f. § 35 · p. 112

§ 35: The Demonstration, by Means of the Theorems of Pascal and Desargues, of Any Theorem Relating to Points of Intersection

David Hilbert — The Foundations of Geometry (Authorized Translation by E. J. Townsend, 1902)

Every proposition relating to points of intersection in a plane has necessarily The form: Select, first of all, an arbitrary system of points and straight lines satisfying respectively the condition that certain ones of these points are situated on certain ones of the straight lines. If, in some known manner, we construct the straight lines joining the given points and determine the points of intersection of the given lines, we shall obtain finally a definite system of three straight lines, of which our proposition asserts that they all pass through the same point.

Suppose we now have a plane geometry in which all of the axioms I 1–2, II …, V are valid. According to $\S$ 17, pp. 53–56, we may now find, by making use of a rectangular pair of axes, for each point a corresponding pair of numbers $(x,y)$ and for each straight line a ratio of three definite numbers $(u:v:w)$. Here, the numbers $x,\ y,\ u,\ v,\ w$ are all real numbers, of which $u,\ v$ cannot both be zero. The condition showing that the given point is situated upon the given straight line, viz.:

$$ ux+vy+w=0 $$

is an equation in the ordinary sense of the word. Conversely, in case $x,\ y,\ u,\ v,\ w$ are numbers of the algebraic domain $\Omega$ of $\S$ 9, and $u,\ v$ are not both zero, we may certainly assume that each pair of numbers $(x,y)$ gives a point and that each ratio of three numbers $(u:v:w)$ gives a straight line in the geometry in question.

If, for all the points and straight lines which occur in connection with any theorem relating to intersections in a plane, we introduce the corresponding pairs and triples of numbers, then such a theorem asserts that a definite expression $A(p_1,p_2,\ldots,p_r)$ with real coefficients and depending rationally upon certain parameters $p_1,p_2,\ldots,p_r$ always vanishes as soon as we put for each of these parameters a number of the main $\Omega$ considered in $\S$ 9. We conclude from this that the expression $A(p_1,p_2,\dots,p_r)$ must also vanish identically in accordance with the laws 7–12 of $\S$ 13.

Since, according to $\S$ 32, Desargues’s theorem holds for the geometry in question, it follows that we certainly can make use of the algebra of segments introduced in $\S$ 24, and because Pascal’s theorem is equally valid in this case, the commutative law of multiplication is also. Hence, for this algebra of segments, all of the laws 7–12 of $\S$ 13 are valid.

If we take as our axes in this new algebra of segments the co-ordinate axes already used and consider the unit points $E$, $E'$ as suitably established, we see that the new algebra of segments is nothing else than the system of co-ordinates previously employed.

In order to show that, for the new algebra of segments, the expression $A(p_1,\ p_2,\ \ldots,\ p_r)$ vanishes identically, it is sufficient to apply the theorems of Pascal and Desargues. Consequently we see that:

Every proposition relative to points of intersection in the geometry in question must always, by the aid of suitably constructed auxiliary points and straight lines, turn out to be a combination of the theorems of Pascal and Desargues. Hence for the proof of the validity of a theorem relating to points of intersection, we need not have resource to the theorems of congruence.