Props. I.17–I.25: Regular Polygons (3-gon to 12-gon) & Golden Section Pentagon Lemma¶
f. Schöne 46 · p. 46In Propositions I.17–I.25, Hero systematically computes the area \(A_n\) of every regular \(n\)-gon of given side \(a\) from the equilateral triangle (\(n = 3\)) through the regular dodecagon (\(n = 12\)), expressing each ratio \(A_n : a^2\) both by an exact geometric construction and by a close rational multiplier suitable for architectural and surveying calculations.
Proposition I.17 (Equilateral Triangle, Schöne pp. 46–48): For side \(a = 10\), \(h^2 = a^2 - (\frac{a}{2})^2 = \frac{3}{4}a^2\), so \(A_3^2 = \frac{3}{16}a^4\) (dynamodynamis). Approximating \(\frac{\sqrt{3}}{4} \approx \frac{13}{30}\), Hero obtains \(A_3 \approx \frac{13}{30}a^2 = 43\frac{1}{3}\) (exact \(25\sqrt{3} \approx 43.3013\)).
Proposition I.18 & Lemma — The Regular Pentagon via Extreme and Mean Ratio (Schöne pp. 48–54; fol. 77v):
To measure the regular pentagon of side \(a = 10\), Hero inscribes it in a circle of center \(Z\) and considers the right triangle formed by the circumradius \(ZB\), the apothem \(Z\Gamma\), and the half-side \(B\Gamma = \frac{a}{2}\), whose acute central angle at \(Z\) is one-tenth of four right angles, i.e., \(\frac{2}{5}\) of a right angle (\(36^\circ\)). He isolates its fundamental golden-section property in an explicit Euclidean lemma:
Lemma (Schöne p. 50; fol. 77v): Let ABC be a right-angled triangle having a right angle at C (Hero’s \(\Gamma\) ), and at A an angle of two-fifths of a right angle ( \(36^\circ\) ). To prove that the square on the sum \((BA + A\Gamma)\) is five times the square on \(A\Gamma\):
\[(BA + A\Gamma)^2 = 5\,A\Gamma^2 \qquad \Longleftrightarrow \qquad \frac{BA + A\Gamma}{A\Gamma} = \sqrt{5}, \qquad \frac{BA}{A\Gamma} = \sqrt{5} - 1 = \frac{2}{\phi}.\]
(Diagram Mapping: A = \(A\), B = \(B\), C = \(\Gamma\), D = \(\Delta\), and G marks the golden cut on \(A\Delta\) with AG = AB = BD ).
Proof of the Lemma:
Produce AC to D so that CD = AC, and join BD.
Because right triangles \(AB\Gamma\) and \(\Delta B\Gamma\) share leg \(B\Gamma\) and have AC = CD, we have AB = BD and \(\angle AB\Gamma = \angle \Gamma B\Delta\) ([I.4]).
Since \(\angle BA\Gamma = \frac{2}{5}\) of a right angle (\(36^\circ\)), its complement \(\angle AB\Gamma\) is \(\frac{3}{5}\) of a right angle (\(54^\circ\) by [I.32]). Hence the whole apex angle \(\angle AB\Delta\) of isosceles triangle ABD is \(\frac{6}{5}\) of a right angle (\(108^\circ\)), which is the interior angle of a regular pentagon!
In a regular pentagon, the diagonal \(A\Delta\) and sides AB, BD cut one another in extreme and mean ratio ([XIII.8]), with AB (= AG via circle (AB)) equal to the greater segment of \(A\Delta\).
Since AC is half the greater segment’s whole line \(A\Delta\)—or directly by Euclid’s *Elements* XIII.1 (“If a straight line be cut in extreme and mean ratio, the square on the greater segment added to the half of the whole is five times the square on the half”)—it follows immediately that:
\[(BA + A\Gamma)^2 = 5\,A\Gamma^2. \qquad \text{Q.E.D.}\]
Approximating \(\sqrt{5} \approx \frac{9}{4}\) (since \((\frac{9}{4})^2 = \frac{81}{16} = 5\frac{1}{16}\)), Hero derives \(\frac{BA}{A\Gamma} \approx \frac{5}{4}\), whence \(\frac{B\Gamma}{A\Gamma} \approx \frac{3}{4}\) (a \(3\text{-}4\text{-}5\) triangle approximation to the \(36^\circ\text{-}54^\circ\text{-}90^\circ\) triangle!) and obtains the rational pentagon formula \(A_5 \approx \frac{5}{3}a^2\) (or more closely \(\frac{12}{7}a^2 = 171\frac{3}{7}\) vs. exact \(\frac{\sqrt{25 + 10\sqrt{5}}}{4}a^2 \approx 172.0477\)).
f. Schöne 56 · p. 56Summary of Regular Polygons in Props. I.17–I.25 (Schöne pp. 46–66):
Prop. |
Polygon (\(n\)) |
Exact Ratio \(A_n / a^2\) |
Hero’s Ratio |
Rel. Error |
|---|---|---|---|---|
I.17 |
Equilateral (\(3\)) |
\(\frac{\sqrt{3}}{4} \approx 0.43301\) |
\(\frac{13}{30} \approx 0.43333\) |
\(+0.074\%\) |
I.18 |
Pentagon (\(5\)) |
\(\frac{\sqrt{25+10\sqrt{5}}}{4} \approx 1.72048\) |
\(\frac{12}{7} \approx 1.71429\) (alt. \(\frac{5}{3}\)) |
\(-0.360\%\) |
I.19 |
Hexagon (\(6\)) |
\(\frac{3\sqrt{3}}{2} \approx 2.59808\) |
\(\frac{13}{5} = 2.60000\) |
\(+0.074\%\) |
I.20 |
Heptagon (\(7\)) |
\(\frac{7}{4}\cot\frac{\pi}{7} \approx 3.63391\) |
\(\frac{43}{12} \approx 3.58333\) (via \(a \approx r_{\text{hex}}\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}\)) |
\(-1.392\%\) |
I.21 |
Octagon (\(8\)) |
\(2(1 + \sqrt{2}) \approx 4.82843\) |
\(\frac{29}{6} \approx 4.83333\) (via \(\sqrt{2} \approx \frac{17}{12}\)) |
\(+0.102\%\) |
I.22 |
Enneagon (\(9\)) |
\(\frac{9}{4}\cot\frac{\pi}{9} \approx 6.18182\) |
\(\frac{51}{8} = 6.375\) (chord table) |
\(+3.125\%\) |
I.23 |
Decagon (\(10\)) |
\(\frac{5}{2}\sqrt{5+2\sqrt{5}} \approx 7.69421\) |
\(\frac{15}{2} = 7.500\) (via \(\mathbb{Q}(\phi)\)) |
\(-2.524\%\) |
I.24 |
Hendecagon (\(11\)) |
\(\frac{11}{4}\cot\frac{\pi}{11} \approx 9.36564\) |
\(\frac{66}{7} \approx 9.42857\) (chord table) |
\(+0.672\%\) |
I.25 |
Dodecagon (\(12\)) |
\(3(2 + \sqrt{3}) \approx 11.19615\) |
\(\frac{45}{4} = 11.250\) (via \(\sqrt{3} \approx \frac{7}{4}\)) |
\(+0.481\%\) |
Notably, for the non-constructible regular enneagon (Prop. I.22, 9-gon) and regular hendecagon (Prop. I.24, 11-gon), Hero explicitly appeals to “the treatises on chords in a circle” (ἐκ τῶν περὶ τῶν ἐν κύκλῳ εὐθειῶν)—providing vital historical testimony to pre-Ptolemaic Hellenistic chord tables descending from Hipparchus.