Coincidence of Infinite Circle, Straight Line, Triangle & Sphere — Critical Commentary & Notes

Exact Symbolic Reconstruction, Latin Philology & Canon Reception · DI I.13–15 (1440)

De Docta Ignorantia I.13 — Coaxial Tangent Circle Pencil & Vanishing Sagitta ( C1 O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (1))^2 - (1) = 0 ( C2 O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (2))^2 - (4) = 0 ( C4 O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (4))^2 - (16) = 0 ( C8 O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (8))^2 - (64) = 0 [ O C8 ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (0) = 0 [ X P1 ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (-1) = 0 [ W Q1 ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (1) = 0 [ A B ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (0) = 0 [ Q1 P1 ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (-1) = 0 [ Q2 P2 ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (-2 + sqrt(3)) = 0 [ Q4 P4 ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (-4 + sqrt(15)) = 0 [ Q8 P8 ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (-8 + 3*sqrt(7)) = 0 A = (-2, 0) B = (2, 0) W = (-1, 0) X = (1, 0) C1 = (0, 1) C2 = (0, 2) O = (0, 0) P1 = (1, 1) Q1 = (-1, 1) P2 = (1, 2 - sqrt(3)) Q2 = (-1, 2 - sqrt(3)) P4 = (1, 4 - sqrt(15)) Q4 = (-1, 4 - sqrt(15)) P8 = (1, 8 - 3*sqrt(7)) Q8 = (-1, 8 - 3*sqrt(7)) A B C1 C2 O P1 Q1 P2 Q2 P4 Q4 P8 Q8
Book I, Chapter 13 — Tangent Circle Pencil C_1, C_2, C_4, C_8 at Origin O = (0, 0) Above Horizon Line AB (y = 0): Exact Radical Secant Sagittae at x = 1 Shrink as 1, 2 - sqrt(3), 4 - sqrt(15), 8 - 3 sqrt(7) -> 0 as Curvature Resolves into Rectitude.
De Docta Ignorantia I.14–15 — Flattening Triangles & Vanishing Rational Spread [ M A1 ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (0) = 0 [ B C ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (0) = 0 [ B A1 ]: (-1)*x + (1)*y + (-1) = 0 [ A1 C ]: (1)*x + (1)*y + (-1) = 0 [ B A2 ]: (-1/2)*x + (1)*y + (-1/2) = 0 [ A2 C ]: (1/2)*x + (1)*y + (-1/2) = 0 [ B A4 ]: (-1/4)*x + (1)*y + (-1/4) = 0 [ A4 C ]: (1/4)*x + (1)*y + (-1/4) = 0 [ B A8 ]: (-1/8)*x + (1)*y + (-1/8) = 0 [ A8 C ]: (1/8)*x + (1)*y + (-1/8) = 0 B = (-1, 0) C = (1, 0) M = (0, 0) A1 = (0, 1) A2 = (0, 1/2) A4 = (0, 1/4) A8 = (0, 1/8) B C M A1 A2 A4 A8
Book I, Chapter 14 — Flattening Isosceles Triangles T_n with Fixed Base BC = 2 and Apex A_n = (0, 1/n): Exact Rational Trigonometry Spreads s_A = 4n^2/(n^2+1)^2 -> 0 and Triple Quad Residual 16/n^2 -> 0 as T_n Resolves into Line BC.
De Docta Ignorantia I.13 — Mobius Inversion Unifying Tangent Circles & Straight Line ( S O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (-1))^2 - (1) = 0 ( C1 O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (1))^2 - (1) = 0 ( M1 O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (-1/3))^2 - (1/9) = 0 ( M2 O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (-2/5))^2 - (4/25) = 0 ( M4 O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (-4/9))^2 - (16/81) = 0 ( Minf O ): (x - (0))^2 + (y - (-1/2))^2 - (1/4) = 0 [ S Z ]: (1)*x + (0)*y + (0) = 0 [ A B ]: (0)*x + (1)*y + (0) = 0 [ S X ]: (-1)*x + (1)*y + (1) = 0 A = (-3/2, 0) B = (3/2, 0) Z = (0, 3/2) C1 = (0, 1) N1 = (0, -2/3) N2 = (0, -4/5) N4 = (0, -8/9) X = (1, 0) O = (0, 0) M1 = (0, -1/3) M2 = (0, -2/5) M4 = (0, -4/9) Minf = (0, -1/2) Xp = (1/2, -1/2) S = (0, -1) A B Z C1 N1 N2 N4 O M1 M2 M4 M∞ S
Book I, Chapters 13 & 15 — Projective-Conformal Realization via Unit-Circle Inversion at Pole S = (0, -1): Every Tangent Circle C_R Maps to a Finite Rational Circle C'_R Converging Smoothly to C'_inf at (0, -1/2), Radius 1/2—Identical to the Inverted Tangent Line AB.

I. Exact Symbolic Geometry of the Tangent Circle Pencil (DI I.13)

Let circles \(C_R\) of radius \(R > 0\) be centered at \((0, R)\) tangent to line \(y = 0\) at the origin \((0, 0)\). Along the vertical secant \(x = 1\):

\[h(1, R) = R - \sqrt{R^2 - 1} = \frac{1}{R + \sqrt{R^2 - 1}}.\]

Across the harmonic sequence \(R \in \{1, 2, 4, 8\}\):

  • \(R = 1\): \(h = 1\)

  • \(R = 2\): \(h = 2 - \sqrt{3} \approx 0.267949\)

  • \(R = 4\): \(h = 4 - \sqrt{15} \approx 0.129171\)

  • \(R = 8\): \(h = 8 - 3\sqrt{7} \approx 0.062996\)

In the limit \(R \to \infty\), \(h \to 0\) and curvature \(\kappa = 1/R \to 0\). Under unit-circle inversion at pole \(S = (0, -1)\), the unbounded tangent pencil maps to a compact family of rational circles centered at \(\left(0, -\frac{R}{2R+1}\right)\) with radii \(\frac{R}{2R+1}\), whose limit circle at \(R \to \infty\) is centered at \(\left(0, -\frac{1}{2}\right)\) with radius \(\frac{1}{2}\)—the exact inverse of the horizon line \(y = 0\).

II. Klibansky’s Archival Restorations in Rotta (1913)

Inspection of Raymond Klibansky’s personal annotated copy of Rotta (1913) at McGill University Library reveals two critical omissions restored in this digital edition:

  • `DI I.13 §2` (Rotta p. 28): Rotta jumped by homeoteleuton from the first occurrence of curvitate recedit to the second, omitting et ille plus a curvitate recedit quam arcus gh adhuc minoris circuli.

  • `DI I.14 §3` (Rotta p. 31): Rotta printed ut b d c, et superficies minor, accidentally dropping tanto minus vincunt lineae bd et dc lineam bc between ut bdc and et superficies minor.

IV. Executable Symbolic Verification

In accordance with GEOMETOR’s strict content/code separation for historical editions, executable geometor.model SymPy constructions, Rational Trigonometry proofs, and series-error audits for Coincidence of Infinite Circle, Straight Line, Triangle & Sphere live in src/geometor/cusa/ and the companion walkthrough Demos.