Chapter VII: Geometrical Constructions Based Upon Axioms I–V¶
Kapitel VII: Die geometrischen Konstruktionen auf Grund der Axiome I–V — David Hilbert (1899 / 1902) — §§ 36–39
In the final chapter, Hilbert returns to Euclid’s constructive postulates (Postulates 1–3), asking precisely which geometric construction problems solvable by straightedge and compass can already be executed using only Axioms I–V—implemented physically by a straightedge (Lineal) and a transferer of segments (Streckenübertrager, specialized in later editions to the fixed-unit gauge Eichmass):
§ 36 — Elementary Constructions Without Full Circles (Theorem 40): Reduces the five fundamental planar constructions—joining points/intersecting lines (Problem 1), drawing parallels (Problem 2), transferring segments (Problem 3), transferring angles (Problem 4), and dropping perpendiculars (Problem 5, solved via semicircle chords and the triangle orthocenter!)—to Problems 1 and 3 alone (Theorem 40).
§ 37 — Pythagorean Radical Criterion (Theorem 41): Proves that a construction problem is solvable by straightedge and segment-transferer if and only if the coordinates of the sought points belong to the domain $\Omega(R)$ generated from the given coordinates $R$ by $+, -, \times, \div$ and $\sqrt{\alpha^2 + \beta^2}$ (Theorem 41). Exhibits an explicit compass-constructible right triangle (hypotenuse $1$, leg $|\sqrt{2}| - 1$, second leg $\sqrt{2|\sqrt{2}| - 2}$) impossible with straightedge and segment-transferer because its conjugate $\sqrt{-2|\sqrt{2}| - 2}$ is imaginary, whereas every number in $\Omega$ is totally real!
§ 38 — Totally Positive Numbers and Sums of Squares (Theorems 42–43): Generalizes Lagrange’s / Fermat’s four-square theorem to algebraic number fields via relative quadratic field theory: every totally positive element of a number field $k$ is a sum of four squares in $k$ (Theorem 42), and every positive-definite univariate polynomial $f(x) \in \mathbb{Q}[x]$ is a quotient of two sums of squares of polynomials in $\mathbb{Q}[x]$ (Theorem 43—the direct progenitor of Hilbert’s Seventeenth Problem, 1900!).
§ 39 — Geometric Multiplicity Criterion (Theorem 44): Combines Theorems 41–43 to establish a purely geometric necessary and sufficient criterion (Theorem 44, proved for 1-parameter problems): a ruler-and-compass problem requiring $n$ minimal square roots is solvable by straightedge and segment-transferer if and only if it possesses exactly $2^n$ real solutions for all real parameter positions of the given points! Concludes that all Gauss-constructible regular polygons and Malfatti’s problem are solvable with straightedge and segment-transferer, whereas Apollonius’s circle-tangency problem is not.
Sections¶
§ 36: Geometrical Constructions by Means of a Straight-Edge and a Transferer of Segments
Suppose we have given a geometry of space, in which all of the axioms I–V are valid. For the sake of simplicity, we shall consider in this chapter a a plane geometry which is contained in this geometry of space and shall investigate the question as to what elementary geometrical constructions may be carried out in such a geometry.
§ 37: Analytical Representation of the Co-ordinates of Points Which Can Be So Constructed
Besides the elementary geometrical problems considered in § 36, there exists a long series of other problems whose solution is possible by the drawing of straight lines and the laying off of segments. In order to get a general survey of the scope of the problems which may be solved in this manner, let us take as the basis of our consideration a system of axes in rectangular co-ordinates and suppose that the co-ordinates of the points are, as usual, represented by real numbers or by functions of certain arbitrary parameters. In order to answer the question in respect to all the points capable of such a construction, we employ the following considerations.
§ 38: The Representation of Algebraic Numbers and of Integral Rational Functions as Sums of Squares
The question of the possibility of geometrical constructions by the aid of a straight-edge and a transferer of segments necessitates, for its complete treatment, particular theorems of an arithmetical and algebraic character, which, it appears to me, are themselves of interest. Since the time of Fermat, it has been known that every positive integral rational number can be represented as the sum of four squares. This theorem of Fermat permits the following remarkable generalization:
§ 39: Criterion for the Possibility of a Geometrical Construction by Means of a Straight-Edge and a Transferer of Segments
Suppose we have given a problem in geometrical construction which can be affected by means of a compass. We shall attempt to find a criterion which will enable us to decide, from the analytical nature of the problem and its solutions, whether or not the construction can be carried out by means of only a straight-edge and a transferer of segments. Our investigation will lead us to the following proposition.