Chapter III: The Theory of Proportion

Kapitel III: Die Lehre von den Proportionen — David Hilbert (1899 / 1902) — §§ 13–17

Chapter III resolves one of the deepest structural problems in the history of geometry: reconstructing Euclid’s Book V–VI theory of proportion and similar triangles purely in the plane (`I 1–2, II–IV`) without the Axiom of Archimedes (`V`):

  • § 13 — Complex Number Systems: Catalogues 17 algebraic axioms (1–12 field laws, 13–16 ordered ring laws, 17 Archimedean property), framing the central question of geometric algebra: which geometric axioms correspond to which algebraic field laws?

  • § 14 — Proof of Pascal’s (Pappus’s) Theorem (Theorem 21): States the affine two-line specialization of Pascal’s hexagram—historically Pappus’s Hexagon Theorem (Synagoge VII.138–139): if $A, B, C$ and $A', B', C'$ lie on two intersecting lines through $O$ with $CB' \parallel BC'$ and $CA' \parallel AC'$, then $BA' \parallel AB'$. Using right-triangle projection operators $a = \alpha c$ and inscribed cyclic quadrilaterals ($ABCD$ on a diameter circle), Hilbert proves operator commutativity $\alpha\beta c \equiv \beta\alpha c$ and deduces Theorem 21 (adding a second direct four-circle proof).

  • § 15 — Geometric Calculus of Segments (*Streckenrechnung*): Defines segment addition $c = a + b$ by collinear juxtaposition and segment multiplication $c = ab$ on perpendicular rays from $O$ via a fixed unit segment $1$ and parallel lines. Crucially, Theorem 21 (Pascalscher Satz) immediately yields commutativity $ab = ba$ and associativity $a(bc) = (ab)c$, while congruent right triangles establish distributivity $a(b + c) = ab + ac$.

  • § 16 — Proportion and Similitude (Theorems 22–23): Defines $a : b = a' : b'$ algebraically as $ab' = ba'$, proves proportionality of corresponding sides in similar triangles (Theorem 22, first for right triangles and then generally via the incenter $S$ of the three angle bisectors!), and deduces the Fundamental Theorem of Proportion (Theorem 23, Thales’s intercept theorem Euclid VI.2).

  • § 17 — Linear Equations of Lines and Planes: Extends positive segments to signed segments ($+, 0, -$) forming an ordered commutative field, establishes rectangular coordinates $(x, y)$, proves every straight line has a linear equation $bx - ay - bc = 0$, and shows how adjoining Archimedes (V) embeds the coordinate domain into $\mathbb{R}^3$.

Sections

O A B C C' B' A'

§ 14: Demonstration of Pascal’s Theorem

In this and the following chapter, we shall take as the basis of our discussion all of the plane axioms with the exception of the axiom of Archimedes; that is to say, the axioms I, 1–2 and II–IV. In the present chapter, we propose, by aid of these axioms, to establish Euclid’s theory of proportion; that is, we shall establish it for the plane and that independently of the axiom of Archimedes.

O 1 a b ab = ba 1 a b

§ 15: An Algebra of Segments, Based Upon Pascal’s Theorem

Pascal’s theorem, which was demonstrated in the last section, puts us in a position to introduce into geometry a method of calculating with segments, in which all of the rules for calculating with real numbers remain valid without any modification.

§ 17: Equations of Straight Lines and of Planes

To the system of segments already discussed, let us now add a second system. We will distinguish the segments of the new system from those of the former one by means of a special sign, and will call them “negative” segments in contradistinction to the “positive” segments already considered. If we introduce also the segment $O$, which is determined by a single point, and make other appropriate conventions, then all of the rules deduced in § 13 for calculating with real numbers will hold equally well here for calculating with segments. We call special attention to the following particular propositions: