Props. I.26–I.33: Circles, Archimedes’ Plinthides, Annuli & Circular Segments

f. Schöne 66 · p. 66
  • Proposition I.26 (Circle, Lost Archimedean Bounds & Concentric Annulus, Schöne pp. 66–70): Hero cites Archimedes' Measurement of a Circle: the circumference of a circle exceeds thrice its diameter by less than \(\frac{1}{7}\) and more than \(\frac{10}{71}\) (\(3\frac{10}{71} < \pi < 3\frac{1}{7}\)), and the circle’s area equals the right triangle of legs \(r\) and \(C\), giving \(A_{\text{circle}} \approx \frac{11}{14} d^2\). Crucially, Hero adds a unique citation of Archimedes’ otherwise lost treatise On Plinthides and Cylinders (Περὶ πλινθίδων καὶ κυλίνδρων), recording finer bounds equivalent to:

    \[\frac{211875}{67441} < \pi < \frac{197888}{62351} \quad \text{(with } \frac{211875}{67441} \approx 3.141635\text{)}.\]

    Hero then measures the concentric circular ring (annulus, ἴτυς) between outer diameter \(D_1\) and inner diameter \(D_2\) of breadth \(w = \frac{D_1 - D_2}{2}\) by the difference-of-squares identity ([II.5]):

    \[A_{\text{itys}} = \frac{11}{14}\left(D_1^2 - D_2^2\right) = \frac{11}{14} \cdot 4w(D_2 + w).\]
  • Proposition I.27 (Infinite Geometric Progression in Ratio 4 : 1, Schöne pp. 70–72): As preparation for Archimedes’ quadrature of the parabola and exhaustion bounds on circular segments, Hero proves that if \(A, B, C, D\) are in continuous ratio \(4 : 1\), then:

    \[\frac{4}{3} A = A + B + C + D + \frac{1}{3} D \qquad \Longleftrightarrow \qquad \frac{A}{3} = B + C + D + \frac{D}{3}.\]
f. Schöne 74 · p. 74
  • Propositions I.28–I.33 (Circular Segments, Schöne pp. 72–80): For a circular segment of chord (base) \(b\) and sagitta (height) \(h\) less than a semicircle, Hero first records the two ancient approximations \(\frac{b + h}{2} \cdot h\) and \(\frac{b + h}{2} \cdot h + \frac{1}{14}\left(\frac{b}{2}\right)^2\), explains why the first fails near a semicircle while the second works well when \(b \le 3h\), and then proves (Prop. I.31) that every circular segment strictly exceeds \(\frac{4}{3}\) of the inscribed triangle of the same base and height—comparing the inscribed triangle stack with Archimedes' Quadrature of the Parabola (\(A_{\text{seg}} > \frac{2}{3} b h\)). In Prop. I.30, he reconstructs the full circle’s diameter from chord and sagitta via Euclid’s intersecting-chords theorem ([III.35]): \((d - h) h = \left(\frac{b}{2}\right)^2 \implies d = h + \frac{b^2}{4h}\).