De Mathematicis Complementis — Inradius, Circumradius, and Archimedes’ Spiral

To Pope Nicholas V: Archimedes’ Spiral and the Convergence of Inradius and Circumradius (1453)

Prima linea est perpendicularis a centro ad latus polygoniae ducta; secunda linea est a centro ad angulum producta. Crescente numero angulorum prima et secunda linea coincidunt in radio circuli.

The first line is the perpendicular drawn from center to polygon side; the second line is drawn from center to angle. As the number of angles increases, first and second line coincide in the radius of the circle. — De Mathematicis Complementis §3

De Docta Ignorantia I.3 — Polygon Exhaustion & Incommensurability of the Circle ( O V0 ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (0))^2 - (1) = 0 [ W1 W2 ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (-1) = 0 [ W2 W3 ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (1) = 0 [ W3 W4 ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (1) = 0 [ W4 W1 ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (-1) = 0 [ O S4 ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (0) = 0 [ T1 T2 ]: (3/2)*x + (-sqrt(3)/2)*y + (sqrt(3)/2) = 0 [ T2 T3 ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (1/2) = 0 [ T3 T1 ]: (-3/2)*x + (-sqrt(3)/2)*y + (sqrt(3)/2) = 0 [ S1 S2 ]: (1)*x + (-1)*y + (1) = 0 [ S2 S3 ]: (1)*x + (1)*y + (1) = 0 [ S3 S4 ]: (-1)*x + (1)*y + (1) = 0 [ S4 S1 ]: (-1)*x + (-1)*y + (1) = 0 [ H1 H2 ]: (1/2)*x + (-sqrt(3)/2)*y + (sqrt(3)/2) = 0 [ H2 H3 ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (sqrt(3)/2) = 0 [ H3 H4 ]: (1/2)*x + (sqrt(3)/2)*y + (sqrt(3)/2) = 0 [ H4 H5 ]: (-1/2)*x + (sqrt(3)/2)*y + (sqrt(3)/2) = 0 [ H5 H6 ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (-sqrt(3)/2) = 0 [ H6 H1 ]: (-1/2)*x + (-sqrt(3)/2)*y + (sqrt(3)/2) = 0 [ O F ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (0) = 0 W1 = (1, 1) W2 = (-1, 1) W3 = (-1, -1) W4 = (1, -1) O = (0, 0) S4 = (1, 0) H1 = (0, 1) H3 = (-sqrt(3)/2, -1/2) H5 = (sqrt(3)/2, -1/2) S2 = (-1, 0) H4 = (0, -1) H2 = (-sqrt(3)/2, 1/2) H6 = (sqrt(3)/2, 1/2) F = (0, -1/2) O S4 H1 H3 H5 S2 H4 H2 H6 F
De Mathematicis Complementis (1453, §§3–10) — The First Line (Inradius) and Second Line (Circumradius) of Inscribed and Circumscribed Regular Polygons Converging to the Circular Arc.

De Mathematicis Complementis (1453, §§1–10) — To Pope Nicholas V: Archimedes’ Spiral and the Convergence of Inradius and Circumradius

Original GEOMETOR Translation from the Latin · h XX, Opuscula Mathematica · Paris 1514 vol. II · Basel 1565 pp. 1005–1010

f. DMC §1

So great is the authority of your supreme pontificate, most blessed Father Nicholas V, that by those who have attentively pondered its force it is likened to the power of squaring the round and rounding the square, as though none greater could be bestowed upon it. In you resides not only the primacy of the keys and authority over learning and the supreme hierarchy of the Church, but by universal judgment you are esteemed from your most happy genius to be like a consummate master of incomparable knowledge across all knowable things. Most magnificently have you brought it about that through your marvellous diligence all discoverable writings of Greeks and Latins alike have come with utmost accuracy to the knowledge of us all—not neglecting even geometric treatises, which by our forebears were rightly held worthy of every honor.

f. DMC §2

Indeed in recent days you placed in my hands the geometric works of great Archimedes, presented to you in Greek and translated into Latin through your zeal, which struck me as so admirable that I could study them only with the greatest diligence. As a result, through my study and toil I have added to them a certain mathematical complement which I have resolved to offer to Your Holiness; for I know you alone to be worthy that truths remaining unknown for ages should through you be laid open to all. In my judgment not only the problems customarily revolving around the long-sought quadrature of the circle, but also those that supply completion across all mathematical perfection, can be attained from these principles.

f. DMC §3

By the testimony of all who have devoted themselves to geometry, no one came closer to squaring the circle than Archimedes. Seeing that this cannot be attained unless the curved circular line is resolved into a straight line, he strove to demonstrate this art by means of the spiral. Yet because the ratio of the motion of a point moving from the center along the radius to the motion by which in the same time another point travels along the circumference—without which the spiral cannot be described—is the very ratio of radius to circumference, which is not known but is the thing sought, on this point he appears to have fallen short; for it will prove easier to square the circle than to trace the spiral and apply a tangent to it at the end of a revolution. From what Archimedes left behind, therefore, this art still remains deeply hidden. Although I had read that many labored in vain over this inquiry, I began to test whether this difficulty might reach completion through the medium of coincidences, whose power I had found supreme in other sciences; and granting the possibility universally admitted, it seemed to me that both the theory and the practice of this art can readily be won in the manner that follows.

f. DMC §4

First let it be noted that in an equilateral many-angled or polygonal figure the single point equidistant from the midpoints and endpoints of the sides is called the center; the line drawn from that center to the midpoint of a side is the radius of the inscribed circle, and let it be called the ‘first line’ [inradius]. The other line drawn from the same center to the endpoint of a side, that is, to a vertex angle, is the radius of the circumscribed circle, and let it be called the ‘second line’ [circumradius]. In every polygon these two lines differ in magnitude, and all the more so the longer its side; for the square on the second line contains the square on the first line together with the square on half the side, being the side opposite the right angle in a right triangle, as Euclid demonstrates.

f. DMC §5

Because the triangle is the first of rectilinear figures, in it the first and second lines differ maximally in magnitude. In the circle, by contrast, they coincide, since there the center stands equidistant from the circumference—the midpoint and endpoint of the side coinciding where every point is angle. In the equilateral triangle the first line is shortest and the second line longest; in the square of the same perimeter the first line is next shortest after that of the triangle and the second line next longest, and so onward in succession. Because the first line in such a square exceeds the first line in the triangle, multiplying each first line by half the common perimeter manifestly produces distinct rectangular areas equal to the respective polygons.

f. DMC §6

Consequently the excess of the area formed from the square’s first line multiplied by the semiperimeter over the area formed from the triangle’s first line multiplied by the same semiperimeter equals the excess of the square’s capacity over the triangle’s capacity; and in every polygon the excess of its first line over the first line of the isoperimetric triangle measures the excess of its capacity over the triangle’s. Now the smaller the difference between first and second lines, the greater the excess of that polygon’s first line over the triangle’s first line; and because in the circle first and second lines coincide, the excess of the isoperimetric circle’s radius over the triangle’s first line is maximal, and hence the circle’s capacity exceeds the triangle’s maximally. Thus a single straight line bent around three sides as a triangle’s perimeter, then around four sides as a square’s, and still further in a pentagon, when extended maximally so that it can be extended no further, becomes the circumference of a circle.

f. DMC §7

From this it is clear that if the triangle has minimal capacity where first and second lines differ maximally, and the circle has maximal capacity where first and second lines coincide, intermediate polygons behave proportionally. Setting the excess of the circle’s capacity over the triangle’s proportional to the difference between first and second lines in the triangle, and its excess over the square’s proportional to their difference in the square, from the excess of any higher polygon’s first line over the triangle’s together with the difference of their radial gaps one seeks the radius of the isoperimetric circle whose circumference equals the three sides of the triangle or the four sides of the square.

f. DMC §8

Once that radius is known, the quadrature of the circle is plain: multiplying the radius of that isoperimetric circle by half its perimeter yields a rectangular area neither greater nor smaller than the circular area, as Archimedes easily demonstrated; and this rectangle is converted into a square whose side is the mean proportional between the radius and the semiperimeter, found from Book VI of Euclid. Though all these steps are familiar to geometers, I wish to render them crystal clear even to readers unpracticed in mathematics. Such equilateral many-angled figures of equal perimeter are called in Greek fashion ‘isopleural and isoperimetric polygons.’

f. DMC §9

Multiplying a straight line by a straight line produces a figure of four right angles; multiplying the same line by double the length produces double the rectangle, and so on; and a straight line drawn from corner to opposite corner is the diagonal because it bisects the figure. Thus ab multiplied by bc produces rectangle abcd of four right angles, and ab multiplied by be (double bc) produces rectangle abef, double abcd, with diagonals ac and ae.

f. DMC §10

Theorem: Multiplying the first line [inradius] by half the perimeter equals the area of the regular polygon. Let abcd be a square of four right angles and equal sides, with a circle inscribed about center e touching the four sides at their midpoints. Draw ef to the point of contact on ab—this is the first line, being the inradius—and draw vertex ray eb and contact radius eg to side bd; double fb to fh, double eg to ei, close the rectangle with ih, and draw diagonal eh. From the preceding lemma triangles efb and ebh are equal, so triangle efh is half the doubled rectangle, proving that the inradius multiplied by the semiperimeter equals the polygon’s area.