De Geometricis Transmutationibus — Isoperimetric Extrema and the Sesquiquartal Radius

To Paolo dal Pozzo Toscanelli: Isoperimetric Extrema and the Sesquiquartal Radius (1445)

Omnium figurarum isoperimetrarum capacior est circulus, et minimae capacitatis triangulus. Inter has extremitates omnes aliae figurae continentur.

Of all isoperimetric figures the circle has greatest capacity, and the triangle least capacity; between these extremes all other figures are contained. — De Geometricis Transmutationibus §1

De Geometricis Transmutationibus (1445) — Quarter-Side Sesquiquarta Rectification ( A D ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (0))^2 - (1) = 0 ( A F ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (0))^2 - (1/4) = 0 ( A H ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (0))^2 - (175/256) = 0 [ A F ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (0) = 0 [ B C ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (1/2) = 0 [ C D ]: (-3/2)*x + (-sqrt(3)/2)*y + (sqrt(3)/2) = 0 [ D B ]: (3/2)*x + (-sqrt(3)/2)*y + (sqrt(3)/2) = 0 [ A H ]: (5/8)*x + (-5*sqrt(3)/16)*y + (0) = 0 D = (0, 1) B = (-sqrt(3)/2, -1/2) C = (sqrt(3)/2, -1/2) A = (0, 0) E = (-sqrt(3)/4, -1/2) F = (0, -1/2) G = (sqrt(3)/4, -1/2) H = (-5*sqrt(3)/16, -5/8) D B C A E F G H
De Geometricis Transmutationibus (1445, §§9–11) — Equilateral Triangle B–C–D Inscribed in Unit Circle A with Quarter-Point E: Ray AE Extended in 5:4 Sesquiquartal Ratio to H Yields AH = 5*sqrt(7)/16.

De Geometricis Transmutationibus (1445, §§1–11) — To Paolo dal Pozzo Toscanelli: Isoperimetric Extrema and the Sesquiquartal Radius

Original GEOMETOR Translation from the Latin · h XX, Opuscula Mathematica · Paris 1514 vol. II · Basel 1565 pp. 945–949

De Geometricis Transmutationibus (1445) — Quarter-Side Sesquiquarta Rectification ( A D ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (0))^2 - (1) = 0 ( A F ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (0))^2 - (1/4) = 0 ( A H ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (0))^2 - (175/256) = 0 [ A F ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (0) = 0 [ B C ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (1/2) = 0 [ C D ]: (-3/2)*x + (-sqrt(3)/2)*y + (sqrt(3)/2) = 0 [ D B ]: (3/2)*x + (-sqrt(3)/2)*y + (sqrt(3)/2) = 0 [ A H ]: (5/8)*x + (-5*sqrt(3)/16)*y + (0) = 0 D = (0, 1) B = (-sqrt(3)/2, -1/2) C = (sqrt(3)/2, -1/2) A = (0, 0) E = (-sqrt(3)/4, -1/2) F = (0, -1/2) G = (sqrt(3)/4, -1/2) H = (-5*sqrt(3)/16, -5/8) D B C A E F G H
De Geometricis Transmutationibus (1445, §§9–11) — Inscribed Equilateral Triangle BCD in Unit Circle A: Quarter-Point E on Side BC Extended in Sesquiquartal Ratio 5:4 Yields Isoperimetric Radius AH = (5/16) sqrt(7), Implying pi ~= (24/35) sqrt(21) ~= 3.142337.
f. DGT §1

To Paolo, son of Master Domenico, Florentine physician, most excellent and learned man: the book On Geometric Transmutations of Nicholas of Cusa, Cardinal.

f. DGT §2

Although the ancients, endowed with great genius, strove by diligent inquiry to make known to themselves and posterity many truths then hidden and achieved fruitful mastery across most of the greatest and best arts, still they did not attain everything desired in every loftier theory—the supreme Provider of the universe having foreordained this lest the power of divine intelligence within us grow sluggish, rather than being borne by keener wonder toward things hidden yet accessible to knowledge. Indeed we are stirred all the more ardently to penetrate what is obscure so that we may delight more serenely in the vigor of the mind. Now among the obstacles that have hitherto hindered those sweating over geometric speculations, one problem has remained unknown to all whose intellectual powers are recorded in the books brought to our notice: namely, establishing the equality or mutual transmutation of the straight and the curved—so much so that to nearly all who have devoted themselves to this quest after immense labors it has seemed that the road to acquiring knowledge of it is barred to us, the impossibility of the thing causing this and nature itself repelling the coincidence of so great an opposition. Judging, however, that the difficulty of this matter lay rather in narrowness of apprehension and slackening of diligence among investigators not watching with the sharpest acumen demanded by the obscurity of the task, whenever any leisure was granted me I betook myself to a new art whereby I might reach what was sought, laboring over it quite diligently for the sake of higher ends until I reduced all my meditations to an easy resolution by the formula written below. Yet because in an art so great and hitherto unknown—on which depends not only the perfection of geometric transmutation, but in which an introduction for ascending to higher realities is also figured—I ought not to trust the obscurity and smallness of my slender wit, I rightly resolved to turn to you, a most skilled judge and lover of truth, and lay open my discovery to a long-tested friend to be weighed in the balance of a most impartial arbiter. Do not cast these pages aside as crude and undigested, dearest friend, even if you are occupied with greater affairs; they are brief to read and very easy to understand. Rather, in proportion as since the years of our youth and adolescence you have unceasingly bound me in the closest knot of friendship and heartfelt embrace, apply your mind all the more carefully now to correcting this work, and suffer it not to go forth into common hands unless emended.

f. DGT §3

After nearly countless attempts by which, ever falling short, I strove to reach the proposed art, at last when I looked back to the principle I employed in On Learned Ignorance a pathway opened before me. Beyond what has already been handed down in geometry, the art I seek requires turning the curved into the straight and the straight into the curved. Since no rational proportion falls between these two, this secret must lie hidden in a certain coincidence of extremes. And since that coincidence resides in the maximum, as explained elsewhere, and the maximum here is the circle which is unknown, it is shown there that it must be sought within the minimum, which is the triangle.

f. DGT §4

Among all many-angled figures (called polygons) having equal sides (called equilateral or isopleural) and equal total perimeter (called isoperimetric), it is established that the triangular figure possesses minimal area-capacity. And since every isoperimetric polygon is the more capacious the more angles it possesses, the isoperimetric circle will be the most capacious of all figures. Yet one cannot arrive at that circle by multiplying angles, any more than one arrives at a maximum in number. No polygon, therefore, can bear a rational proportion to the isoperimetric circle.

f. DGT §5

Because the difference in area-capacity among isoperimetric figures corresponds to the difference among the radii of the circles inscribed in them, as is already known, neither the inscribed circle (which is always smaller) nor the circumscribed circle (which is always larger) will bear a rational proportion to the isoperimetric circle. Now the radii of those inscribed and circumscribed circles are maximally unequal in the triangle, successively less unequal in higher polygons, and coincident in the isoperimetric circle itself, where incircle, circumcircle, and perimeter coincide. Hence we must inquire by what art we may attain that coincidence and our goal.

f. DGT §6

Four tasks appear sufficient for the art we seek: first, given a straight line, to exhibit an equal curve; second, according to the ratio of curve to curve, to exhibit straight line to straight line; third, between given lines to assign two mean proportionals; fourth, according to the ratio of two given lines, for a third given line to exhibit a fourth proportional. The first has hitherto been unknown; the second not yet considered; the third touched upon darkly by a few; the fourth clearly explained by many. Within these four is enfolded everything needful for this transmutatory art, as I shall endeavor to show in exemplary applications once the necessary preliminaries are set down.

f. DGT §7

Everyone admits that there can exist a curved line neither greater nor smaller than a given straight line, even if not everyone affirms that it can be constructed. The circumference of some circle can therefore be neither greater nor smaller than the perimeter of a given polygon, so that the two are isoperimetric; how such a circle may be exhibited is what we investigate.

f. DGT §8

Because the circumscribed circle of an equilateral polygon is all the larger the fewer angles the polygon has, while its inscribed circle is all the smaller, no one can deny that every circle inscribed in an equilateral polygon is smaller than the isoperimetric circle and every circumscribed circle is larger. Falling between the incircle and the circumcircle, therefore, the isoperimetric circle has a radius greater than every inradius and smaller than every circumradius of any equilateral polygon of the same perimeter. After many harder methods, what we seek will become manifest by easy consequence from the following proposition:

f. DGT §9

Proposition: The radius of the circle isoperimetric to an inscribed equilateral triangle stands to the line drawn from the center of the circumscribing circle to the quarter-point of a side in the sesquiquartal ratio [5 : 4].

f. DGT §10

Let a circle be described about center a with an equilateral triangle bcd inscribed in it, and let side bc be divided into four equal parts marked by e, f, g. I say that if the line drawn from a to e is produced by one-fourth of itself so as to become ah, then ah will be the radius of the circle whose circumference equals the three sides of the triangle.

f. DGT §11

This is verified very easily as follows. Drawing the line from a to midpoint f, plainly af is the radius of the inscribed circle, which is the smallest among all incircles of isoperimetric polygons; similarly the line drawn from a to vertex b is the radius of the circumscribed circle, which is the largest among all circumcircles of isoperimetric polygons. If from a you draw a line to a point i very near f and extend it in the ratio of segment if to side bc, producing ak, manifestly ak is smaller than the radius of the isoperimetric circle, since the isoperimetric radius exceeds every inradius. Likewise if from a you draw a line to a point l near b and extend it in the ratio of segment lf to bc, producing am, clearly am is larger than the sought radius, since the sought radius is smaller than every circumradius. Between l and i, therefore, a line can be drawn from a to some intermediate point which, extended according to the ratio of the segment between that point and f to side bc, will equal the radius sought.