f. § 36 · p. 115

§ 36: Geometrical Constructions by Means of a Straight-Edge and a Transferer of Segments

David Hilbert — The Foundations of Geometry (Authorized Translation by E. J. Townsend, 1902)

Suppose we have given a geometry of space, in which all of the axioms I–V are valid. For the sake of simplicity, we shall consider in this chapter a a plane geometry which is contained in this geometry of space and shall investigate the question as to what elementary geometrical constructions may be carried out in such a geometry.

Upon the basis of the axioms of group I, the following constructions are always possible.

Problem 1. To join two points with a straight line and to find the intersection of two straight lines, the lines not being parallel.

Axiom III renders possible the following construction:

Problem 2. Through a given point to draw a parallel to a given straight line.

By the assistance of the axioms (IV) of congruence, it is possible to lay off segments and angles; that is to say, in the given geometry we may solve the following problems:

Problem 3. To lay off from a given point upon a given straight line a given segment.

Problem 4. To lay off on a given straight line a given angle; or what is the same thing, to construct a straight line which shall cut a given straight line at a given angle.

It is impossible to make any new constructions by the addition of the axioms of groups II and V. Consequently, when we take into consideration merely the axioms of groups I–V, all of those constructions and only those are possible, which may be reduced to the problems 1–4 given above.

We will add to the fundamental problems 1–4 also the following:

Problem 5. To draw a perpendicular to a given straight line.

We see at once that this construction can be made in different ways by means of the problems 1–4.

In order to carry out the construction in problem 1, we need to make use of only a straight edge. An instrument which enables us to make the construction in problem 3, we will call a transferer of segments. We shall now show that problems 2, 4, and 5 can be reduced to the constructions in problems 1 and 3 and, consequently, all of the problems 1–5 can be completely constructed by means of a straight-edge and a transferer of segments. We arrive, then, at the following result:

Theorem 40. Those problems in geometrical construction, which may be solved by the assistance of only the axioms I–V, can always be carried out by the use of the straight-edge and the transferer of segments.

Proof. In order to reduce problem 2 to the solution of problems 1 and 3, we join the given point $P$ with any point $A$ of the given straight line and produce $PA$ to $C$, making $AC=PA$. Then, join $C$ with any other point $B$ of the given straight line and produce $CB$ to $Q$, making, $BQ=CB$. The straight line $PQ$ is the desired parallel.

We can solve problem 5 in the following manner. Let $A$ be an arbitrary point of the given straight line. Then upon this straight line, lay off in both directions from $A$ the two equal segments $AB$ and $AC$. Determine, upon any two straight lines passing through the point $A$, the points $E$ and $D$ so that the segments $AD$ and $AE$ will equal $AB$ and $AC$.

Suppose the straight lines $BD$ and $CE$ intersect in $F$ and the straight lines $BE$ and $CD$ intersect in $H$. $FH$ is then the desired perpendicular. In fact, the angles $BDC$ and $BEC$, being inscribed in a semicircle having the diameter $BC$, are both right angles, and, hence, according to the theorem relating to the point of intersection of the altitudes of a triangle, the straight lines $FH$ and $BC$ are perpendicular to each other.

Moreover, we can easily solve problem 4 simply by the drawing of straight lines and the laying off of segments. We will employ the following method which requires only the drawing of parallel lines and the erection of perpendiculars. Let $\beta$ be the angle to be laid off and $A$ its vertex. Draw through $A$ a straight line $l$ parallel to the given straight line, upon which we are to lay off the given angle $\beta$. From an arbitrary point $B$ of one side of the angle $\beta$, let fall a perpendicular upon the other side of this angle and also one upon $l$. Denote the feet of these perpendiculars by $D$ and $C$ respectively. The construction of these perpendiculars is accomplished by means of problems 2 and 5. Then, let fall from $A$ a perpendicular upon $CD$, and let its foot be denoted by $E$. According to the demonstration given in Section § 14, the angle $CAE$ equals $\beta$. Consequently, the construction in 4 is made to depend upon that of 1 and 3 and with this our proposition is demonstrated.

O A B C D P H F
**Orthocenter Perpendicular Construction with Straightedge and Segment-Transferer (§ 36).** Dropping a perpendicular from P to line AB using only a straightedge and Streckenübertrager (Eichmass) via Thales's semicircle right angles at C and D and orthocenter H.