Proposition 12 [ιβ΄ · Prop. V]¶
Functional Signature: Given(Mag(A + B), Mag(B + C)) -> Determined(A = C | ExceedsByGiven(A, C)) · Dependencies: [Data Def. 9], [Data 4], [C.N. 3]
Let there be three magnitudes $AB, BC, CD$, and let $AB + BC = AC$ be given, and let $BC + CD = BD$ also be given. I say that either $AB$ is equal to $CD$, or one exceeds the other by a given magnitude.
Since each of $AC$ and $BD$ is given, $AC$ and $BD$ are either equal or unequal. First, let them be equal: since $AC = BD$, subtract the common magnitude $BC$; then the remainder $AB$ is equal to the remainder $CD$ ([C.N. 3]). Next, let them be unequal, and let $AC$ be greater than $BD$: cut off $EC = BD$ from $AC$ ([Data Def. 1]); since both $AC$ and $EC$ are given, the remainder $AE$ is given ([Data 4]). Subtracting the common part $BC$ from $EC = BD$ gives $EB = CD$ ([C.N. 3]), so $AB = AE + EB$ exceeds $CD$ by the given magnitude $AE$.