Chapter II: The Compatibility and Mutual Independence of the Axioms

Kapitel II: Die Widerspruchslosigkeit und gegenseitige Unabhängigkeit der Axiome — David Hilbert (1899 / 1902) — §§ 9–12

Having erected the five axiom groups in Chapter I, Hilbert inaugurates model-theoretic metamathematics in Chapter II, establishing both compatibility (Widerspruchslosigkeit) and mutual independence (Unabhängigkeit) through four explicit analytic coordinate models:

  • § 9 — Relative Consistency via the Pythagorean Field $\Omega$: Constructs the countable algebraic number domain $\Omega \subset \mathbb{R}$ generated from $1$ by finite applications of $+, -, \times, \div$ and the fifth operation $\sqrt{1 + \omega^2}$. Defining points as $(x, y) \in \Omega^2$, lines as homogeneous ratios $(u : v : w)$, order via algebraic inequalities, and displacements via rational/Pythagorean orthogonal rotations, Hilbert proves that every contradiction deducible from Axioms I–V would already appear in the arithmetic of $\Omega$.

  • § 10 — Independence of the Parallel Axiom III: Proves first that existence of parallels follows from I, II, IV alone (via alternate angles, Euclid I.27), and then restricts the $\Omega$-space of § 9 to the interior of a fixed sphere equipped with projective Cayley–Klein collineations preserving the sphere, yielding a consistent Bolyai–Lobachevsky hyperbolic geometry in which I, II, IV, V hold while III fails.

  • § 11 — Independence of Congruence Axiom IV 6 (SAS): Retains ordinary points, lines, planes, and angles, but redefines segment length between $(x_1, y_1, z_1)$ and $(x_2, y_2, z_2)$ by the anisotropic norm

    $$\sqrt{(x_1 - x_2 + y_1 - y_2)^2 + (y_1 - y_2)^2 + (z_1 - z_2)^2}.$$

    Linear parameter proportionality preserves segment additivity (IV 3), so I, II, III, IV 1–5, V all hold, yet right triangles $OAC$ and $OBC$ with $O(0,0), A(1,0), B(0,1), C(\tfrac{1}{2}, \tfrac{1}{2})$ share $\angle C$, $OC$, and $AC = BC = \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}}$ while $OA = 1 \neq \sqrt{2} = OB$, falsifying SAS (Theorem 10 and IV 6).

  • § 12 — Independence of Archimedes’s Axiom V: Replaces numbers by the countable field $\Omega(t)$ of real algebraic functions of a parameter $t$ generated by $+, -, \times, \div$ and $\sqrt{1 + \omega^2}$, ordered by sign for sufficiently large $t > 0$. Since $n - t < 0$ for every positive integer $n$ as $t \to +\infty$, the segment $1$ laid off $n$ times never reaches $t$, establishing a consistent non-Archimedean geometry satisfying I–IV while violating V.

Sections

§ 9: Compatibility of the Axioms

The axioms, which we have discussed in the previous chapter and have divided into five groups, are not contradictory to one another; that is to say, it is not possible to deduce from these axioms, by any logical process of reasoning, a proposition which is contradictory to any of them. To demonstrate this, it is sufficient to construct a geometry where all of the five groups are fulfilled.

O A A' B X Y OA = OA', ∠AOB = ∠A'OB, yet AB ≠ A'B

§ 11: Independence of the Axioms of Congruence

We shall show the independence of the axioms of congruence by demonstrating that axiom IV, 6, or what amounts to the same thing, that the first theorem of congruence for triangles (theorem 10) cannot be deduced from the remaining axioms I, II, III, IV 1–5, V by any logical process of reasoning.