Prop. I.8: Synthetic Incircle Proof of Δ = √(s(s−a)(s−b)(s−c)) & Root Extraction

f. Schöne 18 · p. 18

Proposition I.8 — Enunciation & Rule on (7, 8, 9) (Schöne p. 18; fol. 70v):

“There is a universal method for finding the area (:term:`embadon`) of any triangle whatever when its three sides are given, without a perpendicular (:term:`kathetos`).”

For example, let the sides of the triangle be \(7, 8, 9\) units:

  1. Add \(7\) and \(8\) and \(9\); the result is \(24\) (perimeter).

  2. Take half of these; the result is \(12\) (\(s = 12\)).

  3. Subtract the \(7\) units: remainder \(5\) (\(s - c = 5\)). Again subtract \(8\) from \(12\): remainder \(4\) (\(s - a = 4\)). And further subtract \(9\): remainder \(3\) (\(s - b = 3\)).

  4. Multiply \(12\) by \(5\): the result is \(60\). Multiply this by \(4\): the result is \(240\). Multiply this by \(3\): the result is \(720\).

  5. Take the square root (side) of \(720\), and it will be the area of the triangle:

\[\Delta^2 = 12 \times 5 \times 4 \times 3 = 720, \qquad \Delta = \sqrt{720} = 12\sqrt{5}.\]

Hero’s Iterative Square-Root Extraction (√720 → 161/6 → 51841/1932)

Rational Iteration on 720 (Schöne pp. 18–20; fol. 70v):

Since \(720\) does not possess a rational square root (ῥητὴν πλευρὰν οὐκ ἔχουσιν), we shall extract its side within a minimal difference (μετὰ διαφόρου ἐλαχίστου) as follows:

  • Since the square nearest to \(720\) is \(729\) and has side \(x_0 = 27\), divide \(720\) by \(27\): the result is \(26\frac{2}{3}\) (\(\frac{80}{3}\)).

  • Add \(27\): the result is \(53\frac{2}{3}\) (\(\frac{161}{3}\)).

  • Take half of these: the result is \(x_1 = 26 + \frac{1}{2} + \frac{1}{3} = 26\frac{5}{6} = \frac{161}{6}\).

  • Therefore the side of \(720\) will be very nearly \(26\frac{5}{6}\). For \(26\frac{5}{6}\) multiplied by itself gives \(720\frac{1}{36}\) (\(\frac{25921}{36}\)), so that the difference (διάφορον) is the \(\frac{1}{36}\) part of a unit!

  • And if we wish the difference to become even smaller than \(\frac{1}{36}\), instead of \(729\) we shall place the \(720\frac{1}{36}\) just found, and doing the same things we shall find the resulting difference to be vastly less than \(\frac{1}{36}\) (namely \(x_2 = \frac{51841}{1932}\), whose square exceeds \(720\) by only \(\frac{1}{3{,}732{,}624}\)).

f. Schöne 20 · p. 20

The Geometric Demonstration (*Γραμμικὴ Ἀπόδειξις*, Schöne pp. 20–24, Fig. 7; fols. 70v–71v):

(Note on Diagram Labels: In the interactive figure below, Roman letters map Hero’s Greek labels as follows: A = \(A\), B = \(B\), C = \(\Gamma\), D = \(\Delta\), E = \(E\), F = \(Z\), G = \(\Theta\), H = \(H\), K = \(K\), L = \(\Lambda\), with auxiliary circumcenter M of the cyclic quadrilateral).

Hero Metrica I.8 — Synthetic Incircle & Cyclic Quadrilateral Proof on (13, 14, 15) ( H E ): (x - 6)**2 + (y - 4)**2 - 16 = 0 ( M C ): (x - 7)**2 + (y + 4)**2 - 65 = 0 [ B C ]: y = 0 [ A B ]: 12*x - 5*y = 0 [ C A ]: -12*x - 9*y + 168 = 0 [ B E ]: -12*x + 18*y = 0 [ C G ]: -56*x/5 - 112*y/5 + 784/5 = 0 [ A H ]: 8*x + y - 52 = 0 [ H J ]: x - 6 = 0 [ T U ]: -16*sqrt(3)*x + 8*sqrt(3)*y + 64*sqrt(3) = 0 [ W X ]: x = 0 [ C L ]: 8*x - 14*y - 112 = 0 / H D /: |seg| = 4 / H E /: |seg| = 4 / H F /: |seg| = 4 / B G /: |seg| = 7 / A D /: |seg| = 7 / A F /: |seg| = 7 / B D /: |seg| = 6 / B E /: |seg| = 6 / C E /: |seg| = 8 / C F /: |seg| = 8 / C G /: |seg| = 21 B = (0, 0) C = (14, 0) A = (5, 12) H = (6, 4) E = (6, 0) D = (30/13, 72/13) F = (46/5, 32/5) G = (-7, 0) K = (4, 0) L = (0, -8) M = (7, -4) B C A H E D F G K L M
  1. Incircle & Semiperimeter Rectangle: Let the given triangle be ABC, with each of AB, BC, CA given; it is required to find the area. Inscribe in the triangle the circle DEF ([IV.4]), whose center is H (X(1) in Kimberling's ETC), and join the angle bisectors AH, BH, CH and perpendicular radii HD, HE, HF ([III.18], ).

    Then the rectangle \(BC \cdot HE\) is double \(\triangle BHC\), the rectangle \(CA \cdot HF\) is double \(\triangle AHC\), and \(AB \cdot HD\) is double \(\triangle AHB\) ([I.41]). Therefore the rectangle contained by the perimeter of ABC and the inradius HE is double ABC.

    Produce CB past B to G (Hero’s \(\Theta\)) so that BG = AD ([I.3]). Because tangents from each vertex to the incircle are equal (AD = AF, BD = BE, and CE = CF by [III.17]), the extended segment CG equals half the perimeter (\(s\)):

    \[\Delta(\triangle ABC) = |CG| \cdot |HE| = s \cdot r, \qquad \Delta^2 = |CG|^2 \cdot |HE|^2.\]

    (Here Hero explicitly forms the fourth-degree product of two squares—a dynamodynamis —writing that \(|CG| \cdot |HE|\) is the square root of \(|CG|^2 \cdot |HE|^2\) ).

f. Schöne 22 · p. 22
  1. Orthogonal Auxiliary Construction & Cyclic Quadrilateral: Draw HL at right angles to CH at H, and BL at right angles to BC at B ([I.11]), meeting BC at K and each other at L (Hero’s \(\Lambda\)); join CL.

    Since both \(\angle CHL\) and \(\angle CBL\) are right angles, the quadrilateral CHBL is inscribed in a circle (CHBL) ([III.22] converse, diameter CL centered at M). Consequently the opposite angles \(\angle CHB + \angle CLB\) equal two right angles ([III.22]).

  2. Angle-Sum Reduction Around the Incenter: Around the incenter H, the three angle bisectors AH, BH, CH together with the three perpendicular radii partition the full \(360^\circ\) (\(4\) right angles) around H into three pairs of congruent right-triangle central angles, so \(\angle CHB + \angle AHD\) equals two right angles. Equating the two supplementary pairs gives:

    \[\angle AHD = \angle CLB, \qquad \angle ADH = \angle CBL = 90^\circ \implies \triangle AHD \sim \triangle CBL \quad (\text{by } \text{VI.4}).\]
  3. Proportion Chain & Right-Triangle Altitude Climax: From \(\triangle AHD \sim \triangle CBL\) and the parallelism BL \(\parallel\) HE ([I.28], yielding \(\triangle KBL \sim \triangle KEH\)), Hero chains five Euclidean ratio steps:

    \[\frac{|BC|}{|BL|} = \frac{|AD|}{|HD|} = \frac{|BG|}{|HE|} \implies \frac{|CB|}{|BG|} = \frac{|BL|}{|HE|} = \frac{|BK|}{|KE|}.\]

    Componendo ([V.18]), adding \(1\) to each side yields:

    \[\frac{|CG|}{|BG|} = \frac{|CB| + |BG|}{|BG|} = \frac{|BK| + |KE|}{|KE|} = \frac{|BE|}{|KE|}.\]

    Multiplying numerator and denominator on the left by \(|CG|\) and on the right by \(|EC|\) ([VI.1]), and applying the right-triangle altitude theorem \(|KE| \cdot |EC| = |HE|^2\) in right triangle \(\triangle KHC\) ([VI.8]):

    \[\frac{|CG|^2}{|CG| \cdot |BG|} = \frac{|BE| \cdot |EC|}{|KE| \cdot |EC|} = \frac{|BE| \cdot |EC|}{|HE|^2} \implies |CG|^2 \cdot |HE|^2 = |CG| \cdot |BG| \cdot |BE| \cdot |EC|.\]

    Since \(|CG| = s\), \(|BG| = s - a\), \(|BE| = s - b\), and \(|EC| = s - c\), each factor is given directly from the three sides, and therefore the area \(\Delta = \sqrt{s(s-a)(s-b)(s-c)}\) is given!

f. Schöne 24 · p. 24
  1. Numerical Synthesis on (13, 14, 15) (Schöne p. 24; fol. 71v): “It shall be compounded thus”: let \(AB = 13\), \(BC = 14\), \(CA = 15\). Add the three: \(42\), whose half is \(s = 21\). Subtract \(13 \to 8\); subtract \(14 \to 7\); subtract \(15 \to 6\). Multiply \(21 \times 8 \times 7 \times 6 = 7056\). Its exact rational square root is \(\Delta = 84\)—matching Proposition I.5 without computing an altitude!