f. § 12 · p. 34

§ 12: Independence of the Axiom of Continuity (Non-Archimedean Geometry)

David Hilbert — The Foundations of Geometry (Authorized Translation by E. J. Townsend, 1902)

In order to demonstrate the independence of the axiom of Archimedes, we must produce a geometry in which all of the axioms are fulfilled with the exception of the one in question. [1]

For this purpose, we construct a domain $\Omega(t)$ of all those algebraic functions of $t$ which may be obtained from $t$ by means of the four arithmetical operations of addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, and the fifth operation $\sqrt{1+\omega^2}$, where $\omega$ represents any function arising from the application of these five operations. The elements of $\Omega(t)$—just as was previously the case for $\Omega$—constitute an enumerable set. These five operations may all be performed without introducing imaginaries, and that in only one way. The domain $\Omega(t)$ contains, therefore, only real, single-valued functions of $t$.

Let $c$ be any function of the domain $\Omega(t)$. Since this function $c$ is an algebraic function of $t$, it can in no case vanish for more than a finite number of values of $t$, and, hence, for sufficiently large positive values of $t$, it must remain always positive or always negative.

Let us now regard the functions of the domain $\Omega(t)$ as a kind of complex numbers. In the system of complex numbers thus defined, all of the ordinary rules of operation evidently hold. Moreover, if $a$, $b$ are any two distinct numbers of this system, then $a$ is said to be greater than, or less than, $b$ (written $a>b$ or $a<b$) according as the difference $c = a-b$ is always positive or always negative for sufficiently large values of $t$. By the adoption of this convention for the numbers of our system, it is possible to arrange them according to their magnitude in a manner analogous to that employed for real numbers. We readily see also that, for this system of complex numbers, the validity of an inequality is not destroyed by adding the same or equal numbers to both members, or by multiplying both members by the same number, providing it is greater than zero.

If $n$ is any arbitrary positive integral rational number, then, for the two numbers $n$ and $t$ of the domain $\Omega (t)$, the inequality $n<t$ certainly holds; for, the difference $n-t$, considered as a function of $t$, is always negative for sufficiently large values of $t$. We express this fact in the following manner: The two numbers $l$ and $t$ of the domain $\Omega (t)$, each of which is greater than zero, possess the property that any multiple whatever of the first always remains smaller than the second.

From the complex numbers of the domain $\Omega (t)$, we now proceed to construct a geometry in exactly the same manner as in § 9, where we took as the basis of our consideration the algebraic numbers of the domain $\Omega$. We will regard a system of three numbers $(x,y,z)$ of the domain $\Omega (t)$ as defining a point, and the ratio of any four such numbers $(u:v:w:r)$, where $u$, $v$, $w$ are not all zero, as defining a plane. Finally, the existence of the equation

$$ xu + yv + zw + r = 0 $$

shall express the condition that the point $(x, y, z)$ lies in the plane $(u:v:w:r)$. Let the straight line be defined in our geometry as the totality of all the points lying simultaneously in the same two planes. If now we adopt conventions corresponding to those of § 9 concerning the arrangement of elements and the laying off of angles and of segments, we shall obtain a “non-archimedean” geometry where, as the properties of the complex number system already investigated show, all of the axioms, with the exception of that of Archimedes, are fulfilled. In fact, we can lay off successively the segment 1 upon the segment $t$ an arbitrary number of times without reaching the end point of the segment $t$, which is a contradiction to the axiom of Archimedes.

THE THEORY OF PROPORTION. [2]


Footnotes