 12/7)**2 - 36/49 = 0 ( K2 X2 ): (x - 3)**2 + (y - 12/5)**2 - 9/25 = 0 ( K3 X3 ): (x - 2)**2 + (y - 12/5)**2 - 4/25 = 0 ( K4 X4 ): (x - 15/11)**2 + (y - 24/11)**2 - 9/121 = 0 [ A C ]: y = 0 P3 = (2, 0) O2 = (5, 0) X1 = (36/7, 12/7) P1 = (30/7, 0) X2 = (18/5, 12/5) X3 = (12/5, 12/5) X4 = (18/11, 24/11) P4 = (15/11, 0) A = (0, 0) D = (4, 0) C = (6, 0) P2 = (3, 0) K1 = (30/7, 12/7) K2 = (3, 12/5) K3 = (2, 12/5) K4 = (15/11, 24/11) P3 O2 P1 P4 A D C P2 K1 K2 K3 K4
Let outer semicircle (O0, A) on diameter AC be divided at D into inner semicircles (O1, A) of radius $r_1$ and (O2, D) of radius $r_2$ ($R = r_1 + r_2$). Inscribe circles C1, C2, C3, C4, $\dots$ mutually tangent in the arbelos, and drop altitudes P1K1, P2K2, P3K3, P4K4 perpendicular to AC. Then for every $n \ge 1$, the altitude $y_n = |P_n K_n|$ equals $n$ times the diameter $d_n$ of circle $C_n$.
step Along baseline AC with $r_1 = 2$ and $r_2 = 1$ ($R = 3$), place A $= (0, 0)$, D $= (4, 0)$, and C $= (6, 0)$, and describe outer semicircle (O0, A) centered at O0 $= (3, 0)$ together with inner semicircles (O1, A) and (O2, D) centered at O1 $= (2, 0)$ and O2 $= (5, 0)$.
step Inscribe the base circle C1 tangent to all three semicircles (Prop. 18 base step, Hultsch I pp. 226–228). By Lemma 2, its center K1 $= \left(\frac{30}{7}, \frac{12}{7}\right)$ above foot P1 has radius $r_1^{(c)} = \frac{6}{7}$ and diameter $d_1 = \frac{12}{7}$, so altitude P1K1 satisfies $y_1 = \frac{12}{7} = 1 \cdot d_1$.
step Inscribe C2 tangent to (O0, A), (O1, A), and C1. By Lemma 3 (Prop. 17), $\frac{y_2}{d_2} = \frac{y_1 + d_1}{d_1} = 1 + 1 = 2$. Indeed K2 $= \left(3, \frac{12}{5}\right)$ has radius $r_2^{(c)} = \frac{3}{5}$, diameter $d_2 = \frac{6}{5}$, and altitude P2K2 $= \frac{12}{5} = 2\,d_2$.
step Repeat the inductive recurrence $\frac{y_{n+1}}{d_{n+1}} = \frac{y_n}{d_n} + 1$ (Hultsch I p. 228, καὶ τοῦτο συμβαῖνον ἐπὶ τὸ ἄπειρον ἀποδειχθήσεται): circle C3 at K3 $= \left(2, \frac{12}{5}\right)$ ($\Delta_3 = 15$) has diameter $d_3 = \frac{4}{5}$ and altitude P3K3 $= \frac{12}{5} = 3\,d_3$; and circle C4 at K4 $= \left(\frac{15}{11}, \frac{24}{11}\right)$ ($\Delta_4 = 22$) has diameter $d_4 = \frac{6}{11}$ and altitude P4K4 $= \frac{24}{11} = 4\,d_4$. Moreover, every center $K_n$ lies on the fixed locus ellipse with foci O1 and O0 since $|K_n O_0| + |K_n O_1| = (R - r_n) + (r_1 + r_n) = R + r_1 = 5$.

In Chapters 29–68 of Book IV (Hultsch I pp. 230–303), Pappus adds the odd-multiple corollary $y_n = (2n - 1)r_n$ when the second inner semicircle degenerates to a point at $A$, and then investigates the linear curves of antiquity—the spiral of :person:`Archimedes <archimedes>` (proving the sector-area one-third theorem), the conchoid of :person:`Nicomedes <nicomedes>`, the quadratrix of :person:`Dinostratus <dinostratus>`, and three solid hyperbola/:term:`neusis <neusis>` constructions for trisecting any rectilinear angle.