De Mathematica Perfectione — Vanishing Sagitta and Intellectual Vision

To Cardinal Antonio Cerdà: Intellectual Vision of the Vanishing Sagitta and the Cusa–Snellius Law (1458)

Visio intellectualis transit supra omnem rationem discursivam, ubi minimum chordae coincidit cum minimo arcus.

Intellectual vision rises above all discursive reason to where the minimal chord coincides with the minimal arc. — De Mathematica Perfectione §2

De Docta Ignorantia I.13 — Coaxial Tangent Circle Pencil & Vanishing Sagitta ( C1 O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (1))^2 - (1) = 0 ( C2 O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (2))^2 - (4) = 0 ( C4 O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (4))^2 - (16) = 0 ( C8 O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (8))^2 - (64) = 0 [ O C8 ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (0) = 0 [ X P1 ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (-1) = 0 [ W Q1 ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (1) = 0 [ A B ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (0) = 0 [ Q1 P1 ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (-1) = 0 [ Q2 P2 ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (-2 + sqrt(3)) = 0 [ Q4 P4 ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (-4 + sqrt(15)) = 0 [ Q8 P8 ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (-8 + 3*sqrt(7)) = 0 A = (-2, 0) B = (2, 0) W = (-1, 0) X = (1, 0) C1 = (0, 1) C2 = (0, 2) O = (0, 0) P1 = (1, 1) Q1 = (-1, 1) P2 = (1, 2 - sqrt(3)) Q2 = (-1, 2 - sqrt(3)) P4 = (1, 4 - sqrt(15)) Q4 = (-1, 4 - sqrt(15)) P8 = (1, 8 - 3*sqrt(7)) Q8 = (-1, 8 - 3*sqrt(7)) A B C1 C2 O P1 Q1 P2 Q2 P4 Q4 P8 Q8
De Mathematica Perfectione (1458) — In Right Triangle abc, as Sagitta Vanishes, Arc Approximates 3*R*sin(theta) / (2*R + R*cos(theta)).

De Mathematica Perfectione (1458, Ded. & §§1–7) — To Cardinal Antonio Cerdà: Intellectual Vision of Vanishing Sagitta and the 3 : (2 + cos θ) Law

Original GEOMETOR Translation from the Latin · h XX, Opuscula Mathematica · Paris 1514 vol. II · Basel 1565 pp. 1110–1114

f. DMP Ded.

To the Most Reverend Father in Christ, Lord Antonio, Cardinal Priest of the Holy Roman Church of the title of Saint Chrysogonus: Nicholas, Cardinal of the title of Saint Peter in Chains, On Mathematical Perfection.

f. DMP §1

Your noble mind is solicitous, Most Reverend Father, to examine even the speculations of duller wits, and on an earlier occasion asked me for something new. Excused from the papal palace by a gouty foot and sitting at home for two days, I composed On Mathematical Perfection, which I send herewith in order to commend for theological inquiries the power of coincidences through an empirical trial upon mathematical problems hitherto unknown. For every knowable truth in mathematics, as I illustrate by certain examples subjoined here, is attained from that coincidence across obscure questions ever eagerly sought yet hitherto patent to none. How mathematics leads us to wholly absolute, divine, and eternal realities Your most learned Paternity—who stand at the summit of theologians—knows far better than I. I have also enclosed a brief writing of my reflections concerning the mirror and the enigma [De Beryllo], wherein if Your Most Reverend Paternity deigns to linger a little, you will straightway see whether I have rightly cast the gaze of the mind into the principle of things—matters that even the most learned shrank from committing to writing. Because such things are set forth less aptly than they are contemplated, I have not blushed to send them to Your Paternity, by whose judgment I wish to be guided, knowing that I impart not to a stranger but to a father who loves me secrets that perhaps seem more precious to me than they really are, ready to correct my estimate according to your verdict, which as a suppliant I beg you to inscribe upon these little books.

f. DMP §2

My aim is to hunt down mathematical perfection out of the coincidence of opposites. Because that perfection consists chiefly in equating straight and curved quantity, I propose to investigate the ratio of two straight lines standing to one another as a chord stands to its arc, knowing that once this ratio is in hand I possess the medium for equating curved quantity with straight. Yet since to discover these lines I must know the ratio of some chord to its arc so as to advance from it to the art, how is it possible for me to know the ratio of any given chord to its arc when between quantities so contrary no numerable ratio may fall?

f. DMP §3

I must therefore have recourse to intellectual vision, which beholds that the minimal—though unassignable—chord coincides with the minimal arc. For the smaller the chord, the smaller still is its sagitta: thus the sagitta de of chord bc is smaller than the sagitta ge of chord fh because bc is smaller than fh, and so onward in succession.

f. DMP §4

The minimal chord, therefore, than which none smaller could be given, if it could be marked out, would have zero sagitta and so would not be shorter than its arc; chord and arc would coincide there if one arrived at minimal quantity in such things. The intellect sees clearly that this is necessary, even while knowing that neither arc nor chord, being continuous magnitudes, can be unqualifiedly minimal in act or potency, since the continuum is endlessly divisible. Yet to draw forth knowledge of their ratio I look to intellectual vision and affirm that I behold where the equality of chord and arc resides: namely, in the unqualified minimum of both. From this beheld equality I proceed to seek my goal by means of a right triangle, through the proposition that follows.

f. DMP §5

Proposition: In a right triangle, let the greatest side [hypotenuse] be called the first line and serve as radius of a circle, let the least side [opposite leg] be called the second line and serve as half-chord, and let the remaining side [adjacent leg] be called the third line: then as the half-arc stands to the half-chord, so stands a line equal to three first lines to a line equal to two first lines together with one third line. That is, in right triangle abc with hypotenuse ac as first line and radius, opposite leg bc as second line and half-chord, adjacent leg ab as third line, hc as half-arc, de equal to three times ac, and fg equal to twice ac plus ab, I say that as hc stands to bc, so de stands to fg [namely θ / sin θ ≈ 3 / (2 + cos θ)].

f. DMP §6

A right triangle is all the smaller the less its first line exceeds its third line. Were a minimal right triangle given, the first line would not exceed the third, and since the second line would be minimal, serving as half-chord it would not be smaller than the half-arc, as shown above. The largest symmetric right triangle here considered occurs when the third line equals the second line, so that the second line is the half-chord of a quadrant [θ = π/4]. I affirm that some single line can be added alike to ac and to ab such that the larger sum stands to the smaller sum as half-arc hc stands to half-chord bc: for since one added line yields a greater ratio than hc : bc and another yields a lesser ratio, plainly a line can be given yielding a ratio neither greater nor lesser than hc : bc, whether chord and arc be commensurable or incommensurable.

f. DMP §7

Now whatever that added line may be, when it is likewise added to ac and ab in the minimal right triangle the proportion holds automatically, because there first and third lines coincide just as half-arc and half-chord coincide [at θ -> 0, (R + c)/(R cos θ + c) -> 1, and matching curvature fixes c = 2R]. Treating the line added in the maximal triangle as identical to that in the minimal triangle, we apply the same law across all intermediate right triangles.